Skip to content

Showcase ranking: add more criteria (votes, thumbs up, comments) #129

Closed as not planned

Description

@wiktoriavh

Why

Ranking by a single metric misses posts that stand out in other ways. Combining votes, thumbs up and comments gives a fairer top list.

Acceptance Criteria

  • The results include the top posts by votes, by thumbs up, and by comments.
  • Comments are not counted for a post whose reactions do not contain a thumbs up.
  • The ranking logic is covered by unit tests.

Open Questions

  • How many posts are listed per category?
  • Can a post appear in more than one category?
  • Is the algorithm final? It may be adjusted later.

Out of Scope

  • Changes to how votes are collected.

Activity

  1. michal-skraburski commented on Oct 10, 2026

    @michal-skraburski
    Contributor

    Answering open questions

    • Algorithm will not be final until @wiktoriavh responds, however it should be easily adjustable and testable in a utility function.
    • Comments should not be counted into the total, because a user can manipulate the amount of votes that a post gets.

    Questions for you

    • What is a Category? There is only one channel in the discord? See attached, is that what you mean?
    Image lol the cat made it in
  2. wiktoriavh commented on Oct 31, 2026

    @wiktoriavh
    MemberAuthor

    @michal-skraburski By category I meant "comments", "thumbs up" and "voting". So each category could have their own type of ranking.

    Speaking of comments, instead of amount of comments, it could be unique users that participated in the comments?
    We should also not limit how many posts can appear in a category. Just show them all. We do not have enough posts to warrant gatekeeping it.

    Then the same for repeating in categories, yes they will.

    I also deem this task as quite low in the priority list. We need more people participating.

  3. michal-skraburski commented on Nov 6, 2026

    @michal-skraburski
    Contributor

    Allow me to reiterate the idea just to make sure I understand fully:
    Instead of having one category like we do currently, we implement 2 other categories, comments and voting.

    So each category could have their own type of ranking.

    This implies we will have multiple different categories, which means something like

    1. Wiki's post
    2. Comrade's post
    3. Makkan's post
    
     Most votes: 💯 
    1. Wiki's post
    2. Comrade's post
    3. Makkan's post
    
    Most likes: 👍 
    1. Wiki's post
    2. Comrade's post
    3. Makkan's post
    

    Combining votes, thumbs up and comments gives a fairer top list.

    However the original description of the issue means exclusively one algorithm which sorts them into one big list instead of 3?

Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment

Metadata

Metadata

Assignees

No one assigned

    Labels

    No labels
    No labels

    Projects

    No projects

      Milestone

      No milestone

      Relationships

      None yet

      Development

      No branches or pull requests

      Issue actions