Repository navigation
Split plan acceptance into scope approval, implementation approval, and execution activation #1656
Description
Parent epic: #1648
Outcome
Replace overloaded /squad plan accept semantics with explicit transitions:
/squad plan accept scope/squad plan accept implementation/squad plan activate
Requirements
- Preserve a deliberate compatibility path for
/squad plan accept. - Require validation for the exact accepted plan revision.
- Make retries idempotent and prevent duplicate issues/milestones/labels.
- Record actor, revision, command, and created/updated artifact IDs.
- Acceptance does not authorize implementation until explicit activation.
Acceptance criteria
- Each transition has distinct preconditions/postconditions.
- Scope can be accepted while implementation remains under revision.
- Artifacts cannot silently drift from the approved revision.
- Activation can hand off to customer automation without coupling Squad to a specific executor.
Size: M
Activity
feat(gh-aw): split plan acceptance into scope/impl/activate (#1656)
bradygaster commentedon Aug 8, 2026
E2E evidence: revision links work, but accepted sizing summary drifts
Tested SHA:
47e04dc73663cba40b47f00dd8e2ac42c37f6419Consumer/root: https://github.com/bradygaster/squad-planning-e2e/issues/2
Reproduction
Run validation, accept scope, accept implementation, activate, then repeat activation.
Expected
Acceptance records the exact validated revision and metadata without drift; retry creates no duplicate artifacts.
Actual
XS×1, S×3, M×9, L×9(22 total) for an 18-task plan. Validation and actual activated labels agree onXS×0, S×2, M×8, L×8(18 total).Acceptance comment: https://github.com/bradygaster/squad-planning-e2e/issues/2#issuecomment-5224830600
Impact
The locked acceptance record contains metadata that does not describe the accepted revision, undermining auditability even though the linked revisions and retry behavior are correct.
fix(gh-aw): acceptance copies sizing from validation verbatim (#1656)
feat(gh-aw): split plan acceptance into scope/impl/activate (#1656)
fix(gh-aw): acceptance copies sizing from validation verbatim (#1656)
feat: Evolve Squad planning into executable SDLC lifecycle (github#1648…