You signed in with another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.You signed out in another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.You switched accounts on another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.Dismiss alert
{{ message }}
Repository navigation
Clarification required for SurfaceDiceMetric #5906
It indeed says it computes the "Normalized Surface Distance (NSD)" intially and later it says it computes the "(Normalized) Surface Dice (NSD)". It then refers to https://github.com/deepmind/surface-distance which does not provide a metric called "Normalized Surface Distance" or "Normalized Surface Dice".
The DeepMind repo however provides a Surface Dice (with compute_surface_dice_at_tolerance) which may be what SurfaceDiceMetric implements but compute_surface_dice_at_tolerance requires a tolerance as input whereas SurfaceDiceMetric does not. It's thus unclear how these can be the same.
I had a quick discussion with @mjorgecardoso and Michela about NSD in the medical segmentation decathlon (https://doi.org/10.1038/s41467-022-30695-9). They confirmed that what they refer to as NSD in the challenge is the same as the Surface Dice in the Deepmind repo (compute_surface_dice_at_tolerance) and the Surface Dice Similarity Coefficient in section 2.2 of https://arxiv.org/abs/1809.04430
I further assume that what MONAI refers to as class_thresholds is actually similar to what the other source call "tolerance". However class_thresholds is given in pixels/voxels rather than milimetres. This makes is harder to relate. Also, it's unclear to me how anisotropix voxels would be handled. If this is a limitation of MONAI's implementation, it would be worth highlighting.
Given that the NSD acronym has been used in a few existing challenges, it may be worth keeping it in MONAI as well but maybe expand it to "Normalized Surface Dice" to improve clarity.
Activity
Nic-Ma commentedon Jan 27, 2023
Hi @yiheng-wang-nv ,
Could you please help take a look at this ticket?
Thanks in advance.
tvercaut commentedon Jan 27, 2023
I had a quick discussion with @mjorgecardoso and Michela about NSD in the medical segmentation decathlon (https://doi.org/10.1038/s41467-022-30695-9). They confirmed that what they refer to as NSD in the challenge is the same as the Surface Dice in the Deepmind repo (
compute_surface_dice_at_tolerance) and the Surface Dice Similarity Coefficient in section 2.2 of https://arxiv.org/abs/1809.04430I further assume that what MONAI refers to as
class_thresholdsis actually similar to what the other source call "tolerance". Howeverclass_thresholdsis given in pixels/voxels rather than milimetres. This makes is harder to relate. Also, it's unclear to me how anisotropix voxels would be handled. If this is a limitation of MONAI's implementation, it would be worth highlighting.Given that the NSD acronym has been used in a few existing challenges, it may be worth keeping it in MONAI as well but maybe expand it to "Normalized Surface Dice" to improve clarity.
extend SurfaceDiceMetric for 3D images (#6549)