Repository navigation
Enh: Upgrade PRD Skill to ask questions #966
Description
I love the PRD skill. It keeps everything very simple and easy to understand.
What do you guys think about giving it a minor upgrade?
The write-a-prd skill has a nice loop where it looks at the dependencies and works through the problems with you, i like the interaction, but i do not like how verbose it is, i tried to use it and did not get what i asked for even though we covered almost every edge case. I dropped back down to the squads prd skills.
The main take away from the write-a-prd skill is that as you answer questions or come up with your own feedback it will go through another loop and look at your code base to see if there is any conflicts with what you want, it is very interactive.
Maybe we leave the PRD skill alone and make an interactive PRD skill, idk, what do you guys think?
Activity
bradygaster commentedon Apr 12, 2026
I like this idea, but I'd like to keep anything that prescribes a specific workflow or style out of Squad. We've talked about, for example, deeper integration with Spec-Kit, which has a lot of the same amazing features for spec-first and spec iteration. Whilst all good ideas, what's good for a Spec-Kit user might not be good for a user of your idea here, so, putting them directly into Squad could alienate users who don't want that type of style. This is an amazing contribution for a "custom squad" in which one wants to do something like this, but again, that'd be a Squad you'd create, export, and share with folks so they could get the benefit.
For example - take a look at Paul Yuk's "Snap Squad": https://github.com/paulyuk/snap-squad
You basically have a custom squad in an NPM package.