TypeVar bound is ignored in generic alias

Bug Report

A generic alias using a TypeVar with a bound allows type arguments that don't match the bound

To Reproduce

% cat tvbound.py 
import typing

FooT = typing.TypeVar("FooT", bound=str)
FooIsh = typing.Union[int, FooT]

bat2: FooIsh[float] = 1.0

% mypy tvbound.py
Success: no issues found in 1 source file
% mypy --version
mypy 0.820+dev.e8afde621531880c2b9c51acba8e565a29cde0b1

Expected Behavior

I would expect an error saying that the value of FooT cannot be float.

Found this as a result of microsoft/pyright#1839.

I would like to mention that using mypy 0.91 I see a more general version of this error where the resolved GenericAlias isn't type checked at all regardless of the bound on the TypeVar. That is:

FooT = typing.TypeVar("FooT")
FooIsh = typing.Union[int, FooT]

bat2: FooIsh[float] = "passes"

fails to report an error.

@harahu

I just closed #13086 as a duplicate of this issue, but @harahu notes in that issue that this bug is also present for generic type aliases that use constrained TypeVars (as well as those that use bound TypeVars):

from typing import Generic, TypeVar, TypeAlias

U = TypeVar("U", bytes, str)
RestrictedTuple: TypeAlias = tuple[U]
i_am_illegal: RestrictedTuple[int]  # Passes, even though this type shouldn't be possible!

Support ParamSpec variables in type aliases (#14159)

@ilevkivskyi

@ilevkivskyi Are you sure this should be closed? I just made a minimal playground example out of the issue I pointed out in #13086, that @AlexWaygood mentioned above:

https://mypy-play.net/?mypy=master&python=3.11&flags=strict&gist=b251ba96b0e4c9632c8ba162f81280e8

This example still fails when run with mypy from the master branch.

@harahu

@harahu, if I run mypy with the master branch checked out locally on this snippet:

import typing

FooT = typing.TypeVar("FooT", bound=str)
FooIsh = typing.Union[int, FooT]
bat: FooIsh[float] = 1.0

FooT2 = typing.TypeVar("FooT2")
FooIsh2 = typing.Union[int, FooT]
bat2: FooIsh[float] = "fails"

U = typing.TypeVar("U", bytes, str)
RestrictedTuple: typing.TypeAlias = tuple[U]
i_am_illegal: RestrictedTuple[int]

Then this is the output:

test.py:5: error: Type argument "float" of "FooIsh" must be a subtype of "str"  [type-var]
test.py:9: error: Incompatible types in assignment (expression has type "str", variable has type "Union[int, float]")  [assignment]
test.py:13: error: Value of type variable "U" of "RestrictedTuple" cannot be "int"  [type-var]
Found 3 errors in 1 file (checked 1 source file)

This seems like the correct output to me; I think it was correct for this issue to be closed.

The "run mypy with the master branch" option on mypy playground is often quite out of sync with what mypy's actual master branch is, unfortunately. (I sort-of think having that option is not particularly helpful if it's not going to be automatically synced with mypy's latest commit). Note that mypy playground isn't run by mypy; it's a third-party project that you can report issues to here: https://github.com/ymyzk/mypy-playground.

I see. You correctly pointed out where I was mistaken. I assumed playground was up to date. Sorry about the confusion.

Navigation Menu

Repository navigation

TypeVar bound is ignored in generic alias #10445

Metadata

Assignees

Labels

Projects

Milestone

Relationships

Development

TypeVar bound is ignored in generic alias #10445

Description

Activity

UnquietCode commented on Nov 1, 2021

AlexWaygood commented on Jul 7, 2022

harahu commented on Nov 24, 2022

AlexWaygood commented on Nov 24, 2022

harahu commented on Nov 24, 2022

Metadata

Metadata

Assignees

Labels

Projects

Milestone

Relationships

Development

Issue actions