Repository navigation
Closed
Description
apt recommends produces nonsensical output.
Example
(with debug output enabled, missing packages are marked [MISSING]):
$ apt recommends mpv
mpv
youtube-dl [MISSING]
python3-pkg-resources
libarchive13
libacl1
libattr1
libc6
libgcc1
gcc-8-base
libbz2-1.0
liblz4-1
liblzma5
liblzo2-2
multiarch-support
libnettle6
libxml2
libicu60
libstdc++6
zlib1g
libasound2
libasound2-data
libass9
libfontconfig1
libexpat1
libfreetype6
libpng16-16
fontconfig-config
ucf
debconf
perl-base
dpkg
libselinux1
libpcre3
libzstd1
tar
coreutils
sensible-utils
fonts-dejavu-core
fonts-liberation
libfribidi0
libharfbuzz0b
libglib2.0-0
libffi6
libmount1
libblkid1
libuuid1
libgraphite2-3
libavcodec58
libswresample3
libavutil56
libdrm2
libdrm-common
libva-drm2
libva2
libva-x11-2
libx11-6
libxcb1
libxau6
libxdmcp6
libbsd0
libx11-data
libxext6
libxfixes3
libvdpau1
libsoxr0
libgomp1
libcairo2
libpixman-1-0
libxcb-render0
libxcb-shm0
libxrender1
libcodec2-0.8.1
libcrystalhd3
libgsm1
libmp3lame0
libopenjp2-7
libopus0
librsvg2-2
libcroco3
libgdk-pixbuf2.0-0
libjpeg8
libjpeg-turbo8
libtiff5
libjbig0
shared-mime-info
libgdk-pixbuf2.0-common
libpango-1.0-0
fontconfig
libthai0
libthai-data
libdatrie1
libpangocairo-1.0-0
libpangoft2-1.0-0
libshine3
libsnappy1v5
libspeex1
libtheora0
libogg0
libtwolame0
libvorbis0a
libvorbisenc2
libvpx5
libwavpack1
libwebp6
libwebpmux3
libx264-152
libx265-160
libnuma1
libxvidcore4
libzvbi0
libzvbi-common
libavdevice58
libavfilter7
libavformat58
libbluray2
libaacs0 [MISSING]
libgcrypt20
libgpg-error0
libchromaprint1
libavcodec-extra57
libavutil55
libopencore-amrnb0
libopencore-amrwb0
libswresample2
libvo-amrwbenc0
libx265-146
libgme0
libgnutls30
libgmp10
libhogweed4
libidn2-0
libunistring2
libp11-kit0
libtasn1-6
libopenmpt0
libmpg123-0
libvorbisfile3
libssh-gcrypt-4
libgssapi-krb5-2
libk5crypto3
libkrb5support0
libkrb5-3
libkeyutils1
libpostproc55
libswscale5
libbs2b0
libflite1
liblilv-0-0
libserd-0-0
libsord-0-0
libsratom-0-0
libmysofa0
libopencv-core3.2
libtbb2
libopencv-imgproc3.2
librubberband2
libfftw3-double3
libsamplerate0
libzmq5
libnorm1
libpgm-5.2-0
libsodium23
libavc1394-0
libraw1394-11
libcaca0
libncursesw5
libtinfo5
libslang2
libcdio-cdda2
libcdio17
libcdio-paranoia2
libdc1394-22
libusb-1.0-0
libudev1
libgl1
libglvnd0
libglx0
libglx-mesa0
libglapi-mesa
libx11-xcb1
libxcb-dri2-0
libxcb-dri3-0
libxcb-glx0
libxcb-present0
libxcb-sync1
libxdamage1
libxshmfence1
libxxf86vm1
libgl1-mesa-dri
libdrm-amdgpu1
libdrm-intel1
libpciaccess0
libdrm-nouveau2
libdrm-radeon1
libelf1
libllvm6.0
libedit2
libsensors4
libiec61883-0
libjack-jackd2-0
libopenal1
libopenal-data
libsndio6.1
libpulse0
libasyncns0
libdbus-1-3
libsystemd0
libsndfile1
libflac8
libwrap0
libsdl2-2.0-0
libwayland-client0
libwayland-cursor0
libwayland-egl1
libxcursor1
libxi6
libxinerama1
libxkbcommon0
xkb-data
libxrandr2
libxss1
x11-common
lsb-base
libsndio7.0
libxcb-shape0
libxcb-xfixes0
libxv1
libcdio18
libdvdnav4
libdvdread4
libegl1
libegl-mesa0
libgbm1
libwayland-server0
liblcms2-2
liblua5.2-0
libsmbclient
samba-libs
libavahi-client3
libavahi-common3
libavahi-common-data
libcap2
libcups2
libjansson4
libldap-2.4-2
libgssapi3-heimdal
libasn1-8-heimdal
libroken18-heimdal
libhcrypto4-heimdal
libheimbase1-heimdal
libheimntlm0-heimdal
libkrb5-26-heimdal
libhx509-5-heimdal
libwind0-heimdal
libsqlite3-0
libsasl2-2
libsasl2-modules-db
libdb5.3
libldap-common
libldb1
libtalloc2
libtdb1
libtevent0
libpam0g
libaudit1
libaudit-common
libcap-ng0
libpopt0
libpython2.7
libpython2.7-stdlib
libpython2.7-minimal
mime-support
libreadline7
readline-common
install-info
libssl1.1
libwbclient0
python-talloc
libuchardet0
libva-wayland2
libvulkan1
The following missing recommended packages were found for mpv:
libaacs0
youtube-dl
You can install them by typing the following command:
apt install libaacs0 youtube-dl
Problem:
Of those two, only youtube-dl is a missing direct recommend:
$ apt show mpv
[...]
Recommends: xdg-utils, youtube-dl (>= 2014.11.26
Direct recommends are the only thing I would want to see as the output of that command.
libaacs0 is a recommendation of the libbluray2 package far down the list. Other recommended packages in the tree are not listed, in particular recommended packages of recommended packages. There is no logic to this limitation. If you go recursive then go fully recursive.
Proposed solution:
Make default operation non-recursive:
$ apt recommends mpv
The following missing recommended packages were found for mpv:
youtube-dl
You can install them by typing the following command:
apt install youtube-dl
but add a --recursive parameter for a fully recursive output:
$ apt recommends mpv --recursive
The following missing recommended packages were found for mpv:
aria2
libaacs0
libbdplus0
mplayer
phantomjs
python3-pyxattr
rtmpdump
va-driver-all
vdpau-driver-all
youtube-dl
You can install them by typing the following command:
apt install aria2 libaacs0 libbdplus0 mplayer phantomjs python3-pyxattr rtmpdump va-driver-all vdpau-driver-all youtube-dl
Metadata
Metadata
Assignees
Labels
No labels
Activity