Repository navigation
Closed
Labels
bugConfirmed incorrect behaviorConfirmed incorrect behavior
Description
What should happen when a front reaches the domain edge? On real terrain, the whole arrival map gets filled.
Mineral Fire 2016 (near Coalinga, CA), 12 × 15 km at 30 m, Farsite with LANDFIRE fuels and HRRR wind. At t = 48.5 h the front is 15 m from the east edge. Half an hour later:
- the kernel prints
WARNING: trashing a fire front with inner fronts(FireFront.cpp:1108) nine times; - no fire node is left;
- 70.9% of the arrival map has one identical time, and no cell is left unburnt, barren ones included.
Repro: repro_edge_flood.py with mineral_inputs.npz (740 KB, available on request), about a minute.
I couldn't reproduce it on a flat synthetic domain: there the front slows down near the edge and stops. A few cells near the ignition do get a negative arrival time (−13 s) in both cases.
Side note: FireDomain.cpp:1128 (singlePolygonAreaBurningScan) reads SWCornerY()/burningMatrixResY where the X line above has +.
repro_edge_flood.py
"""Real terrain (Mineral Fire, 2016): the arrival-time map floods when the front reaches the domain edge.
Needs mineral_inputs.npz (30 m grid, 400 x 500, row 0 south): FBFM40 fuel, elevation,
half-hourly wind (already in the Farsite model's units) and 1 h fuel moisture.
"""
import re, numpy as np, pyforefire as pyff
d = np.load("mineral_inputs.npz")
NY, NX = d["fuel"].shape
Lx, Ly = NX * 30.0, NY * 30.0
with pyff.ForeFireRunner(stdout=None) as ff:
ff["propagationModel"] = "Farsite"; ff["fuelsTable"] = "STDfarsiteFuelsTable"; ff["minSpeed"] = 0
ff["spatialIncrement"] = 3; ff["perimeterResolution"] = 30; ff["minimalPropagativeFrontDepth"] = 30
ff["relax"] = 0.5; ff["bmapLayer"] = 1
ff.execute(f"FireDomain[sw=(0,0,0);ne=({Lx},{Ly},0);t=0]")
ff.addLayer("propagation", "Farsite", "propagationModel")
ff.addIndexLayer("table", "fuel", 0, 0, 0, Lx, Ly, 0, d["fuel"].astype(np.int32)[None, None].copy())
ff.addScalarLayer("data", "altitude", 0, 0, 0, Lx, Ly, 0, d["altitude"].astype(float)[None, None].copy())
for name, k in (("windU", 0), ("windV", 1)):
w = np.zeros((1, 2, 4, 4)); w[0, k] = 1
ff.addScalarLayer("windScalDir", name, 0, 0, 0, Lx, Ly, 0, w)
x, y = d["ignition"]
ff.execute(f"startFire[loc=({x},{y},0);t=0]")
for h, (u, v), m in zip(d["hours"], d["wind"], d["m1"]):
ff.execute(f"trigger[wind;loc=(0,0,0);vel=({u},{v},0)]")
for name, val in (("ones", m), ("tens", m + .01), ("hundreds", m + .02), ("liveh", .3), ("livew", .75)):
ff[f"moistures.{name}"] = float(val)
ff.execute(f"goTo[t={(h + 0.5) * 3600}]")
a = pyff.arrival_time(ff, "/tmp/arrival.asc")
vals, counts = np.unique(a[np.isfinite(a)], return_counts=True)
xs = [float(s.split(",")[0]) for s in re.findall(r"loc=\(([^)]*)\)", ff.execute("print[]"))]
if h >= 46:
print(f"t={h + 0.5:5.1f} h nodes={len(xs):5d} max x={max(xs, default=float('nan')):7.0f} of {Lx:.0f} "
f"unburnt={np.isinf(a).mean():5.1%} largest same-time patch={counts.max() / a.size:5.1%} of the map", flush=True)
if not xs:
breakDrafted with Claude Opus 5.5.
Metadata
Metadata
Assignees
Labels
bugConfirmed incorrect behaviorConfirmed incorrect behavior
Activity
filippi commentedon Oct 30, 2026
hi @HugoFara the far site emulation really is a work in small progress, but if it works (including the reading of original files) it may be a fantastic inter-comparison set.. and the best addition ever for adoption of ForeFire.. thanks a lot
a version of Farsite can be found here
https://github.com/mbedward/farsite/
I know the original Author, Mark Finney, and he is cool with us re-using the code for reproducibility purposes
HugoFara commentedon Oct 30, 2026
Hi, yes I was trying to compare wildfires but unable to use farsite, hence the current developments. It is hard, but no reason we can't get there :)
fix(core): a front reaching the domain edge no longer floods the arri…
fix(core): a front reaching the domain edge no longer floods the arri…
antonio-leblanc commentedon Oct 31, 2026
fixed by #240, merged into dev. closing