[JacobStephens2]

Summary

Documentation only: the #1484 grill, the decisions it reached, and the research behind them. Specs #1484 and #1872 cite these files.

 GLOSSARY.md                        # Arm names a Process; Trial may be many sessions;
                                    # Bar fixes who grades; new term: Grader panel
 docs/adr/
+├── 0027-a-trial-carries-out-a-process-but-is-not-a-command.md
+└── 0028-who-decides-a-verdict-is-fixed-in-the-bar.md
 docs/grill-with-docs/done/
+└── 1484-implement-suite.md        # 10 rounds, Q1.1–Q10.2
 docs/research/
+├── eval-process-arms-and-human-review.md   # Langfuse et al., external runners, blind review
+└── eval-grader-panel.md                    # same-family Graders, panel size, Kimi/DeepSeek Harnesses

What the grill decided, and where it was published:

• Spec Spec: process Trials and a code-graded implement Eval suite #1484 (Tickets Put the Process engine's GitHub, Claim and pull-request use behind one seam #1873–Check Trial transcripts for the real fix #1880): Arms that name a Process, and Trials that carry it out up to Delivery, graded by the real fix's tests.
• Spec Spec: blind pairwise grading of process Trials by a Grader panel and people #1872 (Tickets Run base-tests and cross-tests for each pair of Trials #1881–Count the panel or people in the Verdict, with seeded samples for several readers #1886): blind pairwise grading by a Grader panel and people, with the Bar deciding who counts.
• Release #1484 and build the first 20 discriminating process Eval tasks #1887 releases Spec: process Trials and a code-graded implement Eval suite #1484 and builds the first tasks. Add a Kimi Code CLI Harness #1888 adds a Kimi CLI Harness. Spec: Custom-runner Arms for process Experiments #1468 is narrowed to an external-runner Arm.

Evidence

Execution evidence

No code changes. scripts/affected-tests origin/main selects the whole cargo test suite (the glossary changed). thirdshift is Linux-only, so it runs in the Lima VM. The result is in a comment below, and CI runs it too.

Merge Danger

Door: two-way

Revert the commit. The Specs would then cite missing files.

Blast Radius: documentation

The glossary wording for Arm, Trial and Bar changes for every agent that reads it. The new wording describes behaviour #1484 and #1872 will build, so today's code doesn't yet match the Arm's Process clause, a multi-session Trial or the Bar's grading settings.

[JacobStephens2]

Execution evidence: scripts/affected-tests origin/main at fd89f44, run on Ubuntu 24.04 aarch64 in the Lima VM. Every changed file triggered a conservative full-suite selection, which ran cargo test → PASS in 999 s (3929 passed, 0 failed, 91 ignored).