You signed in with another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.You signed out in another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.You switched accounts on another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.Dismiss alert
{{ message }}
This repository was archived by the owner on Nov 6, 2023. It is now read-only.
Repository navigation
This repository was archived by the owner on Nov 6, 2023. It is now read-only.
Based on the spreadsheet, I suppose that the we can safely make trivial rules for those domains which Enforces HTTPS is set to true, and HSTS is set to anything but Yes, and preloaded. The category Uses HTTPS is probably quite a lower barrier covering any range of configurations.
Uses HTTPS means that the site can be reached over HTTPS, which does mean that https->http downgrades don't count, but it also means that, for example, senate.gov has a Yes for Uses HTTPS. So yeah, I wouldn't use that.
Enforces HTTPS is pretty strict and means that the domain appear to redirect its "endpoints" (http:// and http://www) to an https:// version. It only requires one of https:// or https://www to be up. I think you could safely use that, though it's possible there's an edge case I'm not thinking of.
If HSTS is Yes, it means that the domain's "canonical" endpoint has HSTS on it. This could mean, for example, that https://www.example.gov has an HSTS policy on it but https://example.gov does not, if the canonical endpoint for the domain uses www. In fact, https://example.gov could easily have a certificate not valid for its hostname, while http://example.gov redirects successfully to https://www.example.gov.
If HSTS is Yes, and preload-ready, it means that the root has the right HSTS policy to be preloaded, like https://example.gov, regardless of whether the "canonical" endpoint for the domain uses www. But it means it's not in the preload list at the moment, for whatever reason.
If HSTS is Yes, and preloaded then it's in the preload list.
This methodology is documented at a high level on https://pulse.cio.gov/https/guidance/. It's possible it could change, or that the implementation could change in some subtle way. I don't want to recommend one way or the other that you incorporate the results from pulse.cio.gov, but I do want you to have the information you need to decide if it's helpful.
Activity
Hainish commentedon Jun 8, 2016
Based on the spreadsheet, I suppose that the we can safely make trivial rules for those domains which
Enforces HTTPSis set totrue, andHSTSis set to anything butYes, and preloaded. The categoryUses HTTPSis probably quite a lower barrier covering any range of configurations.Perhaps @konklone can speak to this.
konklone commentedon Jun 8, 2016
Uses HTTPSmeans that the site can be reached over HTTPS, which does mean that https->http downgrades don't count, but it also means that, for example, senate.gov has aYesforUses HTTPS. So yeah, I wouldn't use that.Enforces HTTPSis pretty strict and means that the domain appear to redirect its "endpoints" (http://andhttp://www) to anhttps://version. It only requires one ofhttps://orhttps://wwwto be up. I think you could safely use that, though it's possible there's an edge case I'm not thinking of.If
HSTSisYes, it means that the domain's "canonical" endpoint has HSTS on it. This could mean, for example, thathttps://www.example.govhas an HSTS policy on it buthttps://example.govdoes not, if the canonical endpoint for the domain useswww. In fact,https://example.govcould easily have a certificate not valid for its hostname, whilehttp://example.govredirects successfully tohttps://www.example.gov.If
HSTSisYes, and preload-ready, it means that the root has the right HSTS policy to be preloaded, likehttps://example.gov, regardless of whether the "canonical" endpoint for the domain useswww. But it means it's not in the preload list at the moment, for whatever reason.If
HSTSisYes, and preloadedthen it's in the preload list.This methodology is documented at a high level on https://pulse.cio.gov/https/guidance/. It's possible it could change, or that the implementation could change in some subtle way. I don't want to recommend one way or the other that you incorporate the results from pulse.cio.gov, but I do want you to have the information you need to decide if it's helpful.
Hainish commentedon Jun 8, 2016
Thank you @konklone all this info is very helpful.