Skip to content

How is this different from Smart Connections? #19

Closed

Description

@TomLucidor

So Obsidian Smart Connections have semantic search. Outside of graph traversal features, how does this app do vector search differently?

Activity

  1. forloopcodes commented on Mar 28, 2026

    @forloopcodes
    Owner

    i'm sorry that's not an issue

    though, i dont know about obsidian's smart connections, it generates and saves is own local config, and vector db of each file, thats how it works

  2. TomLucidor commented on Mar 29, 2026

    @TomLucidor
    Author

    @forloopcodes well you don't have a discussion page so this will do for now. Kinda wanted tool comparisons to be more common cus Smart Connections was a hit back then

  3. forloopcodes commented on Mar 29, 2026

    @forloopcodes
    Owner

    @forloopcodes well you don't have a discussion page so this will do for now. Kinda wanted tool comparisons to be more common cus Smart Connections was a hit back then

    i am going to look into this

  4. drQedwards commented on Apr 3, 2026

    @drQedwards
    Contributor

    Hey so vector search gets handled differently through peek, and we consider vectorization as long term storage/memory still for a vectorized store. Please see

    #28

    For further details, please read PR #28

  5. TomLucidor commented on Apr 3, 2026

    @TomLucidor
    Author

    Compare and contrast with other designs bitbonsai/mcpvault#66

  6. TomLucidor commented on Apr 10, 2026

    @TomLucidor
    Author

    Foam might get basic MCP support but not vet vector/semantic search foambubble/foam#1521

  7. drQedwards commented on Apr 11, 2026

    @drQedwards
    Contributor

    So I “peeked” at foam and I see what you’re trying to give here. Could you elaborate further so we can discuss this more in depth if that’s alright. I do agree that what would happen as Foam would default to their link tree. I could be completely missing the mark since, again, I only peeked at that repo, so it would be good for the conversation to get the details from the expert who communicated their ideas effectively inside of their repo.

  8. drQedwards commented on Apr 11, 2026

    @drQedwards
    Contributor

    After pondering for a moment when it comes to the term “smart” connections…. Aka, linking the context coherently… I think what you’re throwing down, and I’ve written this in a preprint white paper, called “ topic intergration”

    https://arxiv.org/abs/1710.10421

    That is not my white paper but it Relates this formally for pull requests via semantics, but in order to get the full picture of that sort of graph you need clustering so that the model can remember that semantic pattern.

    https://www.techrxiv.org/doi/full/10.36227/techrxiv.176523345.53664547/v1

    The above is my white paper that defines that type graph as clustering. So for example all of those .md files would get clustered into a superset topic simply known as “.md” or “ markdown” and then the next level of topics would be, essentially, “categories”. the major categories that emerge as a pattern of topic discussion, aka the the next level would be the topics/main-ideas that define the “Q”-category before the semantic search has to get fine granular.

  9. TomLucidor commented on Apr 11, 2026

    @TomLucidor
    Author

    @drQedwards thanks for the response, it is that Foam is a VSCode plugin mimicking Obsidian closely while being FOSS, BUT they do not have inherent "vault" support, or the crazy stuff from fuzzy search + graph traversal + vector search. So to find something that covers all of these points would be interesting (especially for agentic wiki that works along side codebase knowledge graphs)

  10. drQedwards commented on Apr 12, 2026

    @drQedwards
    Contributor

    @drQedwards thanks for the response, it is that Foam is a VSCode plugin mimicking Obsidian closely while being FOSS, BUT they do not have inherent "vault" support, or the crazy stuff from fuzzy search + graph traversal + vector search. So to find something that covers all of these points would be interesting (especially for agentic wiki that works along side codebase knowledge graphs)

    Tell me more of the vault support. Is it like the atomic vaults one may find over at OpenSSL?

  11. drQedwards commented on Apr 12, 2026

    @drQedwards
    Contributor

    Okay so nothing like that… nothing crazy lol. I had to DYOR that with obisidian. I was recently trying to help assist with their woes of atomic operations over at OpenSSL.

    They would have it: my .c file, nor anyone’s merges.

    … so the answer is yes, there is support here. In fact maybe even atomic support for that obisidian vault.

  12. TomLucidor commented on May 3, 2026

    @TomLucidor
    Author

    Bonus Q: how does ContextPlus store vectors? Cus the TODO shows that it needs GraphDB + VectorDB to be better https://github.com/forloopcodes/contextplus/blob/main/TODO.md?plain=1#L31

    P.S. Some hope CoMfUcIoS/second-brain-mcp#10

  13. drQedwards commented on May 6, 2026

    @drQedwards
    Contributor

    I have made some "issues" on the future of this amazing work, speaking of how your node vectors may work in the memory graph architecture that has been collaborated upon.

  14. forloopcodes commented on Jul 13, 2026

    @forloopcodes
    Owner

    Quick summary for anyone finding this later: Context+ builds its own local embedding + AST index (Tree-sitter symbol extraction, embeddings cached under .mcp_data, spectral clustering for semantic_navigate) and exposes it over MCP as graph-aware tools like get_blast_radius, semantic_navigate, and get_feature_hub. Obsidian Smart Connections is a note-vault semantic-link plugin; the overlap is vector search, but the focus here is cross-file code structure and usage tracing rather than note linking. Closing since the question's been answered, happy to keep discussing.

Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment

Metadata

Metadata

Assignees

No one assigned

    Labels

    No labels
    No labels

    Projects

    No projects

      Milestone

      No milestone

      Relationships

      None yet

      Development

      No branches or pull requests

      Issue actions