Skip to content

Should John Smith Ph. D. Jones read like John Smith PhD Jones, or is the split spelling's reading the better one? #827

Closed

Description

@derek73

S8 (the credential's trailing run) lets an unambiguous credential after the name core start a run to the end of its part, taking a name word behind it as a reported suffix. The split spelling Ph. D. chains a following credential like every other spelling, but in a main segment (no comma, or before a suffix comma) it starts no run over a name word.

input reads reported
John Smith Ph. D. M.D. family 'Smith', suffix 'Ph. D. M.D.' nothing
John Smith Ph. D., M.D. family 'Smith', suffix 'Ph. D., M.D.' nothing
John Smith PhD Jones family 'Smith', suffix 'PhD Jones' suffix-or-name
John Smith Ph.D. Jones family 'Smith', suffix 'Ph.D. Jones' suffix-or-name
John Smith Ph. D. Jones middle 'Smith', family 'Jones', suffix 'Ph. D.' nothing
John Smith Ph. D. Jones, Jr. middle 'Smith', family 'Jones', suffix 'Ph. D., Jr.' nothing
Smith, John Ph. D. Jones family 'Smith', suffix 'Ph. D. Jones' suffix-or-name

Group merges Ph. D. into one flagged piece, and the trailing peel's walk never holds that piece. #603 (decisions/C13) made the merged piece start the run after a comma, but left the main segment as it was. The difference only shows when a name word follows the merged piece.

Proposal, in rule shape

When: the split Ph. D. stands after the name core in a main segment, with a name word behind it, as in "John Smith Ph. D. Jones".

Then, one of:

Because: the three spellings are one credential, and S8's run start asks for an unambiguous credential, not a spelling. The two readings differ only in what they do with a name word, which is the part of #602 most open to doubt.

Boundaries that stay as they are: a known credential behind Ph. D. (John Smith Ph. D. M.D.) reads suffix, and John Smith Ph. D. reads suffix 'Ph. D.'.

Open questions

  1. Does (A) need the peel's walk to hold merged pieces, and what else would that move?
  2. Is (C) worth measuring over the corpora, to see how often a credential is followed by a real name word?
Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment

Metadata

Metadata

Assignees

Projects

No projects

    Milestone

    No milestone

    Relationships

    None yet

    Development

    No branches or pull requests

    Issue actions