[JacobStephens2]

Summary

The #429 grilling log, brought up to date. Docs only: no code and no CONTEXT.md change.

 .scratch/grill-with-docs/429-multi-family-review.md
   Round 1–7 (answered)
+  Round 8 (answered)   which review skill the replays use, the order of the sessions, fresh Codex sub-agents, reverse plan and bug replays
+  Round 9 (answered)   Claude's Effort by role, and the revised plan
+  Round 10 (answered)  when /to-spec and /to-tickets run
   Settled by earlier answers    + about 10 consequences, 3 brought up to date
+  Research results (2026-10-09) Codex's sub-agents, plans, Specs and bugs; kept reports; the pre-#486 skill commit
   Filed                         + #616, the rewrite of #429, and this PR

What changed in the replay plan:

• The six-bug and reverse bug replays use today's review skill. The Spec replay stays on 479a1fb, to match its recorded baseline.
• The reverse plan replay checks 20 of Codex's 27 plans, with a bar of 3.
• A reverse bug replay covers Codex's three bugs (CI red on issue-427: test-macos #559, Report reproduction failures separately from completed Security audits #603, Security review: surface the session's reason when it deliberately ends incomplete #607).
• Claude runs at max as the baseline and at high as the Second opinion being tried. Codex runs at xhigh.
• The Claude sessions run first, alongside Weeding. Weeding pauses only for the Codex and new-Harness sessions.

One correction the log records: Weeding first ran on Codex on 6 October, not 5 October.

Evidence

• Before: main has the log through Round 7, 407 lines.
• After: the log through Round 10, 569 lines. One file changed, 169 insertions and 7 deletions.

Merge Danger

Door: two-way

Blast Radius: none

No command reads this scratch log.

🤖 Generated with Claude Code