Skip to content

Unable To Save Backup #2371

Closed
Closed

Description

@LavenderAndChamomile

Describe the bug

When I go to Backup, then Save To XML File, no window pops up asking where to save my file.

Area of issue

Installation/Other

To reproduce

Click on Backup
Then click on Save To XML

Expected behavior

Click on Backup
Then click on Save To XML
A window should open, showing you where you would like to save your file

Open-Shell version

4.4.169

Windows version

25H2, OS Build 26200.7309

Additional context

I tried to save my XML settings, and they're not working as intended.

Activity

  1. wsmyth1 commented on Dec 11, 2025

    @wsmyth1

    I have the same error when I go to restore my settings. I click on "Load from XML," nothing happens. I expect File Explorer panel to open to specify file.

    Open-shell version
    4.4.169

    Windows 11
    22H2 26200.7462.

  2. 01BastiBasti01 commented on Dec 14, 2025

    @01BastiBasti01

    Stand Heute 14.12.2025 Win11Pro 25H2 Open-Shell 4.4.196

    Der ExplorerPatcher von [Valinet] löst das Problem.
    Nach der Installation werden im Startmenü und der Taskleiste Standard Einstellungen auf Win10 zurückgestellt. was aber nach Wünschen Eingestellt werden kann
    Anscheinend auch das Dialog Feld, Das Open-Shell Benutzt um Einstellungen Laden / Speichern zu können. Und Symbole zu Verändern.

    ExplorerPatcher
    https://github.com/valinet/ExplorerPatcher/releases/tag/26100.4946.69.6_7384790

    Valinet
    https://github.com/valinet

  3. kalman7g commented on Dec 14, 2025

    @kalman7g

    Classic Explorer Bar option missing #2365 resolution fixed this issue for me.
    I submitted this bug back in September

  4. kiroubel-girma commented on Jan 12, 2026

    @kiroubel-girma

    Yes, this needs to be fixed: window (file explorer) does not open.
    Until then use the command line as a workaround:
    StartMenu.exe -backup <xml file> (save the start menu settings)
    StartMenu.exe -xml <xml file> (restore the start menu settings)

  5. Mah-Nuh commented on Jan 13, 2026

    @Mah-Nuh

    Hello kiroubel-girma,

    When I try to use the command line it get a "Command line syntax in not correct" reply. Can you please help ? I tried giving the file path, no success. Thanks !

  6. kiroubel-girma commented on Jan 14, 2026

    @kiroubel-girma

    Maybe you have a space in the path ? Put path between quotes in that case or use auto-completion

    C:\>cd "C:\Program Files\Open-Shell"
    C:\Program Files\Open-Shell>StartMenu.exe -backup "C:\temp\My backup.xml"
    C:\Program Files\Open-Shell>StartMenu.exe -xml  "C:\temp\My backup.xml"
    
    
  7. ConsciousBob commented on Jan 31, 2026

    @ConsciousBob

    [01BastiBasti01] Wrote:

    Stand Heute 14.12.2025 Win11Pro 25H2 Open-Shell 4.4.196

    Der ExplorerPatcher von [Valinet] löst das Problem. Nach der Installation werden im Startmenü und der Taskleiste Standard Einstellungen auf Win10 zurückgestellt. was aber nach Wünschen Eingestellt werden kann Anscheinend auch das Dialog Feld, Das Open-Shell Benutzt um Einstellungen Laden / Speichern zu können. Und Symbole zu Verändern.

    ExplorerPatcher https://github.com/valinet/ExplorerPatcher/releases/tag/26100.4946.69.6_7384790

    Valinet https://github.com/valinet
    ....................................
    English Translation:
    As of today, Dec 14th 2025 Win11 Pro 25H2 Open-Shell 4.4.196 [Valinet]'s ExplorerPatcher solves the problem. After installation, default settings are reset to Win10 in the Start menu and taskbar. but which can be adjusted according to your wishes

    *** Apparently also the dialog box that uses open-shell to load/save settings. And to change symbols.
    ..................................

    Yes, installing the ep patcher does allow Open Shell Menu Settings to be backedup; however, I noticed it broke my Taskbar and System Tray settings, it ungrouped my SystemTray icons and placed them on the Taskbar, and unable to regroup.

    • Note: When installing the ep patcher my Windows 11 System Tray grouping disappeared and all icons went to the Taskbar. and now UNABLE to re-group those icons and the Taskbar function doesn't work the same (Taskbar Settings > Personalization > Taskbar > Taskbar behavior). Apparently it breaks some components of the Taskbar and System Tray. I had to uninstall ep patcher, but ep patcher does fix the v4.4.196 Open Shell issue of not being able to Backup Menu Settings.

    I uninstalled ep patcher and I got my System Tray and Taskbar functionality back, but now unable to Backup Open Shell Menu Settings.

    So by using these specific Command Prompt (not PowerShell commands) as mentioned already here by [kiroubel-girma]. We can back up Menu Settings, and even Explorer and IE settings, using the following commands in Command Prompt:

    Note:
    -backup is for backing up the file
    -xml is for restoring the file

    cd "C:\Program Files\Open-Shell"
    StartMenu.exe -backup "D:\Temp\Menu Settings.xml"
    StartMenu.exe -xml "D:\Temp\Menu Settings.xml"
    ...........................
    cd "C:\Program Files\Open-Shell"
    ClassicExplorerSettings.exe -backup "D:\Temp\Explorer Settings.xml"
    ClassicExplorerSettings.exe -xml "D:\Temp\Explorer Settings.xml"
    .............
    cd "C:\Program Files\Open-Shell"
    ClassicIE_64.exe -backup "D:\Temp\IE Settings.xml"
    ClassicIE_64.exe -xml "D:\Temp\IE Settings.xml"
    .................................................................

    FOR POWERSHELL USE THESE COMMANDS <<<

    Using Windows PowerShell (v5.x) or Powershell 7 (v7.x)

    • These commands assume the target folder is D:\Temp (change D:\Temp target as needed)

    Working commands for PowerShell 5 and 7

    From ANY directory:
    & "C:\Program Files\Open-Shell\StartMenu.exe" -backup "D:\Temp\Menu Settings.xml"
    & "C:\Program Files\Open-Shell\StartMenu.exe" -xml "D:\Temp\Menu Settings.xml"

    & "C:\Program Files\Open-Shell\StartMenu.exe" -backup "D:\Temp\Explorer Settings.xml"
    & "C:\Program Files\Open-Shell\StartMenu.exe" -xml "D:\Temp\Explorer Settings.xml"

    & "C:\Program Files\Open-Shell\StartMenu.exe" -backup "D:\Temp\IE Settings.xml"
    & "C:\Program Files\Open-Shell\StartMenu.exe" -xml "D:\Temp\IE Settings.xml"
    .............
    From inside the Open‑Shell folder:
    cd "C:\Program Files\Open-Shell"

    .\StartMenu.exe -backup "D:\Temp\Menu Settings.xml"
    .\StartMenu.exe -xml "D:\Temp\Menu Settings.xml"

    .\StartMenu.exe -backup "D:\Temp\Explorer Settings.xml"
    .\StartMenu.exe -xml "D:\Temp\Explorer Settings.xml"

    .\StartMenu.exe -backup "D:\Temp\IE Settings.xml"
    .\StartMenu.exe -xml "D:\Temp\IE Settings.xml"

  8. Mah-Nuh commented on Feb 2, 2026

    @Mah-Nuh

    Hello,

    I re-tried Command Prompt as suggested by [kiroubel-girma], but still couldn't seem to get it working. Then I also checked out [ConsciousBob] suggestion about the Valinet ExplorerPatcher, but that sounds too iffy (listed downsides and side effcts I found are discourageing). Then, in #2299 I found a simple method which suggests to... simply hover the mouse over the Windows Start button after clicking the Backup button, and yes, the dialog box appears, it's wicked-simple – and adopted !

  9. ConsciousBob commented on Feb 2, 2026

    @ConsciousBob

    Hello,

    I re-tried Command Prompt as suggested by [kiroubel-girma], but still couldn't seem to get it working. Then I also checked out [ConsciousBob] suggestion about the Valinet ExplorerPatcher, but that sounds too iffy (listed downsides and side effcts I found are discourageing). Then, in #2299 I found a simple method which suggests to... simply hover the mouse over the Windows Start button after clicking the Backup button, and yes, the dialog box appears, it's wicked-simple – and adopted !

    Thanks for sharing such an obscure feature, which is Interesting. I just tried that, and yes, the dialog box comes up, but I'm unable to change the location (C:\Windows\System32) and unable to save the file as I get a Permissions restriction and am asked to save to Documents, but it never saves it. Windows 11 25H2

    Image

  10. bonzibudd commented on Feb 2, 2026

    @bonzibudd
    Member

    I can replicate this on 25H2 along with followup by @ConsciousBob

  11. Mah-Nuh commented on Feb 3, 2026

    @Mah-Nuh

    Hello,

    Sorry, I should've added that you must type the path/filename in the "File name" box. I personnally save to a local destination on my D:\ drive, so it looks like something like this :

    "D:\MyFolder\OpenShell\Menu Settings.xml"

    Of course, it would be nice if there were a fix in a new release of Open Shell, but until then, I think this is the easiest workaround for this issue.

  12. DrR0Ck commented on Feb 6, 2026

    @DrR0Ck

    This is an issue for me as of 4.4.197 installation. Exactly as described above; no dialog box unless hovering over the start button, and not able to navigate in the save file box when/if it does open. Windows 25H2 installed. Also using Windhawk (FWIW).

  13. RogerYao-Dev commented on Mar 4, 2026

    @RogerYao-Dev
  14. added a commit that references this issue on May 12, 2026
    ddca898
  15. added a commit that references this issue on May 12, 2026
    b207064
Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment

Metadata

Metadata

Assignees

No one assigned

    Labels

    BugSomething isn't working right.

    Type

    No type

    Projects

    No projects

      Milestone

      No milestone

      Relationships

      None yet

      Development

      No branches or pull requests

      Issue actions