Skip to content

mint-apt-recommends.py bug and suggestion #86

Closed

Description

@gm10

apt recommends produces nonsensical output.

Example

(with debug output enabled, missing packages are marked [MISSING]):

$ apt recommends mpv
  mpv 
   youtube-dl [MISSING]
    python3-pkg-resources 
   libarchive13 
    libacl1 
     libattr1 
      libc6 
       libgcc1 
        gcc-8-base 
    libbz2-1.0 
    liblz4-1 
    liblzma5 
    liblzo2-2 
     multiarch-support 
    libnettle6 
    libxml2 
     libicu60 
      libstdc++6 
     zlib1g 
   libasound2 
    libasound2-data 
   libass9 
    libfontconfig1 
     libexpat1 
     libfreetype6 
      libpng16-16 
     fontconfig-config 
      ucf 
       debconf 
        perl-base 
         dpkg 
          libselinux1 
           libpcre3 
          libzstd1 
          tar 
       coreutils 
       sensible-utils 
      fonts-dejavu-core 
      fonts-liberation 
    libfribidi0 
    libharfbuzz0b 
     libglib2.0-0 
      libffi6 
      libmount1 
       libblkid1 
        libuuid1 
     libgraphite2-3 
   libavcodec58 
    libswresample3 
     libavutil56 
      libdrm2 
       libdrm-common 
      libva-drm2 
       libva2 
      libva-x11-2 
       libx11-6 
        libxcb1 
         libxau6 
         libxdmcp6 
          libbsd0 
        libx11-data 
       libxext6 
       libxfixes3 
      libvdpau1 
     libsoxr0 
      libgomp1 
    libcairo2 
     libpixman-1-0 
     libxcb-render0 
     libxcb-shm0 
     libxrender1 
    libcodec2-0.8.1 
    libcrystalhd3 
    libgsm1 
    libmp3lame0 
    libopenjp2-7 
    libopus0 
    librsvg2-2 
     libcroco3 
     libgdk-pixbuf2.0-0 
      libjpeg8 
       libjpeg-turbo8 
      libtiff5 
       libjbig0 
      shared-mime-info 
      libgdk-pixbuf2.0-common 
     libpango-1.0-0 
      fontconfig 
      libthai0 
       libthai-data 
       libdatrie1 
     libpangocairo-1.0-0 
      libpangoft2-1.0-0 
    libshine3 
    libsnappy1v5 
    libspeex1 
    libtheora0 
     libogg0 
    libtwolame0 
    libvorbis0a 
    libvorbisenc2 
    libvpx5 
    libwavpack1 
    libwebp6 
    libwebpmux3 
    libx264-152 
    libx265-160 
     libnuma1 
    libxvidcore4 
    libzvbi0 
     libzvbi-common 
   libavdevice58 
    libavfilter7 
     libavformat58 
      libbluray2 
       libaacs0 [MISSING]
        libgcrypt20 
         libgpg-error0 
      libchromaprint1 
       libavcodec-extra57 
        libavutil55 
        libopencore-amrnb0 
        libopencore-amrwb0 
        libswresample2 
        libvo-amrwbenc0 
        libx265-146 
      libgme0 
      libgnutls30 
       libgmp10 
       libhogweed4 
       libidn2-0 
        libunistring2 
       libp11-kit0 
       libtasn1-6 
      libopenmpt0 
       libmpg123-0 
       libvorbisfile3 
      libssh-gcrypt-4 
       libgssapi-krb5-2 
        libk5crypto3 
         libkrb5support0 
        libkrb5-3 
         libkeyutils1 
     libpostproc55 
     libswscale5 
     libbs2b0 
     libflite1 
     liblilv-0-0 
      libserd-0-0 
      libsord-0-0 
      libsratom-0-0 
     libmysofa0 
     libopencv-core3.2 
      libtbb2 
     libopencv-imgproc3.2 
     librubberband2 
      libfftw3-double3 
      libsamplerate0 
     libzmq5 
      libnorm1 
      libpgm-5.2-0 
      libsodium23 
    libavc1394-0 
     libraw1394-11 
    libcaca0 
     libncursesw5 
      libtinfo5 
     libslang2 
    libcdio-cdda2 
     libcdio17 
    libcdio-paranoia2 
    libdc1394-22 
     libusb-1.0-0 
      libudev1 
    libgl1 
     libglvnd0 
     libglx0 
      libglx-mesa0 
       libglapi-mesa 
       libx11-xcb1 
       libxcb-dri2-0 
       libxcb-dri3-0 
       libxcb-glx0 
       libxcb-present0 
       libxcb-sync1 
       libxdamage1 
       libxshmfence1 
       libxxf86vm1 
       libgl1-mesa-dri 
        libdrm-amdgpu1 
        libdrm-intel1 
         libpciaccess0 
        libdrm-nouveau2 
        libdrm-radeon1 
        libelf1 
        libllvm6.0 
         libedit2 
        libsensors4 
    libiec61883-0 
    libjack-jackd2-0 
    libopenal1 
     libopenal-data 
     libsndio6.1 
    libpulse0 
     libasyncns0 
     libdbus-1-3 
      libsystemd0 
     libsndfile1 
      libflac8 
     libwrap0 
    libsdl2-2.0-0 
     libwayland-client0 
     libwayland-cursor0 
     libwayland-egl1 
     libxcursor1 
     libxi6 
     libxinerama1 
     libxkbcommon0 
      xkb-data 
     libxrandr2 
     libxss1 
      x11-common 
       lsb-base 
    libsndio7.0 
    libxcb-shape0 
    libxcb-xfixes0 
    libxv1 
   libcdio18 
   libdvdnav4 
    libdvdread4 
   libegl1 
    libegl-mesa0 
     libgbm1 
      libwayland-server0 
   liblcms2-2 
   liblua5.2-0 
   libsmbclient 
    samba-libs 
     libavahi-client3 
      libavahi-common3 
       libavahi-common-data 
     libcap2 
     libcups2 
     libjansson4 
     libldap-2.4-2 
      libgssapi3-heimdal 
       libasn1-8-heimdal 
        libroken18-heimdal 
       libhcrypto4-heimdal 
        libheimbase1-heimdal 
       libheimntlm0-heimdal 
        libkrb5-26-heimdal 
         libhx509-5-heimdal 
          libwind0-heimdal 
         libsqlite3-0 
      libsasl2-2 
       libsasl2-modules-db 
        libdb5.3 
      libldap-common 
     libldb1 
      libtalloc2 
      libtdb1 
      libtevent0 
     libpam0g 
      libaudit1 
       libaudit-common 
       libcap-ng0 
     libpopt0 
     libpython2.7 
      libpython2.7-stdlib 
       libpython2.7-minimal 
       mime-support 
       libreadline7 
        readline-common 
         install-info 
       libssl1.1 
     libwbclient0 
     python-talloc 
   libuchardet0 
   libva-wayland2 
   libvulkan1 

The following missing recommended packages were found for mpv:

    libaacs0
    youtube-dl

You can install them by typing the following command:

    apt install libaacs0 youtube-dl

Problem:

Of those two, only youtube-dl is a missing direct recommend:

$ apt show mpv
[...]
Recommends: xdg-utils, youtube-dl (>= 2014.11.26

Direct recommends are the only thing I would want to see as the output of that command.

libaacs0 is a recommendation of the libbluray2 package far down the list. Other recommended packages in the tree are not listed, in particular recommended packages of recommended packages. There is no logic to this limitation. If you go recursive then go fully recursive.

Proposed solution:

Make default operation non-recursive:

$ apt recommends mpv

The following missing recommended packages were found for mpv:

    youtube-dl

You can install them by typing the following command:

    apt install youtube-dl

but add a --recursive parameter for a fully recursive output:

$ apt recommends mpv --recursive

The following missing recommended packages were found for mpv:

    aria2
    libaacs0
    libbdplus0
    mplayer
    phantomjs
    python3-pyxattr
    rtmpdump
    va-driver-all
    vdpau-driver-all
    youtube-dl

You can install them by typing the following command:

    apt install aria2 libaacs0 libbdplus0 mplayer phantomjs python3-pyxattr rtmpdump va-driver-all vdpau-driver-all youtube-dl

Activity

Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment

Metadata

Metadata

Assignees

No one assigned

    Labels

    No labels
    No labels

    Type

    No type

    Projects

    No projects

      Milestone

      No milestone

      Relationships

      None yet

      Development

      No branches or pull requests

      Issue actions