You signed in with another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.You signed out in another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.You switched accounts on another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.Dismiss alert
{{ message }}
Repository navigation
Explore sending and receiving of custom onion messages #121
How do you think about this in relation to the ldk-node scope? Its definitely something that most users will have no need for, though is of course quite trivial.
Yup, I agree that it's kinda out-of-scope of the minimal API, hence the 'Explore' in the title. We got some requests for it (e.g., for lndk testing), and I generally like the idea of having a simple tool available that allows people to start using/playing with OMs. Still, it might be a feature that anyone willing to fork the codebase could easily add on their own if they wanted.
I generally like the idea of having a simple tool available that allows people to start using/playing with OMs
If that's the goal we should have a demo of a simple rust project that spins up a node that can only send +receive OMs without anything else, but that doesn't help those wanting to use it in conjunction with a real node of course.
They are looking to use LDK Node for (integration) testing purposes, i.e., to have an easy way to spawn up a node in CI and see if messages come through.
If that's the goal we should have a demo of a simple rust project that spins up a node that can only send +receive OMs without anything else, but that doesn't help those wanting to use it in conjunction with a real node of course.
Right. Just from the experience over the last months I can see that there is a lot of utility in having a quick way to spawn up a full lightning node and interact with it programatically. It's just great to be able to connect to any node and test something out in ~5 lines of Rust. Longer term it might be nice to have a tool providing this kind of 'swiss army knife' utility, which however doesn't mean it has to be LDK Node mainline. Another example for a 'nice to have' utility would probably be probing capabilities (see #19).
As said, I agree that features such as OMs are out-of-scope for LDK Node (at least for now). Main intention here was to document the feature request and possibly come back to it / explore its feasibility in the future.
Activity
TheBlueMatt commentedon Jun 9, 2023
How do you think about this in relation to the ldk-node scope? Its definitely something that most users will have no need for, though is of course quite trivial.
moneyball commentedon Jun 9, 2023
That was going to be my question too.
tnull commentedon Jun 9, 2023
Yup, I agree that it's kinda out-of-scope of the minimal API, hence the 'Explore' in the title. We got some requests for it (e.g., for lndk testing), and I generally like the idea of having a simple tool available that allows people to start using/playing with OMs. Still, it might be a feature that anyone willing to fork the codebase could easily add on their own if they wanted.
moneyball commentedon Jun 9, 2023
Hmmm doesn't LNDK use LDK not LDK Node?
TheBlueMatt commentedon Jun 10, 2023
If that's the goal we should have a demo of a simple rust project that spins up a node that can only send +receive OMs without anything else, but that doesn't help those wanting to use it in conjunction with a real node of course.
tnull commentedon Jun 10, 2023
They are looking to use LDK Node for (integration) testing purposes, i.e., to have an easy way to spawn up a node in CI and see if messages come through.
Right. Just from the experience over the last months I can see that there is a lot of utility in having a quick way to spawn up a full lightning node and interact with it programatically. It's just great to be able to connect to any node and test something out in ~5 lines of Rust. Longer term it might be nice to have a tool providing this kind of 'swiss army knife' utility, which however doesn't mean it has to be LDK Node mainline. Another example for a 'nice to have' utility would probably be probing capabilities (see #19).
As said, I agree that features such as OMs are out-of-scope for LDK Node (at least for now). Main intention here was to document the feature request and possibly come back to it / explore its feasibility in the future.
tnull commentedon Nov 15, 2023
This recently became a priority again as users want to be able to send/receive OMs via LDK Node. Adding to the 0.3 milestone.
tnull commentedon Sep 12, 2024
Not sure if the concrete user demand persists, so closing this for now.