You signed in with another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.You signed out in another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.You switched accounts on another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.Dismiss alert
{{ message }}
This repository was archived by the owner on Dec 21, 2024. It is now read-only.
Repository navigation
This repository was archived by the owner on Dec 21, 2024. It is now read-only.
SpigotMC has assessed that plugins calling SuggestPaper() are advertising #41
I raise this to suggest that the wording of the Paperlib.suggestPaper() be modified to not breach the SpigotMC advertising rules. I actually tried to get an idea from them as to what that actually is ...but I couldnt get answer. I think removing the link is probably a start. At the end of the day no alternative reliable and safe plugin marketplace exists. If plugins that call this method breach the guidelines they get removed and in the end they are not assisting spreading the word about Paper's benefits.
At the end of the day no alternative reliable and safe plugin marketplace exists
yet! am trying...
has somebody tried to approach spigot resource staff about this? the intend here isn't malicious for advertising, its to inform users (in a standardized manner) that the given plugin utilizes features of the paper api and thus runs noticeable better on paper servers. I view that in the same realm of a soft dependency. "hey my cool plugin a works better if you pair it with cool lib b". Its not telling everybody to install lib b, just suggesting that, in order to use the plugin in the way it was designed, its better to install it.
maybe the text could be reworded to put more emphasis on that? Put the "normal" benefits of paper a step back and put the actual benefits of the plugin into the foreground (while still mentioning stuff like timings v2, just put the focus elsewhere)
Any source for Spigot removing any plugin that runs this? Because I've never seen any removed due to it.
in typical spigot fashion rule enforcement isn't consistent. some mod seems to have had a bad day and send out a bunch of punishments (to authors that really only want the best for their users...)
Reacted by Frank van der Heijden, tadhgboyle and Matt
Easy, next to the rewording, make the suggestPaper() method not print anything if a file by the name .I_Really_Dont_Want_To_Use_Paper_Because_IDC_About_Performance is present in the plugin root, also removes immediately the "argument" of it being spam in the console.
It exists: -Dpaperlib.shown-benefits No clue whether it's actually documented - whether it's part of the plugin's "contract". It definitely isn't advertised in the "suggest message" itself, which is a poor choice if you ask me.
Unfortunately I doubt a flag will meet the guidelines of SpigotMC - what would be helpful is if someone where able to get a clear indication if any sort of Paper suggestion would not breach SpigotMC's guidelines. @SpigotMC could comment that would be great
I think the best approach would be, if a resource update gets rejected, reply to that and ask staff how to change the wording so that its covered by spigot rules but still convey the message of hey, if you do this, this plugin will be even nicer!
ok, so it seems like at least some ppl at spigot agree with my viewpoint that this is basically just saying that there is a soft dependency.
so, we should come up with a new message, that focuses on that fact more than just straight up advertising paper like it is right now. something like
"plugin will provide a better experience if you would use paper as your server software.
it would enable to usage of features such as async chunk loading, async teleportation and faster block state manipulation.
you can learn more about paper and its features and improvements here"
(I am bad at writing messages)
once we formulate a message that both plugin devs and the paper team likes, ill run that by spigot again and hopefully get their blessing, so that this can be resolved nicely.
soooooo any volunteers for coming up with such a message? :P
Reacted by HexedHero, LaurenceBarnes, Yannick Lamprecht, Olivia and Narimm
"This plugin optionally supports an extended API, Paper-API. Using a server software that supports this API will ensure you can enable the full features of this plugin. This includes advanced timings management, extended events, and asynchronous functions that will improve the speed at which this plugin can function, thus reducing the load on your hardware. You can read more here (link - not to a download page - info page like a gist or wiki that can be changed.)"
My suggesting would be that we mention that multiple forks support that API (officially and unofficially) This dilutes the argument its advertising,
The other option if SpigotMC was not willing to budge was to reverse it. I generally dislike negativity but it may actually be the only way any sort of message is allowed - it isn't advertising because it doesn't mention alternate server software.
"You are operating on server software that is not optimized and runs a reduced API that will increase the load on your CPU. Adittionally it runs a outdated version of /timings and is missing newer event classes that can improve functionality in this Plugin. Please contact your plugin support for more information. "
Reacted by Jacob Andersen, Malfrador and Titaniumtown
=================================================================================
KittehPlugin works better if you use Paper as your server software because
with Paper (https://papermc.io) present, it makes use of the following features:
* Asynchronous chunk loading
* Asynchronous teleporting
* Raw byte item serialization
=================================================================================
Reacted by Josua Parks, Josh Roy, Jacob Andersen, Malfrador, Olivia, MiniDigger | Martin, TheBusyBiscuit, James Harrell, Daniil Zao., das_ and 2 more
=================================================================================
KittehPlugin is running on server software that is not as feature-rich as one that provides the Paper API.
There are numerous benefits to using a server software with Paper support (such as one of these: <link to page of all (safe/recommended, i.e. not Yatopia or any other 'dangerous' impl>).
Specifically, this plugin is currently unable to use the following features:
* Asynchronous chunk loading
* Asynchronous teleporting
* Raw byte item serialization
=================================================================================
changed the title [-]SpigotMC has assed that plugings calling SuggestPaper() are advertising[/-][+]SpigotMC has asked that plugings calling SuggestPaper() are advertising[/+]on Feb 28, 2021
changed the title [-]SpigotMC has asked that plugings calling SuggestPaper() are advertising[/-][+]SpigotMC has asked that plugins calling SuggestPaper() are advertising[/+]on Feb 28, 2021
changed the title [-]SpigotMC has asked that plugins calling SuggestPaper() are advertising[/-][+]SpigotMC has assessed that plugins calling SuggestPaper() are advertising[/+]on Feb 28, 2021
=================================================================================
KittehPlugin is running on server software that is not as feature-rich as one that provides the Paper API.
There are numerous benefits to using a server software with Paper support (such as one of these: <link to page of all (safe/recommended, i.e. not Yatopia or any other 'dangerous' impl>).
Specifically, this plugin is currently unable to use the following features:
* Asynchronous chunk loading
* Asynchronous teleporting
* Raw byte item serialization
=================================================================================
I think this might be the way to go - Mini did you want to propose it to Choco?
Activity
HexedHero commentedon Feb 18, 2021
Any source for Spigot removing any plugin that runs this? Because I've never seen any removed due to it.
MiniDigger commentedon Feb 18, 2021
yet! am trying...
has somebody tried to approach spigot resource staff about this? the intend here isn't malicious for advertising, its to inform users (in a standardized manner) that the given plugin utilizes features of the paper api and thus runs noticeable better on paper servers. I view that in the same realm of a soft dependency. "hey my cool plugin a works better if you pair it with cool lib b". Its not telling everybody to install lib b, just suggesting that, in order to use the plugin in the way it was designed, its better to install it.
maybe the text could be reworded to put more emphasis on that? Put the "normal" benefits of paper a step back and put the actual benefits of the plugin into the foreground (while still mentioning stuff like timings v2, just put the focus elsewhere)
in typical spigot fashion rule enforcement isn't consistent. some mod seems to have had a bad day and send out a bunch of punishments (to authors that really only want the best for their users...)
FrankHeijden commentedon Feb 18, 2021
Easy, next to the rewording, make the
suggestPaper()method not print anything if a file by the name.I_Really_Dont_Want_To_Use_Paper_Because_IDC_About_Performanceis present in the plugin root, also removes immediately the "argument" of it being spam in the console.katekerllenevich commentedon Feb 18, 2021
It would make more sense to add a startup flag for that like
-DPaperLib.dontSuggestPaper=trueTrigary commentedon Feb 18, 2021
It exists:
-Dpaperlib.shown-benefitsNo clue whether it's actually documented - whether it's part of the plugin's "contract". It definitely isn't advertised in the "suggest message" itself, which is a poor choice if you ask me.Narimm commentedon Feb 21, 2021
Unfortunately I doubt a flag will meet the guidelines of SpigotMC - what would be helpful is if someone where able to get a clear indication if any sort of Paper suggestion would not breach SpigotMC's guidelines. @SpigotMC could comment that would be great
MiniDigger commentedon Feb 21, 2021
does pinging an org even do anything? lol
I think the best approach would be, if a resource update gets rejected, reply to that and ask staff how to change the wording so that its covered by spigot rules but still convey the message of hey, if you do this, this plugin will be even nicer!
Narimm commentedon Feb 21, 2021
I did I got told I was trying to bypass the report
MiniDigger commentedon Feb 21, 2021
many helpful, such wow. ill try talking to somebody at spigot
MiniDigger commentedon Feb 21, 2021
ok, so it seems like at least some ppl at spigot agree with my viewpoint that this is basically just saying that there is a soft dependency.
so, we should come up with a new message, that focuses on that fact more than just straight up advertising paper like it is right now. something like
"plugin will provide a better experience if you would use paper as your server software.
it would enable to usage of features such as async chunk loading, async teleportation and faster block state manipulation.
you can learn more about paper and its features and improvements here"
(I am bad at writing messages)
once we formulate a message that both plugin devs and the paper team likes, ill run that by spigot again and hopefully get their blessing, so that this can be resolved nicely.
soooooo any volunteers for coming up with such a message? :P
Remove suggest Paper
Narimm commentedon Feb 23, 2021
"This plugin optionally supports an extended API, Paper-API. Using a server software that supports this API will ensure you can enable the full features of this plugin. This includes advanced timings management, extended events, and asynchronous functions that will improve the speed at which this plugin can function, thus reducing the load on your hardware. You can read more here (link - not to a download page - info page like a gist or wiki that can be changed.)"
My suggesting would be that we mention that multiple forks support that API (officially and unofficially) This dilutes the argument its advertising,
The other option if SpigotMC was not willing to budge was to reverse it. I generally dislike negativity but it may actually be the only way any sort of message is allowed - it isn't advertising because it doesn't mention alternate server software.
"You are operating on server software that is not optimized and runs a reduced API that will increase the load on your CPU. Adittionally it runs a outdated version of /timings and is missing newer event classes that can improve functionality in this Plugin. Please contact your plugin support for more information. "
mbax commentedon Feb 28, 2021
Idea: Plugins specify exactly which features require Paper.
Plugin usage:
With those being String constants.
In console:
jacobsandersen commentedon Feb 28, 2021
Chiming in to say I think a combo of @Narimm's message and @mbax's idea for enumerating the benefits would be really nice.
i.e.:
[-]SpigotMC has assed that plugings calling SuggestPaper() are advertising[/-][+]SpigotMC has asked that plugings calling SuggestPaper() are advertising[/+][-]SpigotMC has asked that plugings calling SuggestPaper() are advertising[/-][+]SpigotMC has asked that plugins calling SuggestPaper() are advertising[/+][-]SpigotMC has asked that plugins calling SuggestPaper() are advertising[/-][+]SpigotMC has assessed that plugins calling SuggestPaper() are advertising[/+]Narimm commentedon Mar 3, 2021
I think this might be the way to go - Mini did you want to propose it to Choco?