blockexpr "return" keyword selection #3

Activity

1. curiosity-a commented on Nov 24, 2021

   

   curiosity-a

   on Nov 24, 2021

   Last edited by curiosity-a

   More actions

   First of all, let's get this out of the way: result should not be a keyword. It is traditionally used as an identifier and should remain that way.

   Personally, I don't like leave, it doesn't have the connotation of returning a value. And exit has the connotation of ending the entire program.

   Now for my suggestions:

   • submit
   • produce
   • serve

   I don't have a clear preference among these three (although I'm not so sure about submit). I selected these words because they have the connotation of returning a value, at least in my opinion.
2. JanSharp commented on Nov 24, 2021

   

   JanSharp

   on Nov 24, 2021

   Last edited by JanSharp

   OwnerAuthor

   More actions

   Yea no, result will definitely not be it.

   Agreed on leave and exit, that's why I also don't like them.

   submit is a bit similar to result imo where in normal code it already has common meaning, mostly as a submit button. It's better than leave for sure, but still problematic.
   Unfortunately serve is problematic due to politics (or whichever the right term for it is). "recently" git moved the default branch name from "master" to "main" (decided by the community) due to the "master" "slave" terminology. "serve" can very easily be put in the same boat, so I'd rather stay away from that.

   I like produce. I see very few issues with that.

   With all that said, thanks a lot for the input, and my current candidates are

   • break - simple and sweet
   • produce - describes the concept of resulting in values
   • retreat - incredibly similar to return but still different

   There are downsides and upsides to all of those, so I'm still not sure. Definitely better than my initial thoughts though
3. curiosity-a commented on Nov 24, 2021

   

   curiosity-a

   on Nov 24, 2021

   More actions

   break depends a lot on if you are going to introduce the classical break functionality and how. It may clash with that. And there is always the connotation of that functionality.

   retreat I saw on Discord, but didn't like it. Did't sound fitting. I think it's because it implies moving away, not from one thing to another. Speaking of which, new series of candidates:

   • transfer
   • pass
   • convey