Skip to content

feat: preserve Rheon v2 controls through Data, Pipeline and Runs - #43

Draft
MrScripty wants to merge 1 commit into
plan/rheon-v2-readiness-20261013from
feature/rheon-v2-consumer-20261013
Draft

MrScripty wants to merge 1 commit into
plan/rheon-v2-readiness-20261013from
feature/rheon-v2-consumer-20261013

Conversation

@MrScripty

@MrScripty MrScripty commented Oct 13, 2026 •

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Owner

Integration disposition — 2026-10-14

Current reconciliation (2026-10-14): the exact original archive still fails supported Library transfer because archive-host DNS cannot resolve. No original bytes were installed or substitute producer/model run performed. Actual v2 V2/V4/V5 remain pending. Independent generic science/storage is now delivered by merged PR56; this blocker does not hold those features. The original branch and all authored-v2 assertions remain intact.

Original source and qualification record follows:

Rheon producer-v2 trajectories now retain their original run.json, frames.jsonl and controls.json through single/batch import, compact inspection, explicit human review, frozen releases, editable validation/export Pipeline and durable Runs. Explicit version dispatch rejects missing controls, version/file mixtures and malformed interval bindings before persistence. Existing v1 bytes, metadata and completed results remain unchanged.

The implementation pins the merged producer controls reader and its numerical-reader version independently from retained v1, reuses immutable storage and the existing supervisor, and adds no schema change or simulator execution. Review identified a single-import JSON boundary gap; both routes now share strict decoding with a real HTTP regression.

Qualification limit: v2 positive and negative fixtures are explicitly authored. The recorded actual PR32 packet exists, but original frames and handoff receipt remain unavailable locally after supported Library transfer failed. Actual-packet acceptance remains blocked; no fabricated receipt or substitute producer run. A8 real-model positive qualification also remains open: current read-only inventory found no compatible available runtime/model endpoint. No model downloads or general 3D training expansion.

Validation so far: focused backend/HTTP/release and PostgreSQL graph/run/backup/restore tests pass; source pins and complete v1 prepared identities match; a genuine pre-v2 cafe533 completed v1 Run reopens with identical record, graph, report, artifact manifest and release. All Python compilation/static JS/controller suites pass. Both recorded-v1 and authored-v2 offline browser workflows pass. Independent source review has no remaining findings. Full local discovery passed 633 tests in 473.811s (two optional base-interpreter skips separately covered by 20 native-reader tests, zero skips). The improved authored-v2 browser receipt is clean-head 51bec9e and explicitly denies actual-packet acceptance. Final exact head 51bec9ea89f03357473aca0d40f2fa8251598a25 passed lifecycle CI 120/120 steps and workspace-ui 14/14 steps, with zero failed or skipped steps. The owned disposable PostgreSQL fixture is stopped; the clean worktree is retained for draft review.

Stacked on #42. PR38–42 unchanged. No merge or deployment.

Implementation evidence and remaining gates · Canonical plan

Current retrieval check (2026-10-13): supported Library materialization resolved the exact73722-byte original archive, but the archive host fails DNS resolution (gaierrorErrno-3). Current supported helper returneddownloadfailed; no original bytes were installed and no transfer bypass was used. Safe failure receiptSHA8332ed5e3926fe1bc1c5174f0b78e4aaee8735100fe575f163632c851270ea7d retained in the task workspace. Actual-packet acceptance and merge remain blocked.

@coderabbitai

coderabbitai Bot commented Oct 13, 2026

Copy link
Copy Markdown

Important

Draft PR not reviewed

Draft PRs are not automatically reviewed by default.

  • Trigger a manual review

To automatically review draft PRs, update your CodeRabbit configuration:

reviews:
  auto_review:
    drafts: true
  • Autofix · Keep fixing CodeRabbit findings and required CI, and resolving merge conflicts

Thanks for using CodeRabbit! It's free for OSS, and your support helps us grow. If you like it, consider giving us a shout-out.

❤️ Share

Comment @coderabbitai help to get the list of available commands.

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Owner Author

Disposition (2026-10-21): preserve this draft at 51bec9ea89f03357473aca0d40f2fa8251598a25. Independent GPT-6.1 Sol High review confirms valuable controls-v2 implementation/tests/source evidence remain absent from main (11 changed paths, including both pinned controls validators). PR56, merge 61b0727123f93ce8e7bc6f25e83796bdb1e8d38a, retained the independent generic work; it does not replace this v2 capability. README v2 guidance was reviewed separately and remains with this deferred implementation rather than being advertised as shipped.

Exact-head lifecycle38391176382 and UI38391176388 passed. Those authored-fixture passes do not satisfy actual-packet V2/V4/V5. Original native packet Rheon-PR32-actual-producer-v2-020437fa-compact-packet.zip (73,722 bytes, SHA256 66a0f6d4e993b4be19df51ac39944bdb8b937078aa058218a849fef9bc6ddb2e) still lacks locally verified original frames and handoff receipt. Recorded frames: 518,951 bytes, SHA256 1f0cb462f6d145cdaca62a11d180c1bbcb0da6f8a7dae5369faf0be8f2dcdd28. Supported transfer previously failed; no substitute producer run or transfer bypass is admitted.

Unblock by supplying the original packet through supported retrieval, verifying all recorded identities/receipt and running the specified pinned-reader/actual consumer qualifications, then reviewing integration against current main. Broader A8 positive real-model qualification remains separately unavailable without an existing legitimate compatible endpoint or explicit provisioning authorization. Branch, original failures and all v2 assertions remain preserved. No model/hardware/scientific acceptance is inferred.

Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment

Labels

None yet

Projects

None yet

Development

Successfully merging this pull request may close these issues.

1 participant