[JacobStephens2]

Summary

Review / Fix Pass -> main + release-* -> skip
explicit Fix     -> repair release PR as requested
Session commands -> release / tag push -> destructive-command signal
tag push         -> owner + exact Cargo bump from origin/main
                 -> plan -> build -> host -> publish
Day shift wizard -> Admin-only creation/updates + no-deletion v* rules

Closes #2156. Targets issue-2054.

Evidence

Execution evidence

• Review admission — cargo test --test review_pass author_pass_skips_release_bumps_into_main_only
  • Before: assertion failed: state["prs"][selected]["postedComments"].is_array(); 1 failed.
  • After: 1 passed. Checks exclusion into main and eligibility into another base.
• Fix admission and explicit target — cargo test --test fix_pass passes_skip_release_bumps_but_explicit_fix_still_repairs_them
  • Before: left: None, right: Some("repaired\n"); 1 failed because the ordinary PR was not repaired.
  • After: 1 passed. Covers author-scoped and unscoped Passes, another base, and explicit --no-merge --no-base-fix repair of the skipped release PR.
• Session signals — cargo test --test metrics destructive_command_patterns_flag_fixture_commands_but_not_near_misses
  • Before: assertion `left == right` failed; release/tag-push flags absent.
  • After: 1 passed, including near misses, wrappers, refspecs, deletion and follow-tags.
• Workflow generation — python3 -m unittest discover -s scripts -p test_generate_release.py
  • Before: AssertionError: " - 'processes/**'" not found.
  • After: 10 tests passed, including disposable Git fixtures for exact trees, actors, dependency/source changes, version disagreement and file modes.
• Push event identity — python3 -m unittest discover -s scripts -p test_generate_release.py -k moved_since
  • Before: AssertionError: 0 == 0 (a mismatched push event was accepted).
  • After: 1 passed.
• python3 scripts/generate-release.py --check passes against the regenerated workflow.
• python3 -m unittest discover -s scripts -p 'test_*.py': 72 passed.
• bash -n scripts/setup-release-tags.sh passes. shellcheck -e SC1087,SC2317 scripts/setup-release-tags.sh passes; exclusions concern the required unchanged wizard library. Tests never mutate live rulesets; the owner performs and verifies browser changes interactively.
• scripts/affected-tests refs/remotes/origin/issue-2054: site checks passed (69 tests, 174.26s). The local Rust run compiled in 6m 43s and was stopped after successful CI covered the exact head, following docs/testing.md's CI reuse policy. An earlier selector attempt was terminated during site checks; the site rerun passed.
• CI run passed for 04bf9bc6b5121bda9dfee469e6b8ec3fddfc2a19: all four Rust partitions, the coverage gate, Console and site checks.
• Release workflow passed for the same head, including both MUSL artifact builds and release smoke checks. The PR path exercised guard admission; tag-push actor/tree rejection is covered by the local Git fixtures.

Visual evidence

Documentation captures use the same expanded sections at 1440×900 and 390×844. Before captures are from 4d24f79d in a temporary detached worktree; binary evidence is hosted in a secret Gist.

Homepage: Skills and Processes

Desktop (1440×900)

Mobile (390×844)

How it works: scheduled Passes

Desktop (1440×900)

Mobile (390×844)

Architecture: Pass admission

Desktop (1440×900)

Mobile (390×844)

Manual: release fences

Desktop (1440×900)

Mobile (390×844)

Seams under test

• Black-box Review and Fix CLI Pass admission, plus explicit targeted Fix delivery, with real Git and fake GitHub/Harness services.
• Session signals exposed by thirdshift show --json from recorded command streams.
• Release generator CLI output/check mode and the generated tag guard executed against disposable Git repositories.
• Wizard shell syntax and static review; no live ruleset writes in tests.

Review coverage

thirdshift-code-review compared refs/remotes/origin/issue-2054...HEAD (4d24f79d base). Standards: 0 findings; Spec: 0 findings. Each reviewer read all 16 changed files, including generated workflow/manual hunks. No generated exclusions and no changed files left unread on either axis. Full reports and each axis's files-read list are retained with this Session.

Unaddressed findings

Standards

None.

Spec

None.

Security

None.

Security review outcome

No unaddressed introduced findings.

Merge Danger

Door: two-way

Revert the code/workflow to undo the implementation. The wizard changes no settings itself; the owner manages repository rulesets separately.

Blast Radius: release

Background eligibility changes only for release-* heads into main. Tag publication now waits for the owner/tree gate; the wizard still needs to be run by the owner to provision or verify repository tag protection.

Built with codex codex-cli 0.167.1 · gpt-6.1-sol · xhigh

[JacobStephens2]

Review run. No fixes to push. Spec axis used the pull request body alone; no closing issue was linked.

Reviewed PR #2161 at 04bf9bc6 against 4d24f79d170c8e72be238f405efc4d3215962375. The PR remains open. No fixes were needed, no tracked files changed, and no commit was created.

Standards

0 findings. No documented-standard violations or actionable code smells.

Coverage: all 16 changed files read directly, including generated output. No exclusions or unread changed files.

Final files-read list — Standards

AGENTS.md
CODING_STANDARDS.md
.agents/skills/codebase-design/SKILL.md
.agents/skills/thirdshift-code-review/SKILL.md
.agents/skills/wizard/SKILL.md
GLOSSARY.md
docs/agents/domain.md
docs/code-navigation.md
docs/testing.md
docs/adr/0003-static-binaries-through-github-releases.md
docs/adr/0019-session-logs-become-session-traces.md
docs/adr/0029-in-progress-marks-only-a-live-run.md
.github/workflows/release.yml
README.md
docs/guide.md
scripts/generate-release.py
scripts/release-tag-guard.py
scripts/setup-release-tags.sh
scripts/test_generate_release.py
scripts/release.sh
site/architecture/index.html
site/docs/index.html
site/how-it-works/index.html
site/index.html
src/github/review.rs
src/logs/session_signals/destructive.rs
tests/fix_pass.rs
tests/fixtures/destructive-commands.json
tests/review_pass.rs

Spec

0 findings. Admission rules, explicit Fix behavior, command signals, release gating, wizard policy, and documentation match the PR body.

The PR body alone was the Spec source: the supplied input contained no linked closing issues, and GitHub confirmed closingIssuesReferences: []. No comments were fetched.

Coverage: all 16 changed files read directly. No generated-output exclusions or unread changed files.

Final files-read list — Spec

.thirdshift-review-input.md
AGENTS.md
CODING_STANDARDS.md
GLOSSARY.md
.agents/skills/codebase-design/SKILL.md
.agents/skills/thirdshift-code-review/SKILL.md
docs/agents/domain.md
docs/code-navigation.md
docs/adr/0003-static-binaries-through-github-releases.md
docs/adr/0004-self-merge-by-thirdshift-not-github-auto-merge.md
docs/adr/0013-every-harness-runs-unattended-and-fully-trusted.md
.github/workflows/release.yml
README.md
docs/guide.md
scripts/generate-release.py
scripts/release-tag-guard.py
scripts/release.sh
scripts/setup-release-tags.sh
scripts/test_generate_release.py
site/architecture/index.html
site/docs/index.html
site/how-it-works/index.html
site/index.html
src/args.rs
src/github/review.rs
src/logs/session_signals/destructive.rs
tests/fix_pass.rs
tests/fixtures/destructive-commands.json
tests/metrics.rs
tests/review_pass.rs

Unaddressed findings

• Standards: None.
• Spec: None.

Validation

All required validation ran in this worktree.

Exact command	Exit	Result
scripts/affected-tests 4d24f79d170c8e72be238f405efc4d3215962375	0	All selected checks passed
npm test --prefix site	0	69 tests passed; includes manual freshness check
cargo test	0	4,519 passed, 199 ignored, 0 failed across 106 binaries
python3 -m unittest discover -s scripts -p test_generate_release.py	0	10 passed
python3 -m unittest discover -s scripts -p 'test_*.py'	0	72 passed
bash -n scripts/setup-release-tags.sh	0	Syntax passed
git diff --check	0	Passed
npm ci --prefix site	0	Dependencies installed
npx --prefix site playwright install --with-deps chromium	0	Browser dependencies ready

cargo nextest --version exited 101 because nextest is unavailable; the selector used cargo test. No required validation remained unrun. The full Rust run exercised and passed the new Review admission, Fix admission/explicit-target, and destructive-command fixture tests.

Saved: Standards report, Spec report, summary.json, and validation log.

Standards: 0 findings, no worst issue. Spec: 0 findings, no worst issue.

Security

No unaddressed introduced findings.

CI passed or absent at 04bf9bc