Repository navigation
Description
Claude's calls to "atomic record" fail.
Here are my calls to "atomic doctor check" and my attempt to repair.
b$ atomic doctor check
ℹ Verifying native derived indexes against graph authority...
⚠ 64 native derived-index problem(s) found:
✗ TREE missing row 'voltageStateMachine_v25.c' expected=11
✗ TREE stale row 'baseline' actual=115
✗ TREE stale row 'baseline/protoread.c' actual=112
✗ TREE stale row 'baseline/voltage_state_machine.c' actual=113
✗ TREE stale row 'baseline/voltage_state_machine.h' actual=114
✗ TREE stale row 'dbook.tgz' actual=137
✗ TREE stale row 'disturbance_examples_2' actual=119
✗ TREE stale row 'disturbance_examples_3' actual=138
✗ TREE stale row 'event-truth-806a10315682-20260914T130508047-rising.png' actual=120
✗ TREE stale row 'event-truth-806a10315682-20260914T130508372-falling.png' actual=126
✗ TREE stale row 'event-truth-806a1034c284-20260922T131925414-rising.png' actual=131
✗ TREE stale row 'tools/fetch_minutes.py' actual=139
✗ TREE stale row 'tools/find_disturbances.py' actual=117
✗ TREE stale row 'transcripts' actual=118
✗ TREE stale row 'transcripts/prototype-half-cycle-algorithms' actual=116
✗ TREE stale row 'zoomedbigfonts1.png' actual=136
✗ REV_TREE missing row '11' expected=voltageStateMachine_v25.c
✗ REV_TREE stale row '112' actual=baseline/protoread.c
✗ REV_TREE stale row '113' actual=baseline/voltage_state_machine.c
✗ REV_TREE stale row '114' actual=baseline/voltage_state_machine.h
✗ REV_TREE stale row '115' actual=baseline
✗ REV_TREE stale row '116' actual=transcripts/prototype-half-cycle-algorithms
✗ REV_TREE stale row '117' actual=tools/find_disturbances.py
✗ REV_TREE stale row '118' actual=transcripts
✗ REV_TREE stale row '119' actual=disturbance_examples_2
✗ REV_TREE stale row '120' actual=event-truth-806a10315682-20260914T130508047-rising.png
✗ REV_TREE stale row '126' actual=event-truth-806a10315682-20260914T130508372-falling.png
✗ REV_TREE stale row '131' actual=event-truth-806a1034c284-20260922T131925414-rising.png
✗ REV_TREE stale row '136' actual=zoomedbigfonts1.png
✗ REV_TREE stale row '137' actual=dbook.tgz
✗ REV_TREE stale row '138' actual=disturbance_examples_3
✗ REV_TREE stale row '139' actual=tools/fetch_minutes.py
✗ INODES missing row '121' expected=81:7488157
✗ INODES missing row '122' expected=81:4350364
✗ INODES missing row '123' expected=81:2716842
✗ INODES missing row '124' expected=81:9513236
✗ INODES missing row '125' expected=81:5118223
✗ INODES missing row '127' expected=81:2345883
✗ INODES missing row '128' expected=81:14655054
✗ INODES missing row '129' expected=81:2129464
✗ INODES missing row '130' expected=81:11601089
✗ INODES missing row '132' expected=81:10495494
✗ INODES missing row '133' expected=81:3428034
✗ INODES missing row '134' expected=81:1442218
✗ INODES missing row '135' expected=81:9790226
✗ REV_INODES missing row '81:10495494' expected=132
✗ REV_INODES missing row '81:11601089' expected=130
✗ REV_INODES missing row '81:1442218' expected=134
✗ REV_INODES missing row '81:14655054' expected=128
✗ REV_INODES missing row '81:2129464' expected=129
✗ REV_INODES missing row '81:2345883' expected=127
✗ REV_INODES missing row '81:2716842' expected=123
✗ REV_INODES missing row '81:3428034' expected=133
✗ REV_INODES missing row '81:4350364' expected=122
✗ REV_INODES missing row '81:5118223' expected=125
✗ REV_INODES missing row '81:7488157' expected=121
✗ REV_INODES missing row '81:9513236' expected=124
✗ REV_INODES missing row '81:9790226' expected=135
✗ DIRECTORIES stale row '104' actual=0x01
✗ DIRECTORIES stale row '106' actual=0x01
✗ DIRECTORIES stale row '115' actual=0x01
✗ DIRECTORIES stale row '118' actual=0x01
✗ DIRECTORIES stale row '77' actual=0x01
✗ DIRECTORIES stale row '82' actual=0x01
Run atomic doctor repair-native-indexes to rebuild derived caches atomically from graph and change facts.
✗ Internal error: native derived-index verification found 64 problem(s)
Hint: This appears to be a bug. Please report it at: https://github.com/atomicdotdev/atomic/issues
b$ cd /2026/hcc && atomic doctor repair-native-indexes
cd /2026/hcc && atomic doctor check
ℹ Rebuilding native derived indexes from graph authority...
✓ Repaired 64 native derived-index problem(s); wrote 508 rows atomically; journaled as operation HTZNEYRY6XDS2JFDJ3NRZIFYOGCMUTECPII2NDGUSMIYY36ALEIQ.
ℹ Verifying native derived indexes against graph authority...
✓ Native derived indexes are consistent (508 rows).
Verifying working-copy consistency against the graph...
ℹ Checked 46 clean file(s); 0 with uncommitted edits skipped; 0 conflicted.
✓ Working copy is consistent with the graph.
That message seems encouraging, but Claude still can't record anything after this check. Claude reports:
Why nothing has recorded: every atomic record here fails with:
✗ atomic:CHANGE_REJECTED: Repository error: Invalid operation: tree projection kind for inode 106 disagrees with DIRECTORIES
- The end-of-turn hook almost certainly hits the same error. Its failures are hidden, which is why nothing has been recorded since 01:07.
- I re-ran atomic doctor check in /2026/hcc and it passes (534 rows consistent).
- Recording only plothc.py, plot_voltage_state.py, reconstruct_vctcxo_zcticks.py and .atomicignore gives the same error, so it isn't caused by the new or re-added files.
- Before the repair, inode 106 was one of the directory entries the doctor flagged ("DIRECTORIES stale row '106'"). Its current check doesn't look at whatever is still inconsistent, so
repair-native-indexes doesn't fix it.I've stopped trying further atomic repairs. I don't know atomic's internals well enough to guess safely, and these commands change the shared repository.
Suggested next steps:
- Report it to atomic. Their error message asks for that (https://github.com/atomicdotdev/atomic/issues). Include the record error above and the doctor output you pasted.
Is this a bug, or should I just be trying "atomic doctor reconcile-working-copy"?
Activity
leefaus commentedon Oct 28, 2026
2 things:
atomic --version