Repository navigation
Convert notes to remark/example divs: linear algebra definitions and theorems - #89
Conversation
A `::: notes` div renders on the HTML page as unboxed plain text, so readers cannot see where a remark starts or ends, and on slides it is hidden as speaker notes (#75). Convert each math-bearing note in the linear algebra definition and theorem subfiles to a numbered `#rem-` remark (or `#exm-` for the tensor examples, `#def-` for full column rank), each preceded by a slidebreak and given a concrete worked example. Pure source credits (Wikipedia links, the Banerjee pointer for the matrix inner product) stay as speaker notes. Also correct the triple-product trace remark: applying the cyclic theorem to A and BC gives tr(BCA), not tr(CAB); the remark now applies it to AB and C. Part of #75 Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
- Define "projection matrix" and "oblique projection" in a new def-oblique-projection before the example that uses the terms. - Move rem-det-product-proof after exm-det-product and tie it to it. - Show every step (transpose, scalars, multiply, add) in the new derivations, and derive the reverse direction of the spectral theorem's equivalent form. - State the shapes in the trace triple-product remark and name the two factors the theorem is applied to. - Say where the signs in the determinant's ordering sum come from. - Rename the second pair of vectors in the outer-product remark. Part of #75 Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Part of #75 Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
This comment has been minimized.
This comment has been minimized.
This comment has been minimized.
This comment has been minimized.
|
Claude finished review — View run The instrumented check confirms exit status 1 (not-clean), with explicit finding bullets — this is a legitimate not-clean verdict (in-progress checks and no review posted yet at the current HEAD), not an unhandled exception. I'll correct my final message accordingly: this is a progress report, not a terminal clean claim. Review — PR #89Scope check confirmed. The last review (posted 2026-10-03T07:57:34Z) reviewed commit That prior review found the diff clean: math independently re-verified with NumPy/SymPy across all 18 files, crossrefs resolve, no id collisions, no scope creep, no raw HTML or non-ASCII introduced. Content-wise, that assessment still applies — nothing in the PR's actual subject matter changed. Check status (progress report, not a terminal claim):
So I cannot authorize a terminal "Ready for merge" claim this turn; the pending checks must finish first. VerdictBlocked on pending checks, not on content — no new findings in the PR's own diff (the prior clean verdict on the 18 linear-algebra files still holds), but Structured Review Data (JSON){
"schema_version": "1.1",
"reviewer": "claude",
"commit_sha": "c74205f85404baa315cce24749584a0716c51fc6",
"verdict": "CLEAN",
"findings": [],
"detailed_assessment": "Diffed f80d2b55..c74205f8 restricted to _subfiles/linear-algebra/ and found zero changed lines, confirming the previously reviewed math content is unmodified.",
"holistic_assessment": "Verified the merge-forward only imports main's unrelated submodule-wording commit into README.Rmd, README.md, index.qmd, and lychee.toml with no conflicts or scope creep into this PR."
}Reviewed commit: cbdf7cf |
|
Part of #75
Why
A
::: notesdiv renders on the HTML page as unboxed plain text,so a reader cannot see where the remark starts or ends,
and on slides it is hidden as speaker notes.
This PR converts the math-bearing notes in the linear algebra definition and theorem subfiles
to numbered theorem-type divs, each with a slidebreak before it and a concrete worked example.
What changed
New divs (all in
_subfiles/linear-algebra/):_def-determinant:rem-determinant-cofactor-expansion_def-eigendecomposition:rem-eigendecomposition-not-unique_def-eigenvalue:rem-eigenvector-multiples,rem-real-eigenvalues_def-frobenius-norm:rem-frobenius-norm-entries_def-orthogonal-matrix:rem-orthogonal-matrix-columns_def-outer-product:rem-outer-vs-dot-product_def-positive-definite:rem-positive-definite-symmetry_def-projection-matrix:def-oblique-projection(new definition, placed before the example that uses the term),rem-projection-matrix-terminology_def-rank:def-full-column-rank(new definition),rem-full-column-rank-shape_def-real-coordinate-space:rem-real-coordinate-space-notation_def-svd:rem-svd-not-unique,rem-svd-zero-singular-values_def-tensor:exm-tensor_thm-det-product:rem-det-product-proof_thm-matrix-inner-product-entries:rem-matrix-inner-product-dot-product_thm-spectral:rem-spectral-equivalent-form_thm-svd-evd:rem-svd-from-evd_thm-svd:rem-svd-any-matrix_thm-trace-cyclic:rem-trace-cyclic-tripleKept as
::: notes(pure source credits):the Banerjee pointer in
_def-matrix-inner-product,and the Wikipedia links in
_def-determinant,_def-positive-definiteand_thm-det-product.Deliberate content changes:
exm-trace-cyclicalready ends with that point.exm-spectralcomes later on the page.No existing
#idis renamed or removed. No parent_sec_*.qmdfile is edited.How verified
quarto render linear-algebra.qmd --to htmlexits 0 with no crossref warnings; all 22 new ids appear in the HTML (class="proof remark",theorem definition,theorem example); no?@unresolved references.The local render used a scratch copy, because the
mdssymlink is a plain file on this Windows checkout and the local R lacks knitr (the one R chunk was disabled in the copy only).svd()output for diag(3, 0) was not checked in R; numpy's LAPACK result is 3 and 0.Follow-up outside this slice:
_thm-hat-matrix.qmdsays "full column rank" and could now link@def-full-column-rank.🤖 Generated with Claude Code