Skip to content
This repository was archived by the owner on Nov 6, 2023. It is now read-only.

New toolbar icons for Firefox and Chrome/ium - #2882

Closed
snwh wants to merge 1 commit into
EFForg:masterfrom
snwh:master
Closed

snwh wants to merge 1 commit into
EFForg:masterfrom
snwh:master

Conversation

@snwh

@snwh snwh commented Sep 12, 2015

Copy link
Copy Markdown

I use https-everywhere on Firefox and Chrome, however the toolbar icons aren't the greatest or don't fit in, so I'd thought I'd design and propose some.

Proposed example:
https-everywhere-toolbars

@semenko

semenko commented Sep 12, 2015

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Contributor

Whoa, I like these a lot! 💯

@snwh

snwh commented Sep 13, 2015

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Author

@semenko thanks. 😄

@semenko

semenko commented Sep 13, 2015

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Contributor

FYI, the EFF folks are pretty busy with the https://letsencrypt.org/ launch.

(This might not get much discussion for a month or so.)

@snwh

snwh commented Sep 13, 2015

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Author

@semenko no worries. I'm patient.

@J0WI

J0WI commented Sep 13, 2015

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Contributor

Would it be possible/better to use a single SVG instead of multiple PNGs?

@snwh

snwh commented Sep 13, 2015

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Author

@J0WI it is possible, I wouldn't say better. These are rendered from an SVG, but if I recall correctly don't think extensions support SVG files for icons.

@jsha

jsha commented Sep 13, 2015

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Member

@snwh: Thanks for designing these! As it happens, I was thinking the same thing, and had asked EFF's in-house graphic designer, Hugh D'Andrade, for a new logo for HTTPS Everywhere. The design he came up with wound up being very similar to yours: a larger circle, with clearer arrows pointing out towards the four corners. The main difference: I asked Hugh for an alternative to the lock icon. Since the lock in the URL bar is intended as an indicator of the security state, I felt like it would be confusing to have an always-on lock in the HTTPS Everywhere logo.

Here's Hugh's version: https-active-24

My current plan is to roll this out in the next release of HTTPS Everywhere, along with new banners for the homepage and Twitter account.

@PotcFdk

PotcFdk commented Sep 13, 2015

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Contributor

I agree with @jsha, having multiple locks near the URL bar might cause confusion with less experienced users who might not even know that they have HTTPSE installed, seeing as, for example, it might have been installed by a computer-savvy friend to improve the user's security experience.

@snwh while your version seems to work well with the other icons in your screenshot, have you checked how the icons look like with a Firefox theme that has a dark background?

@semenko

semenko commented Sep 13, 2015

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Contributor

Hm, agreed regarding padlock confusion, although the "S" strikes me as a bit random.

I'd love to see some mocks with other icon options (a shield? a key?)

@snwh

snwh commented Sep 13, 2015

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Author

@semenko A lock is already the common metaphor for https in most (if not all browsers).

@jsha hmm, just an "S" doesn't really get across that a user is more secure when using https-everywhere.

@PotcFdk trying to account for all the various themes is a losing battle. It's the best case to design with the default theme colors in mind –which are all light-background.

@snwh

snwh commented Sep 13, 2015

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Author

@jsha also, I still think making the icon fit the style of extensions' toolbar icons is a better route, which that one (no offence to Hugh) doesn't do.

@semenko

semenko commented Sep 13, 2015

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Contributor

@snwh I actually like the lock a ton -- and definitely prefer it over the "S" and the current icon.

However, I'm also concerned about users mistaking the HTTPSe lock for "everything being secure" or other dangerous ideas. (I'm guessing that UX folks like @adrifelt would shame us for using a big padlock for HTTPSe.)

I'm reminded of this video of a non-technical user trying to interpret an SSL error: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ngCIU7b5j-M

(The top comments are now from confused users who've figured out that typing "danger" will silently bypass the TLS warning :/ )

@snwh

snwh commented Sep 13, 2015

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Author

@semenko for what it's worth, I am in UX myself. ;)

@semenko

semenko commented Sep 13, 2015

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Contributor

Oh of course! (Sorry, that that came out wrong. I meant more security interaction folks.)

I just have a sneaking suspicion that if we show a clearer large padlock to the right of every site, some subset of users will think "Hey, everything is hidden from my ISP/employer now!" or "This free coffeeshop wifi is now secure!"

That said, maybe they think that now, just by the extension's name?

There's no great way for us to A/B test, and the data are pretty weak (if anything, they show users don't care about padlocks at all...).

From http://www.usablesecurity.org/emperor/emperor.pdf [PDF]:

"""
Prior studies have reported that few users notice the presence of HTTPS indicators such as the browser lock icon [6, 20]. Our results corroborate these findings and extend them by showing that even participants whose passwords are at risk fail to react as recommended when HTTPS indicators are absent.
The failure of all of our participants to respond to the removal of HTTPS indicators cannot be entirely attributed to ignorance. In the post-task questionnaire, three participants mentioned HTTPS indicators, though only in the context of explaining another attack clue.
"""

There's an excerpt in https://static.googleusercontent.com/media/research.google.com/en//pubs/archive/41323.pdf [PDF] that's relevant:

"""
Friedman et al. asked participants whether screenshots of websites depicted secure connections; many participants could not reliably determine whether a connection was secure [15]. Whalen and Inkpen used eye-tracking software to determine that none of their 16 participants looked at the lock or key icon in the URL bar, HTTP(S) status in the URL bar, or the SSL certificate when asked to browse websites “normally” [33]. Some browsers modify the lock icon or color of the URL bar to tell the user when a website has an Extended Validation (EV) SSL certificate. Jackson et al. asked 27 study subjects to classify 12 websites as either phishing or legitimate sites, but the EV certificates did not help subjects identify the phishing sites [19].
"""

@snwh

snwh commented Sep 13, 2015

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Author

@semenko I don't think a GitHub merge proposal is the place for a discussion on the bigger implications of the lock icon. ;)

This is simply me proposing an update to the existing icons with using a symbolic version of https-everywhere's logo which is poorly rendered as these small toolbar icons.

@ldgbc

ldgbc commented Sep 16, 2015

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Contributor

Will you be adding some color to this? It look plain like Firefox's hamburger icon. The Australis icon are all plain and boring. It cheaper to not add color I suppose.

@snwh

snwh commented Sep 16, 2015

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Author

@ldgbc the whole idea is to match the menu icon and other toolbar icons.

@adrifelt

Copy link
Copy Markdown

fwiw, I think it's OK to have the lock in the icon as long as it's clear that it's an action-icon and not a status-icon. meaning that you have to click on it for something to happen, rather than telling you whether the page you're currently looking at is secure. i think the arrows do that.

@semenko

semenko commented Sep 17, 2015

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Contributor

Well, in that case, I'm 100% in favor of @snwh's icons. Thanks @adrifelt!

@thecosmicfrog

Copy link
Copy Markdown

Other than @snwh's wonderful talents at work again, there is now a major reason to use this icon as the HTTPS Everywhere icon in Firefox is now affected by this bug which causes it to completely mess up the order of the Hamburger Menu:

https://bugzilla.mozilla.org/show_bug.cgi?id=1148826

@fuglede

fuglede commented Sep 21, 2015

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Contributor

@thecosmicfrog: Hm, how would the new icons change this fact? (For HTTPS-E, this bug is #2253 btw.)

@snwh

snwh commented Sep 21, 2015

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Author

@fuglede it doesn't. The badge is independent of the icon.

@J0WI

J0WI commented Apr 6, 2016

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Contributor

This is our only ope PR with "High Priority". Have the EFF anything on the roadmap with the HTTPS Everywhere brand?

@jsha

jsha commented Apr 6, 2016

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Member

We also have https://github.com/EFForg/https-everywhere/pull/4100/files open, but after a round of internal feedback, we've asked our graphic designers for another revision, so currently blocked on that.

@ghost

ghost commented May 27, 2016

Copy link
Copy Markdown

Please can this PR no longer be tagged "High Priority"?

Security and basic functionality are high priority. A new logo, nice though it is (although I like the existing logo, too), is not. It is almost certainly lower priority than many of the other 194 pull requests currently in the queue, including some that are not labelled "High Priority".

Thanks :)

@J0WI

J0WI commented Jul 29, 2016

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Contributor

We have a complete new logo now, so I think I can close this one.

@J0WI J0WI closed this Jul 29, 2016
@snwh

snwh commented Jul 29, 2016

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Author

A logo doesn't equal an icon, and as an icon designer, I'm kind of disappointed. Too many projects miss that concept and overuse their logo. But I won't argue the point further.

Sign up for free to subscribe to this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in.

Labels

None yet

Projects

None yet

Development

Successfully merging this pull request may close these issues.

9 participants