From a48c7ea6026961839b88c3b250b92f4f35beed3c Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: MrScripty Date: Fri, 13 Nov 2026 18:39:31 -0700 Subject: [PATCH 1/4] chore(evidence): retire the last hand-listed metadata check release-maintenance-policy/metadata-closure validated a hand-typed list of 12 module paths. The whole-corpus check canonical-corpus-metadata/ canonical-corpus already validates all 74 canonical modules through the same call, so the listed check could not fail for a reason the corpus check does not also report. A mutation test confirmed it: 48 metadata defects across the 12 listed modules failed both checks with the same diagnostic each time. The retirement was made by the Engine's maintain_evidence operation (preview, then apply), not by hand. Retiring the only check emptied the suite, so the Engine also removed the suite, its registry entry and its enforcement-suite node in the policy-impact catalogue. No relationship named the node or the suite, so none changed. Fifty-five sibling checks were retired earlier; this one was held back because the node catalogue digest is part of every coverage requirement. Removing the node changes all 53 requirement IDs and turns the 16 current certificates stale. The owner has accepted that; the certificates are left in place and reissued in a later commit, each after review. docs/audits/metadata-closure-retirement-2026-11-13.md is the review record supplied to the operation. Suites 24 -> 23, checks 67 -> 66, catalogue nodes 122 -> 121, certificates current/stale 16/8 -> 0/24. Co-Authored-By: Claude Fable 5.2 --- .../metadata-closure-retirement-2026-11-13.md | 75 +++ .../generated/suite-inputs.json | 88 +--- .../policy-impact-node-catalog.toml | 491 +++++++++++++++++- .../suite-registry.toml | 5 - .../suites/release-maintenance-policy.toml | 9 - 5 files changed, 569 insertions(+), 99 deletions(-) create mode 100644 docs/audits/metadata-closure-retirement-2026-11-13.md delete mode 100644 evaluation/standards-effectiveness/suites/release-maintenance-policy.toml diff --git a/docs/audits/metadata-closure-retirement-2026-11-13.md b/docs/audits/metadata-closure-retirement-2026-11-13.md new file mode 100644 index 00000000..ed4f5a95 --- /dev/null +++ b/docs/audits/metadata-closure-retirement-2026-11-13.md @@ -0,0 +1,75 @@ +# Retirement of the last hand-listed metadata check + +Reviewed revision `a5e8bf7ee4f29ba14826df1ce363bef13fbe2963`. This is the review +record supplied to the Engine's `maintain_evidence` operation for the retirement +below. It records what was checked before the retirement; it is not a coverage +attestation. + +## Decision + +On 2026-11-13 the repository owner decided to retire +`release-maintenance-policy/metadata-closure` and accepted that the coverage +certificates it invalidates are reissued afterwards, each after its own review. +Fifty-five sibling checks were retired on 2026-11-12; this one was held back +only because of that certificate effect. + +## What is retired + +| Item | Disposition | +| --- | --- | +| Check `release-maintenance-policy/metadata-closure` | Retired. It ran `metadata_graph` over a hand-typed list of 12 module paths. | +| Suite `release-maintenance-policy` | Retired by the Engine because it has no other check. | +| Registry entry for that suite | Removed with the suite. | +| Catalogue node `release-maintenance-policy` (`enforcement-suite`) | Removed with the suite. | + +The suite required `release-reference-closure`, which stays registered with its +own checks. No registered suite requires `release-maintenance-policy`. + +## Why the check is redundant + +The check `canonical-corpus-metadata/canonical-corpus` validates every member of +`evaluation/standards-effectiveness/canonical-module-corpus.toml` through the same +`validate_module_metadata` call the retired check used. + +- All 12 listed paths are among the 74 corpus members. +- Mutation test on a scratch copy of the reviewed revision: four defects + (a `Requires` target that does not exist, a removed `Level` line, a wrong + `Canonical owner` path, a `Specializes` target that does not exist) were + introduced one at a time into each of the 12 modules, 48 mutations in all. + The retired check failed 48 times. The whole-corpus check failed the same 48 + times with the same diagnostic code each time. No defect was reported by the + retired check alone. + +The retired check therefore could not fail for a reason the whole-corpus check +does not also report. + +## Graph and certificate effect + +- The removed node is neither the source nor the consumer of any policy-impact + relationship, and no relationship names `suite:release-maintenance-policy` as + its evidence owner. No relationship is removed or re-owned. +- The node catalogue digest is part of every coverage requirement. Removing a + node changes all 53 requirement IDs, so the 16 certificates that were current + at the reviewed revision become stale. The 8 certificates that were already + stale stay stale. +- Stale certificates are left in place (`prune_stale_certificates` is `false`). + A stale certificate is ignored when coverage is read; its policy unit reports + `review-required` until a new certificate is published for it. + +## Counts + +| | Before | After | +| --- | ---: | ---: | +| Registered suites | 24 | 23 | +| Checks | 67 | 66 | +| Catalogue nodes | 122 | 121 | +| Certificates current / stale | 16 / 8 | 0 / 24 | + +## Engine operation + +`maintain_evidence` with this file as evidence, first with `apply: false` and +then with `apply: true`. Plan: `retire_checks` naming the one check; no suite, +input, description, relationship or consumer entries; +`replacement_evidence_owner` `review:consumer` (unused, because no relationship +names the retired suite). The Engine's candidate verification passed with 23 +suites and 66 checks. diff --git a/evaluation/standards-effectiveness/generated/suite-inputs.json b/evaluation/standards-effectiveness/generated/suite-inputs.json index 944e53e8..79709d3b 100644 --- a/evaluation/standards-effectiveness/generated/suite-inputs.json +++ b/evaluation/standards-effectiveness/generated/suite-inputs.json @@ -128,11 +128,6 @@ "role": "canonical-policy-impact", "suite": "policy-semantic-impact" }, - { - "check": "metadata-closure", - "role": "metadata", - "suite": "release-maintenance-policy" - }, { "check": "root-links", "role": "link-target", @@ -1486,7 +1481,7 @@ ] }, { - "digest": "sha256:fc176982992241069f3bbb40173fd7176e10d5c9fdc1373a16c88647819ad7c4", + "digest": "sha256:9d3ec990d2ee5a74bf1bb71db3619a3fa5c90288b5c5b809f2219efa22343062", "path": "evaluation/standards-effectiveness/policy-impact-node-catalog.toml", "state": "present", "uses": [ @@ -2158,7 +2153,7 @@ ] }, { - "digest": "sha256:af8f30134a34385b211429c7d325b9f0c233839ec8d49aee03f882f67aa69ca5", + "digest": "sha256:8634e8ae372621d80260a6006743ad8bdfe4a87cc5eccc944610448663862748", "path": "evaluation/standards-effectiveness/suite-registry.toml", "state": "present", "uses": [ @@ -2277,18 +2272,6 @@ } ] }, - { - "digest": "sha256:61760956e55a27d2333794a36514cdabf23ca2d73722a6f71c00fb7ffda53ea8", - "path": "evaluation/standards-effectiveness/suites/release-maintenance-policy.toml", - "state": "present", - "uses": [ - { - "check": "current-structure", - "role": "registered-policy-impact", - "suite": "policy-semantic-impact" - } - ] - }, { "digest": "sha256:7fea2ba620f744cee21fbd96edfff1fe2f88f43ce5d277a2edf4e0a3e979e9f7", "path": "evaluation/standards-effectiveness/suites/release-reference-closure.toml", @@ -8054,11 +8037,6 @@ "role": "canonical-policy-impact", "suite": "policy-semantic-impact" }, - { - "check": "metadata-closure", - "role": "metadata", - "suite": "release-maintenance-policy" - }, { "check": "root-router-routes", "role": "link-target", @@ -8263,11 +8241,6 @@ "role": "canonical-policy-impact", "suite": "policy-semantic-impact" }, - { - "check": "metadata-closure", - "role": "metadata", - "suite": "release-maintenance-policy" - }, { "check": "root-router-routes", "role": "link-target", @@ -8375,11 +8348,6 @@ "role": "canonical-policy-impact", "suite": "policy-semantic-impact" }, - { - "check": "metadata-closure", - "role": "metadata", - "suite": "release-maintenance-policy" - }, { "check": "root-router-routes", "role": "link-target", @@ -8437,11 +8405,6 @@ "role": "canonical-policy-impact", "suite": "policy-semantic-impact" }, - { - "check": "metadata-closure", - "role": "metadata", - "suite": "release-maintenance-policy" - }, { "check": "root-router-routes", "role": "link-target", @@ -8499,11 +8462,6 @@ "role": "canonical-policy-impact", "suite": "policy-semantic-impact" }, - { - "check": "metadata-closure", - "role": "metadata", - "suite": "release-maintenance-policy" - }, { "check": "root-router-routes", "role": "link-target", @@ -9886,11 +9844,6 @@ "role": "canonical-policy-impact", "suite": "policy-semantic-impact" }, - { - "check": "metadata-closure", - "role": "metadata", - "suite": "release-maintenance-policy" - }, { "check": "legacy-index-destinations", "role": "target", @@ -10008,11 +9961,6 @@ "role": "canonical-policy-impact", "suite": "policy-semantic-impact" }, - { - "check": "metadata-closure", - "role": "metadata", - "suite": "release-maintenance-policy" - }, { "check": "root-router-routes", "role": "link-target", @@ -10264,11 +10212,6 @@ "role": "canonical-policy-impact", "suite": "policy-semantic-impact" }, - { - "check": "metadata-closure", - "role": "metadata", - "suite": "release-maintenance-policy" - }, { "check": "root-router-routes", "role": "link-target", @@ -10416,11 +10359,6 @@ "role": "canonical-policy-impact", "suite": "policy-semantic-impact" }, - { - "check": "metadata-closure", - "role": "metadata", - "suite": "release-maintenance-policy" - }, { "check": "root-router-routes", "role": "link-target", @@ -10483,11 +10421,6 @@ "role": "canonical-policy-impact", "suite": "policy-semantic-impact" }, - { - "check": "metadata-closure", - "role": "metadata", - "suite": "release-maintenance-policy" - }, { "check": "root-router-routes", "role": "link-target", @@ -10550,11 +10483,6 @@ "role": "canonical-policy-impact", "suite": "policy-semantic-impact" }, - { - "check": "metadata-closure", - "role": "metadata", - "suite": "release-maintenance-policy" - }, { "check": "root-router-routes", "role": "link-target", @@ -10589,11 +10517,11 @@ } ], "registry": { - "digest": "sha256:af8f30134a34385b211429c7d325b9f0c233839ec8d49aee03f882f67aa69ca5", + "digest": "sha256:8634e8ae372621d80260a6006743ad8bdfe4a87cc5eccc944610448663862748", "path": "evaluation/standards-effectiveness/suite-registry.toml" }, "repository_index": { - "digest": "sha256:ae3843ae7d58b01dbbd6efb662286d52e4fc9c70f9c5e14bde04c0544d9b7d17", + "digest": "sha256:c2a56690ade32430a01832b2459f02feed2569f9d015abe1d08a10349ab23d36", "uses": [ { "check": "python-package-contract", @@ -10664,14 +10592,6 @@ "path": "evaluation/standards-effectiveness/suites/release-reference-closure.toml", "requires": [] }, - { - "digest": "sha256:61760956e55a27d2333794a36514cdabf23ca2d73722a6f71c00fb7ffda53ea8", - "id": "release-maintenance-policy", - "path": "evaluation/standards-effectiveness/suites/release-maintenance-policy.toml", - "requires": [ - "release-reference-closure" - ] - }, { "digest": "sha256:63cca2ceac227aacccf33a964801a645bb4083719e5011a46a313308f2628026", "id": "s1-routing", diff --git a/evaluation/standards-effectiveness/policy-impact-node-catalog.toml b/evaluation/standards-effectiveness/policy-impact-node-catalog.toml index 602ab4f0..3c3ba631 100644 --- a/evaluation/standards-effectiveness/policy-impact-node-catalog.toml +++ b/evaluation/standards-effectiveness/policy-impact-node-catalog.toml @@ -1,3 +1,492 @@ schema_version = 2 source_id = "standards.policy-impact-catalog" -nodes = [{ id = "prompts/full-codebase-standards-refactor.md", metadata = { artifact_kind = "prompt", authority = "projection", repository_path = "prompts/full-codebase-standards-refactor.md" } }, { id = "prompts/implement-plan.md", metadata = { artifact_kind = "prompt", authority = "projection", repository_path = "prompts/implement-plan.md" } }, { id = "prompts/planning.md", metadata = { artifact_kind = "prompt", authority = "projection", repository_path = "prompts/planning.md" } }, { id = "templates/PLAN-TEMPLATE.md", metadata = { artifact_kind = "template", authority = "projection", repository_path = "templates/PLAN-TEMPLATE.md" } }, { id = "evaluation/standards-effectiveness/verification-guide.md", metadata = { artifact_kind = "documentation", authority = "projection", repository_path = "evaluation/standards-effectiveness/verification-guide.md" } }, { id = "evaluation/standards-effectiveness/fixtures/planning/full-review-prompt-decisions.tsv", metadata = { artifact_kind = "fixture", authority = "evidence", repository_path = "evaluation/standards-effectiveness/fixtures/planning/full-review-prompt-decisions.tsv" } }, { aliases = ["evaluation/standards-effectiveness/suites/planning-consolidation.toml"], id = "planning-consolidation", metadata = { artifact_kind = "enforcement-suite", authority = "evidence", repository_path = "evaluation/standards-effectiveness/suites/planning-consolidation.toml", suite_id = "planning-consolidation" } }, { aliases = ["evaluation/standards-effectiveness/suites/policy-semantic-impact.toml"], id = "policy-semantic-impact", metadata = { artifact_kind = "enforcement-suite", authority = "evidence", repository_path = "evaluation/standards-effectiveness/suites/policy-semantic-impact.toml", suite_id = "policy-semantic-impact" } }, { aliases = ["evaluation/standards-effectiveness/suites/s1-routing.toml"], id = "s1-routing", metadata = { artifact_kind = "enforcement-suite", authority = "evidence", repository_path = "evaluation/standards-effectiveness/suites/s1-routing.toml", suite_id = "s1-routing" } }, { aliases = ["evaluation/standards-effectiveness/suites/release-maintenance-policy.toml"], id = "release-maintenance-policy", metadata = { artifact_kind = "enforcement-suite", authority = "evidence", repository_path = "evaluation/standards-effectiveness/suites/release-maintenance-policy.toml", suite_id = "release-maintenance-policy" } }, { id = "evaluation/standards-effectiveness/router-projection.toml", metadata = { artifact_kind = "routing-projection", authority = "projection", repository_path = "evaluation/standards-effectiveness/router-projection.toml" } }, { id = "evaluation/standards-effectiveness/fixtures/routing/generated-contract-decisions.tsv", metadata = { artifact_kind = "fixture", authority = "evidence", repository_path = "evaluation/standards-effectiveness/fixtures/routing/generated-contract-decisions.tsv" } }, { id = "evaluation/standards-effectiveness/fixtures/routing/generated-contract-routes.tsv", metadata = { artifact_kind = "fixture", authority = "evidence", repository_path = "evaluation/standards-effectiveness/fixtures/routing/generated-contract-routes.tsv" } }, { id = "evaluation/standards-effectiveness/fixtures/planning/systemic-finding-missing-audit.md", metadata = { artifact_kind = "fixture", authority = "evidence", repository_path = "evaluation/standards-effectiveness/fixtures/planning/systemic-finding-missing-audit.md" } }, { aliases = ["evaluation/standards-effectiveness/suites/standards-recovery-routing.toml"], id = "standards-recovery-routing", metadata = { artifact_kind = "enforcement-suite", authority = "evidence", repository_path = "evaluation/standards-effectiveness/suites/standards-recovery-routing.toml", suite_id = "standards-recovery-routing" } }, { aliases = ["evaluation/standards-effectiveness/suites/a1c-contract-conformance.toml"], id = "generated-contract-semantic-conformance", metadata = { artifact_kind = "enforcement-suite", authority = "evidence", repository_path = "evaluation/standards-effectiveness/suites/a1c-contract-conformance.toml", suite_id = "generated-contract-semantic-conformance" } }, { aliases = ["evaluation/standards-effectiveness/suites/a1c-public-cutover.toml"], id = "a1c-public-cutover", metadata = { artifact_kind = "enforcement-suite", authority = "evidence", repository_path = "evaluation/standards-effectiveness/suites/a1c-public-cutover.toml", suite_id = "a1c-public-cutover" } }, { id = "docs/archive/plans/standards-engine-standards-recovery/reports/json-schema-instance-equality-reproduction.md", metadata = { artifact_kind = "documentation", authority = "evidence", repository_path = "docs/archive/plans/standards-engine-standards-recovery/reports/json-schema-instance-equality-reproduction.md" } }, { id = "docs/archive/plans/standards-engine-standards-recovery/reports/historical-a1-repair-reproductions.md", metadata = { artifact_kind = "documentation", authority = "evidence", repository_path = "docs/archive/plans/standards-engine-standards-recovery/reports/historical-a1-repair-reproductions.md" } }, { id = "tools/standards_engine/contracts/a1-contract.schema.json", metadata = { artifact_kind = "implementation-artifact", authority = "evidence", repository_path = "tools/standards_engine/contracts/a1-contract.schema.json" } }, { id = "tools/standards_contracts/standards_contracts/projection.py", metadata = { artifact_kind = "implementation-artifact", authority = "evidence", repository_path = "tools/standards_contracts/standards_contracts/projection.py" } }, { id = "tools/standards_contracts/standards_contracts/compiler.py", metadata = { artifact_kind = "implementation-artifact", authority = "evidence", repository_path = "tools/standards_contracts/standards_contracts/compiler.py" } }, { id = "tools/standards_contracts/standards_contracts/runtime.py", metadata = { artifact_kind = "implementation-artifact", authority = "evidence", repository_path = "tools/standards_contracts/standards_contracts/runtime.py" } }, { id = "tools/standards_identity/standards_identity/encoding.py", metadata = { artifact_kind = "implementation-artifact", authority = "evidence", repository_path = "tools/standards_identity/standards_identity/encoding.py" } }, { id = "tools/standards_engine/standards_engine/_generated_contract.py", metadata = { artifact_kind = "implementation-artifact", authority = "evidence", repository_path = "tools/standards_engine/standards_engine/_generated_contract.py" } }, { id = "tools/standards_engine/standards_engine/__init__.py", metadata = { artifact_kind = "implementation-artifact", authority = "evidence", repository_path = "tools/standards_engine/standards_engine/__init__.py" } }, { id = "tools/standards_engine/standards_engine/tools.py", metadata = { artifact_kind = "implementation-artifact", authority = "evidence", repository_path = "tools/standards_engine/standards_engine/tools.py" } }, { id = "tools/standards_engine/standards_engine/engine.py", metadata = { artifact_kind = "implementation-artifact", authority = "evidence", repository_path = "tools/standards_engine/standards_engine/engine.py" } }, { id = "tools/standards_snapshots/standards_snapshots/store.py", metadata = { artifact_kind = "implementation-artifact", authority = "evidence", repository_path = "tools/standards_snapshots/standards_snapshots/store.py" } }, { id = "tools/standards_snapshots/standards_snapshots/module.py", metadata = { artifact_kind = "implementation-artifact", authority = "evidence", repository_path = "tools/standards_snapshots/standards_snapshots/module.py" } }, { id = "tools/standards_applicability/standards_applicability/core.py", metadata = { artifact_kind = "implementation-artifact", authority = "evidence", repository_path = "tools/standards_applicability/standards_applicability/core.py" } }, { id = "tools/standards_analysis/standards_analysis/kernel.py", metadata = { artifact_kind = "implementation-artifact", authority = "evidence", repository_path = "tools/standards_analysis/standards_analysis/kernel.py" } }, { id = "tools/standards_analysis/standards_analysis/state.py", metadata = { artifact_kind = "implementation-artifact", authority = "evidence", repository_path = "tools/standards_analysis/standards_analysis/state.py" } }, { id = "tools/standards_analysis/standards_analysis/trust.py", metadata = { artifact_kind = "implementation-artifact", authority = "evidence", repository_path = "tools/standards_analysis/standards_analysis/trust.py" } }, { id = "evaluation/standards-effectiveness/fixtures/contracts/a1c/python-package-imports.toml", metadata = { artifact_kind = "fixture", authority = "evidence", repository_path = "evaluation/standards-effectiveness/fixtures/contracts/a1c/python-package-imports.toml" } }, { id = "tools/graph_engine/graph_engine/__init__.py", metadata = { artifact_kind = "implementation-artifact", authority = "projection", repository_path = "tools/graph_engine/graph_engine/__init__.py" } }, { id = "tools/graph_engine/pyproject.toml", metadata = { artifact_kind = "implementation-artifact", authority = "projection", repository_path = "tools/graph_engine/pyproject.toml" } }, { id = "tools/query_edges.py", metadata = { artifact_kind = "implementation-artifact", authority = "projection", repository_path = "tools/query_edges.py" } }, { id = "tools/standards_analysis/pyproject.toml", metadata = { artifact_kind = "implementation-artifact", authority = "projection", repository_path = "tools/standards_analysis/pyproject.toml" } }, { id = "tools/standards_analysis/standards_analysis/__init__.py", metadata = { artifact_kind = "implementation-artifact", authority = "projection", repository_path = "tools/standards_analysis/standards_analysis/__init__.py" } }, { id = "tools/standards_applicability/pyproject.toml", metadata = { artifact_kind = "implementation-artifact", authority = "projection", repository_path = "tools/standards_applicability/pyproject.toml" } }, { id = "tools/standards_applicability/standards_applicability/__init__.py", metadata = { artifact_kind = "implementation-artifact", authority = "projection", repository_path = "tools/standards_applicability/standards_applicability/__init__.py" } }, { id = "tools/standards_snapshots/README.md", metadata = { artifact_kind = "documentation", authority = "projection", repository_path = "tools/standards_snapshots/README.md" } }, { id = "tools/repository_git/pyproject.toml", metadata = { artifact_kind = "implementation-artifact", authority = "projection", repository_path = "tools/repository_git/pyproject.toml" } }, { id = "tools/repository_git/repository_git/__init__.py", metadata = { artifact_kind = "implementation-artifact", authority = "projection", repository_path = "tools/repository_git/repository_git/__init__.py" } }, { id = "tools/standards_snapshots/pyproject.toml", metadata = { artifact_kind = "implementation-artifact", authority = "projection", repository_path = "tools/standards_snapshots/pyproject.toml" } }, { id = "tools/standards_snapshots/standards_snapshots/__init__.py", metadata = { artifact_kind = "implementation-artifact", authority = "projection", repository_path = "tools/standards_snapshots/standards_snapshots/__init__.py" } }, { id = "tools/repository_git/repository_git/repository.py", metadata = { artifact_kind = "implementation-artifact", authority = "projection", repository_path = "tools/repository_git/repository_git/repository.py" } }, { id = "tools/repository_git/tests/test_repository.py", metadata = { artifact_kind = "fixture", authority = "evidence", repository_path = "tools/repository_git/tests/test_repository.py" } }, { id = "tools/standards_snapshots/tests/test_store.py", metadata = { artifact_kind = "fixture", authority = "evidence", repository_path = "tools/standards_snapshots/tests/test_store.py" } }, { id = "tools/standards_snapshots/tests/test_module.py", metadata = { artifact_kind = "fixture", authority = "evidence", repository_path = "tools/standards_snapshots/tests/test_module.py" } }, { id = "tools/standards_contracts/pyproject.toml", metadata = { artifact_kind = "implementation-artifact", authority = "projection", repository_path = "tools/standards_contracts/pyproject.toml" } }, { id = "tools/standards_contracts/standards_contracts/__init__.py", metadata = { artifact_kind = "implementation-artifact", authority = "projection", repository_path = "tools/standards_contracts/standards_contracts/__init__.py" } }, { id = "tools/standards_engine/contracts/README.md", metadata = { artifact_kind = "documentation", authority = "projection", repository_path = "tools/standards_engine/contracts/README.md" } }, { id = "tools/standards_engine/contracts/a1-interface.toml", metadata = { artifact_kind = "implementation-artifact", authority = "projection", repository_path = "tools/standards_engine/contracts/a1-interface.toml" } }, { id = "tools/standards_engine/contracts/examples/a1-examples.json", metadata = { artifact_kind = "fixture", authority = "evidence", repository_path = "tools/standards_engine/contracts/examples/a1-examples.json" } }, { id = "tools/standards_engine/contracts/generated/agent-tools.json", metadata = { artifact_kind = "implementation-artifact", authority = "projection", repository_path = "tools/standards_engine/contracts/generated/agent-tools.json" } }, { id = "tools/standards_engine/contracts/identity-fixtures.json", metadata = { artifact_kind = "fixture", authority = "evidence", repository_path = "tools/standards_engine/contracts/identity-fixtures.json" } }, { id = "tools/standards_engine/pyproject.toml", metadata = { artifact_kind = "implementation-artifact", authority = "projection", repository_path = "tools/standards_engine/pyproject.toml" } }, { id = "tools/standards_engine/standards_engine/rendering.py", metadata = { artifact_kind = "implementation-artifact", authority = "projection", repository_path = "tools/standards_engine/standards_engine/rendering.py" } }, { id = "tools/standards_graph/pyproject.toml", metadata = { artifact_kind = "implementation-artifact", authority = "projection", repository_path = "tools/standards_graph/pyproject.toml" } }, { id = "tools/standards_graph/standards_graph/__init__.py", metadata = { artifact_kind = "implementation-artifact", authority = "projection", repository_path = "tools/standards_graph/standards_graph/__init__.py" } }, { id = "tools/standards_identity/README.md", metadata = { artifact_kind = "documentation", authority = "projection", repository_path = "tools/standards_identity/README.md" } }, { id = "tools/standards_identity/pyproject.toml", metadata = { artifact_kind = "implementation-artifact", authority = "projection", repository_path = "tools/standards_identity/pyproject.toml" } }, { id = "tools/standards_identity/standards_identity/__init__.py", metadata = { artifact_kind = "implementation-artifact", authority = "projection", repository_path = "tools/standards_identity/standards_identity/__init__.py" } }, { id = "tools/standards_metadata/pyproject.toml", metadata = { artifact_kind = "implementation-artifact", authority = "projection", repository_path = "tools/standards_metadata/pyproject.toml" } }, { id = "tools/standards_metadata/standards_metadata/__init__.py", metadata = { artifact_kind = "implementation-artifact", authority = "projection", repository_path = "tools/standards_metadata/standards_metadata/__init__.py" } }, { id = "tools/standards_policy_impact/pyproject.toml", metadata = { artifact_kind = "implementation-artifact", authority = "projection", repository_path = "tools/standards_policy_impact/pyproject.toml" } }, { id = "tools/standards_policy_impact/standards_policy_impact/__init__.py", metadata = { artifact_kind = "implementation-artifact", authority = "projection", repository_path = "tools/standards_policy_impact/standards_policy_impact/__init__.py" } }, { id = "tools/standards_verifier/pyproject.toml", metadata = { artifact_kind = "implementation-artifact", authority = "projection", repository_path = "tools/standards_verifier/pyproject.toml" } }, { id = "tools/standards_verifier/standards_verifier/__init__.py", metadata = { artifact_kind = "implementation-artifact", authority = "projection", repository_path = "tools/standards_verifier/standards_verifier/__init__.py" } }, { id = "tools/standards_verifier/standards_verifier/checks/python_package_contract.py", metadata = { artifact_kind = "implementation-artifact", authority = "projection", repository_path = "tools/standards_verifier/standards_verifier/checks/python_package_contract.py" } }, { id = "tools/standards_verifier/standards_verifier/entrypoints.py", metadata = { artifact_kind = "implementation-artifact", authority = "projection", repository_path = "tools/standards_verifier/standards_verifier/entrypoints.py" } }, { id = "tools/standards_verifier/standards_verifier/git_reachability.py", metadata = { artifact_kind = "implementation-artifact", authority = "projection", repository_path = "tools/standards_verifier/standards_verifier/git_reachability.py" } }, { id = "tools/standards_verifier/standards_verifier/python_packages.py", metadata = { artifact_kind = "implementation-artifact", authority = "projection", repository_path = "tools/standards_verifier/standards_verifier/python_packages.py" } }, { id = "tools/standards_verifier/tests/test_python_package_contract.py", metadata = { artifact_kind = "fixture", authority = "evidence", repository_path = "tools/standards_verifier/tests/test_python_package_contract.py" } }, { id = "tools/standards_verifier/verify.py", metadata = { artifact_kind = "implementation-artifact", authority = "projection", repository_path = "tools/standards_verifier/verify.py" } }, { id = "tools/verify_git_reachability.py", metadata = { artifact_kind = "implementation-artifact", authority = "projection", repository_path = "tools/verify_git_reachability.py" } }, { id = "tools/standards_analysis/standards_analysis/keys.py", metadata = { artifact_kind = "implementation-artifact", authority = "projection", repository_path = "tools/standards_analysis/standards_analysis/keys.py" } }, { id = "tools/standards_analysis/standards_analysis/coverage.py", metadata = { artifact_kind = "implementation-artifact", authority = "projection", repository_path = "tools/standards_analysis/standards_analysis/coverage.py" } }, { id = "tools/standards_analysis/standards_analysis/impact.py", metadata = { artifact_kind = "implementation-artifact", authority = "projection", repository_path = "tools/standards_analysis/standards_analysis/impact.py" } }, { id = "tools/standards_analysis/standards_analysis/obligations.py", metadata = { artifact_kind = "implementation-artifact", authority = "projection", repository_path = "tools/standards_analysis/standards_analysis/obligations.py" } }, { id = "tools/standards_analysis/standards_analysis/reading.py", metadata = { artifact_kind = "implementation-artifact", authority = "projection", repository_path = "tools/standards_analysis/standards_analysis/reading.py" } }, { id = "tools/standards_metadata/standards_metadata/policy_units.py", metadata = { artifact_kind = "implementation-artifact", authority = "projection", repository_path = "tools/standards_metadata/standards_metadata/policy_units.py" } }, { id = "tools/standards_metadata/standards_metadata/suite_inputs.py", metadata = { artifact_kind = "implementation-artifact", authority = "projection", repository_path = "tools/standards_metadata/standards_metadata/suite_inputs.py" } }, { id = "tools/standards_analysis/tests/test_coverage.py", metadata = { artifact_kind = "fixture", authority = "evidence", repository_path = "tools/standards_analysis/tests/test_coverage.py" } }, { id = "tools/standards_engine/tests/test_analysis.py", metadata = { artifact_kind = "fixture", authority = "evidence", repository_path = "tools/standards_engine/tests/test_analysis.py" } }, { id = "tools/standards_verifier/standards_verifier/policy_impact.py", metadata = { artifact_kind = "implementation-artifact", authority = "projection", repository_path = "tools/standards_verifier/standards_verifier/policy_impact.py" } }, { id = "tools/standards_verifier/tests/test_policy_impact.py", metadata = { artifact_kind = "fixture", authority = "evidence", repository_path = "tools/standards_verifier/tests/test_policy_impact.py" } }, { id = "tools/graph_engine/graph_engine/projection.py", metadata = { artifact_kind = "implementation-artifact", authority = "evidence", repository_path = "tools/graph_engine/graph_engine/projection.py" } }, { id = "tools/graph_engine/graph_engine/registry.py", metadata = { artifact_kind = "implementation-artifact", authority = "evidence", repository_path = "tools/graph_engine/graph_engine/registry.py" } }, { id = "tools/standards_analysis/standards_analysis/routing.py", metadata = { artifact_kind = "implementation-artifact", authority = "evidence", repository_path = "tools/standards_analysis/standards_analysis/routing.py" } }, { id = "tools/standards_snapshots/standards_snapshots/errors.py", metadata = { artifact_kind = "implementation-artifact", authority = "evidence", repository_path = "tools/standards_snapshots/standards_snapshots/errors.py" } }, { id = "tools/standards_snapshots/standards_snapshots/model.py", metadata = { artifact_kind = "implementation-artifact", authority = "evidence", repository_path = "tools/standards_snapshots/standards_snapshots/model.py" } }, { id = "tools/repository_git/repository_git/model.py", metadata = { artifact_kind = "implementation-artifact", authority = "evidence", repository_path = "tools/repository_git/repository_git/model.py" } }, { id = "tools/standards_metadata/standards_metadata/source.py", metadata = { artifact_kind = "implementation-artifact", authority = "evidence", repository_path = "tools/standards_metadata/standards_metadata/source.py" } }, { id = "tools/repository_git/repository_git/errors.py", metadata = { artifact_kind = "implementation-artifact", authority = "projection", repository_path = "tools/repository_git/repository_git/errors.py" } }, { id = "tools/standards_metadata/standards_metadata/corpus.py", metadata = { artifact_kind = "implementation-artifact", authority = "projection", repository_path = "tools/standards_metadata/standards_metadata/corpus.py" } }, { id = "tools/standards_metadata/standards_metadata/loader.py", metadata = { artifact_kind = "implementation-artifact", authority = "projection", repository_path = "tools/standards_metadata/standards_metadata/loader.py" } }, { id = "tools/standards_contracts/standards_contracts/errors.py", metadata = { artifact_kind = "implementation-artifact", authority = "evidence", repository_path = "tools/standards_contracts/standards_contracts/errors.py" } }, { id = "tools/standards_contracts/standards_contracts/model.py", metadata = { artifact_kind = "implementation-artifact", authority = "evidence", repository_path = "tools/standards_contracts/standards_contracts/model.py" } }, { id = "tools/standards_graph/standards_graph/repository.py", metadata = { artifact_kind = "implementation-artifact", authority = "evidence", repository_path = "tools/standards_graph/standards_graph/repository.py" } }, { id = "tools/standards_identity/standards_identity/errors.py", metadata = { artifact_kind = "implementation-artifact", authority = "evidence", repository_path = "tools/standards_identity/standards_identity/errors.py" } }, { id = "tools/standards_policy_impact/standards_policy_impact/compiler.py", metadata = { artifact_kind = "implementation-artifact", authority = "evidence", repository_path = "tools/standards_policy_impact/standards_policy_impact/compiler.py" } }, { id = "tools/standards_verifier/standards_verifier/checks/__init__.py", metadata = { artifact_kind = "implementation-artifact", authority = "evidence", repository_path = "tools/standards_verifier/standards_verifier/checks/__init__.py" } }, { id = "tools/standards_verifier/standards_verifier/checks/contract_projection.py", metadata = { artifact_kind = "implementation-artifact", authority = "evidence", repository_path = "tools/standards_verifier/standards_verifier/checks/contract_projection.py" } }, { id = "tools/standards_verifier/standards_verifier/repository_graph.py", metadata = { artifact_kind = "implementation-artifact", authority = "evidence", repository_path = "tools/standards_verifier/standards_verifier/repository_graph.py" } }, { id = "tools/standards_verifier/standards_verifier/suite_inputs.py", metadata = { artifact_kind = "implementation-artifact", authority = "projection", repository_path = "tools/standards_verifier/standards_verifier/suite_inputs.py" } }, { id = "tools/standards_verifier/standards_verifier/checks/markdown_link_coverage.py", metadata = { artifact_kind = "implementation-artifact", authority = "projection", repository_path = "tools/standards_verifier/standards_verifier/checks/markdown_link_coverage.py" } }, { id = "tools/standards_verifier/standards_verifier/checks/markdown_links.py", metadata = { artifact_kind = "implementation-artifact", authority = "projection", repository_path = "tools/standards_verifier/standards_verifier/checks/markdown_links.py" } }, { id = "tools/standards_verifier/standards_verifier/checks/metadata.py", metadata = { artifact_kind = "implementation-artifact", authority = "projection", repository_path = "tools/standards_verifier/standards_verifier/checks/metadata.py" } }, { id = "tools/standards_verifier/standards_verifier/checks/metadata_route.py", metadata = { artifact_kind = "implementation-artifact", authority = "projection", repository_path = "tools/standards_verifier/standards_verifier/checks/metadata_route.py" } }, { id = "tools/standards_verifier/standards_verifier/checks/policy_impact.py", metadata = { artifact_kind = "implementation-artifact", authority = "projection", repository_path = "tools/standards_verifier/standards_verifier/checks/policy_impact.py" } }, { id = "tools/standards_verifier/standards_verifier/checks/table.py", metadata = { artifact_kind = "implementation-artifact", authority = "projection", repository_path = "tools/standards_verifier/standards_verifier/checks/table.py" } }, { id = "tools/standards_verifier/standards_verifier/model.py", metadata = { artifact_kind = "implementation-artifact", authority = "projection", repository_path = "tools/standards_verifier/standards_verifier/model.py" } }, { id = "tools/standards_analysis/standards_analysis/coverage_publication.py", metadata = { artifact_kind = "implementation-artifact", authority = "evidence", repository_path = "tools/standards_analysis/standards_analysis/coverage_publication.py" } }, { id = "tools/standards_engine/tests/test_coverage_publication.py", metadata = { artifact_kind = "fixture", authority = "evidence", repository_path = "tools/standards_engine/tests/test_coverage_publication.py" } }, { id = "tools/standards_engine/standards_engine/evidence_maintenance.py", metadata = { artifact_kind = "implementation-artifact", authority = "evidence", repository_path = "tools/standards_engine/standards_engine/evidence_maintenance.py" } }, { id = "tools/standards_engine/tests/test_evidence_maintenance.py", metadata = { artifact_kind = "fixture", authority = "evidence", repository_path = "tools/standards_engine/tests/test_evidence_maintenance.py" } }, { id = "consumer.engine.authoring-guide", metadata = { artifact_kind = "documentation", authority = "projection", repository_path = ".agents/skills/standards-engine/references/authoring.md" } }, { id = "consumer.analysis.routing-tests", metadata = { artifact_kind = "fixture", authority = "evidence", repository_path = "tools/standards_analysis/tests/test_routing.py" } }, { id = "consumer.engine.navigation-tests", metadata = { artifact_kind = "fixture", authority = "evidence", repository_path = "tools/standards_engine/tests/test_navigation.py" } }] + +[[nodes]] +id = "prompts/full-codebase-standards-refactor.md" +metadata = { artifact_kind = "prompt", authority = "projection", repository_path = "prompts/full-codebase-standards-refactor.md" } + +[[nodes]] +id = "prompts/implement-plan.md" +metadata = { artifact_kind = "prompt", authority = "projection", repository_path = "prompts/implement-plan.md" } + +[[nodes]] +id = "prompts/planning.md" +metadata = { artifact_kind = "prompt", authority = "projection", repository_path = "prompts/planning.md" } + +[[nodes]] +id = "templates/PLAN-TEMPLATE.md" +metadata = { artifact_kind = "template", authority = "projection", repository_path = "templates/PLAN-TEMPLATE.md" } + +[[nodes]] +id = "evaluation/standards-effectiveness/verification-guide.md" +metadata = { artifact_kind = "documentation", authority = "projection", repository_path = "evaluation/standards-effectiveness/verification-guide.md" } + +[[nodes]] +id = "evaluation/standards-effectiveness/fixtures/planning/full-review-prompt-decisions.tsv" +metadata = { artifact_kind = "fixture", authority = "evidence", repository_path = "evaluation/standards-effectiveness/fixtures/planning/full-review-prompt-decisions.tsv" } + +[[nodes]] +aliases = ["evaluation/standards-effectiveness/suites/planning-consolidation.toml"] +id = "planning-consolidation" +metadata = { artifact_kind = "enforcement-suite", authority = "evidence", repository_path = "evaluation/standards-effectiveness/suites/planning-consolidation.toml", suite_id = "planning-consolidation" } + +[[nodes]] +aliases = ["evaluation/standards-effectiveness/suites/policy-semantic-impact.toml"] +id = "policy-semantic-impact" +metadata = { artifact_kind = "enforcement-suite", authority = "evidence", repository_path = "evaluation/standards-effectiveness/suites/policy-semantic-impact.toml", suite_id = "policy-semantic-impact" } + +[[nodes]] +aliases = ["evaluation/standards-effectiveness/suites/s1-routing.toml"] +id = "s1-routing" +metadata = { artifact_kind = "enforcement-suite", authority = "evidence", repository_path = "evaluation/standards-effectiveness/suites/s1-routing.toml", suite_id = "s1-routing" } + +[[nodes]] +id = "evaluation/standards-effectiveness/router-projection.toml" +metadata = { artifact_kind = "routing-projection", authority = "projection", repository_path = "evaluation/standards-effectiveness/router-projection.toml" } + +[[nodes]] +id = "evaluation/standards-effectiveness/fixtures/routing/generated-contract-decisions.tsv" +metadata = { artifact_kind = "fixture", authority = "evidence", repository_path = "evaluation/standards-effectiveness/fixtures/routing/generated-contract-decisions.tsv" } + +[[nodes]] +id = "evaluation/standards-effectiveness/fixtures/routing/generated-contract-routes.tsv" +metadata = { artifact_kind = "fixture", authority = "evidence", repository_path = "evaluation/standards-effectiveness/fixtures/routing/generated-contract-routes.tsv" } + +[[nodes]] +id = "evaluation/standards-effectiveness/fixtures/planning/systemic-finding-missing-audit.md" +metadata = { artifact_kind = "fixture", authority = "evidence", repository_path = "evaluation/standards-effectiveness/fixtures/planning/systemic-finding-missing-audit.md" } + +[[nodes]] +aliases = ["evaluation/standards-effectiveness/suites/standards-recovery-routing.toml"] +id = "standards-recovery-routing" +metadata = { artifact_kind = "enforcement-suite", authority = "evidence", repository_path = "evaluation/standards-effectiveness/suites/standards-recovery-routing.toml", suite_id = "standards-recovery-routing" } + +[[nodes]] +aliases = ["evaluation/standards-effectiveness/suites/a1c-contract-conformance.toml"] +id = "generated-contract-semantic-conformance" +metadata = { artifact_kind = "enforcement-suite", authority = "evidence", repository_path = "evaluation/standards-effectiveness/suites/a1c-contract-conformance.toml", suite_id = "generated-contract-semantic-conformance" } + +[[nodes]] +aliases = ["evaluation/standards-effectiveness/suites/a1c-public-cutover.toml"] +id = "a1c-public-cutover" +metadata = { artifact_kind = "enforcement-suite", authority = "evidence", repository_path = "evaluation/standards-effectiveness/suites/a1c-public-cutover.toml", suite_id = "a1c-public-cutover" } + +[[nodes]] +id = "docs/archive/plans/standards-engine-standards-recovery/reports/json-schema-instance-equality-reproduction.md" +metadata = { artifact_kind = "documentation", authority = "evidence", repository_path = "docs/archive/plans/standards-engine-standards-recovery/reports/json-schema-instance-equality-reproduction.md" } + +[[nodes]] +id = "docs/archive/plans/standards-engine-standards-recovery/reports/historical-a1-repair-reproductions.md" +metadata = { artifact_kind = "documentation", authority = "evidence", repository_path = "docs/archive/plans/standards-engine-standards-recovery/reports/historical-a1-repair-reproductions.md" } + +[[nodes]] +id = "tools/standards_engine/contracts/a1-contract.schema.json" +metadata = { artifact_kind = "implementation-artifact", authority = "evidence", repository_path = "tools/standards_engine/contracts/a1-contract.schema.json" } + +[[nodes]] +id = "tools/standards_contracts/standards_contracts/projection.py" +metadata = { artifact_kind = "implementation-artifact", authority = "evidence", repository_path = "tools/standards_contracts/standards_contracts/projection.py" } + +[[nodes]] +id = "tools/standards_contracts/standards_contracts/compiler.py" +metadata = { artifact_kind = "implementation-artifact", authority = "evidence", repository_path = "tools/standards_contracts/standards_contracts/compiler.py" } + +[[nodes]] +id = "tools/standards_contracts/standards_contracts/runtime.py" +metadata = { artifact_kind = "implementation-artifact", authority = "evidence", repository_path = "tools/standards_contracts/standards_contracts/runtime.py" } + +[[nodes]] +id = "tools/standards_identity/standards_identity/encoding.py" +metadata = { artifact_kind = "implementation-artifact", authority = "evidence", repository_path = "tools/standards_identity/standards_identity/encoding.py" } + +[[nodes]] +id = "tools/standards_engine/standards_engine/_generated_contract.py" +metadata = { artifact_kind = "implementation-artifact", authority = "evidence", repository_path = "tools/standards_engine/standards_engine/_generated_contract.py" } + +[[nodes]] +id = "tools/standards_engine/standards_engine/__init__.py" +metadata = { artifact_kind = "implementation-artifact", authority = "evidence", repository_path = "tools/standards_engine/standards_engine/__init__.py" } + +[[nodes]] +id = "tools/standards_engine/standards_engine/tools.py" +metadata = { artifact_kind = "implementation-artifact", authority = "evidence", repository_path = "tools/standards_engine/standards_engine/tools.py" } + +[[nodes]] +id = "tools/standards_engine/standards_engine/engine.py" +metadata = { artifact_kind = "implementation-artifact", authority = "evidence", repository_path = "tools/standards_engine/standards_engine/engine.py" } + +[[nodes]] +id = "tools/standards_snapshots/standards_snapshots/store.py" +metadata = { artifact_kind = "implementation-artifact", authority = "evidence", repository_path = "tools/standards_snapshots/standards_snapshots/store.py" } + +[[nodes]] +id = "tools/standards_snapshots/standards_snapshots/module.py" +metadata = { artifact_kind = "implementation-artifact", authority = "evidence", repository_path = "tools/standards_snapshots/standards_snapshots/module.py" } + +[[nodes]] +id = "tools/standards_applicability/standards_applicability/core.py" +metadata = { artifact_kind = "implementation-artifact", authority = "evidence", repository_path = "tools/standards_applicability/standards_applicability/core.py" } + +[[nodes]] +id = "tools/standards_analysis/standards_analysis/kernel.py" +metadata = { artifact_kind = "implementation-artifact", authority = "evidence", repository_path = "tools/standards_analysis/standards_analysis/kernel.py" } + +[[nodes]] +id = "tools/standards_analysis/standards_analysis/state.py" +metadata = { artifact_kind = "implementation-artifact", authority = "evidence", repository_path = "tools/standards_analysis/standards_analysis/state.py" } + +[[nodes]] +id = "tools/standards_analysis/standards_analysis/trust.py" +metadata = { artifact_kind = "implementation-artifact", authority = "evidence", repository_path = "tools/standards_analysis/standards_analysis/trust.py" } + +[[nodes]] +id = "evaluation/standards-effectiveness/fixtures/contracts/a1c/python-package-imports.toml" +metadata = { artifact_kind = "fixture", authority = "evidence", repository_path = "evaluation/standards-effectiveness/fixtures/contracts/a1c/python-package-imports.toml" } + +[[nodes]] +id = "tools/graph_engine/graph_engine/__init__.py" +metadata = { artifact_kind = "implementation-artifact", authority = "projection", repository_path = "tools/graph_engine/graph_engine/__init__.py" } + +[[nodes]] +id = "tools/graph_engine/pyproject.toml" +metadata = { artifact_kind = "implementation-artifact", authority = "projection", repository_path = "tools/graph_engine/pyproject.toml" } + +[[nodes]] +id = "tools/query_edges.py" +metadata = { artifact_kind = "implementation-artifact", authority = "projection", repository_path = "tools/query_edges.py" } + +[[nodes]] +id = "tools/standards_analysis/pyproject.toml" +metadata = { artifact_kind = "implementation-artifact", authority = "projection", repository_path = "tools/standards_analysis/pyproject.toml" } + +[[nodes]] +id = "tools/standards_analysis/standards_analysis/__init__.py" +metadata = { artifact_kind = "implementation-artifact", authority = "projection", repository_path = "tools/standards_analysis/standards_analysis/__init__.py" } + +[[nodes]] +id = "tools/standards_applicability/pyproject.toml" +metadata = { artifact_kind = "implementation-artifact", authority = "projection", repository_path = "tools/standards_applicability/pyproject.toml" } + +[[nodes]] +id = "tools/standards_applicability/standards_applicability/__init__.py" +metadata = { artifact_kind = "implementation-artifact", authority = "projection", repository_path = "tools/standards_applicability/standards_applicability/__init__.py" } + +[[nodes]] +id = "tools/standards_snapshots/README.md" +metadata = { artifact_kind = "documentation", authority = "projection", repository_path = "tools/standards_snapshots/README.md" } + +[[nodes]] +id = "tools/repository_git/pyproject.toml" +metadata = { artifact_kind = "implementation-artifact", authority = "projection", repository_path = "tools/repository_git/pyproject.toml" } + +[[nodes]] +id = "tools/repository_git/repository_git/__init__.py" +metadata = { artifact_kind = "implementation-artifact", authority = "projection", repository_path = "tools/repository_git/repository_git/__init__.py" } + +[[nodes]] +id = "tools/standards_snapshots/pyproject.toml" +metadata = { artifact_kind = "implementation-artifact", authority = "projection", repository_path = "tools/standards_snapshots/pyproject.toml" } + +[[nodes]] +id = "tools/standards_snapshots/standards_snapshots/__init__.py" +metadata = { artifact_kind = "implementation-artifact", authority = "projection", repository_path = "tools/standards_snapshots/standards_snapshots/__init__.py" } + +[[nodes]] +id = "tools/repository_git/repository_git/repository.py" +metadata = { artifact_kind = "implementation-artifact", authority = "projection", repository_path = "tools/repository_git/repository_git/repository.py" } + +[[nodes]] +id = "tools/repository_git/tests/test_repository.py" +metadata = { artifact_kind = "fixture", authority = "evidence", repository_path = "tools/repository_git/tests/test_repository.py" } + +[[nodes]] +id = "tools/standards_snapshots/tests/test_store.py" +metadata = { artifact_kind = "fixture", authority = "evidence", repository_path = "tools/standards_snapshots/tests/test_store.py" } + +[[nodes]] +id = "tools/standards_snapshots/tests/test_module.py" +metadata = { artifact_kind = "fixture", authority = "evidence", repository_path = "tools/standards_snapshots/tests/test_module.py" } + +[[nodes]] +id = "tools/standards_contracts/pyproject.toml" +metadata = { artifact_kind = "implementation-artifact", authority = "projection", repository_path = "tools/standards_contracts/pyproject.toml" } + +[[nodes]] +id = "tools/standards_contracts/standards_contracts/__init__.py" +metadata = { artifact_kind = "implementation-artifact", authority = "projection", repository_path = "tools/standards_contracts/standards_contracts/__init__.py" } + +[[nodes]] +id = "tools/standards_engine/contracts/README.md" +metadata = { artifact_kind = "documentation", authority = "projection", repository_path = "tools/standards_engine/contracts/README.md" } + +[[nodes]] +id = "tools/standards_engine/contracts/a1-interface.toml" +metadata = { artifact_kind = "implementation-artifact", authority = "projection", repository_path = "tools/standards_engine/contracts/a1-interface.toml" } + +[[nodes]] +id = "tools/standards_engine/contracts/examples/a1-examples.json" +metadata = { artifact_kind = "fixture", authority = "evidence", repository_path = "tools/standards_engine/contracts/examples/a1-examples.json" } + +[[nodes]] +id = "tools/standards_engine/contracts/generated/agent-tools.json" +metadata = { artifact_kind = "implementation-artifact", authority = "projection", repository_path = "tools/standards_engine/contracts/generated/agent-tools.json" } + +[[nodes]] +id = "tools/standards_engine/contracts/identity-fixtures.json" +metadata = { artifact_kind = "fixture", authority = "evidence", repository_path = "tools/standards_engine/contracts/identity-fixtures.json" } + +[[nodes]] +id = "tools/standards_engine/pyproject.toml" +metadata = { artifact_kind = "implementation-artifact", authority = "projection", repository_path = "tools/standards_engine/pyproject.toml" } + +[[nodes]] +id = "tools/standards_engine/standards_engine/rendering.py" +metadata = { artifact_kind = "implementation-artifact", authority = "projection", repository_path = "tools/standards_engine/standards_engine/rendering.py" } + +[[nodes]] +id = "tools/standards_graph/pyproject.toml" +metadata = { artifact_kind = "implementation-artifact", authority = "projection", repository_path = "tools/standards_graph/pyproject.toml" } + +[[nodes]] +id = "tools/standards_graph/standards_graph/__init__.py" +metadata = { artifact_kind = "implementation-artifact", authority = "projection", repository_path = "tools/standards_graph/standards_graph/__init__.py" } + +[[nodes]] +id = "tools/standards_identity/README.md" +metadata = { artifact_kind = "documentation", authority = "projection", repository_path = "tools/standards_identity/README.md" } + +[[nodes]] +id = "tools/standards_identity/pyproject.toml" +metadata = { artifact_kind = "implementation-artifact", authority = "projection", repository_path = "tools/standards_identity/pyproject.toml" } + +[[nodes]] +id = "tools/standards_identity/standards_identity/__init__.py" +metadata = { artifact_kind = "implementation-artifact", authority = "projection", repository_path = "tools/standards_identity/standards_identity/__init__.py" } + +[[nodes]] +id = "tools/standards_metadata/pyproject.toml" +metadata = { artifact_kind = "implementation-artifact", authority = "projection", repository_path = "tools/standards_metadata/pyproject.toml" } + +[[nodes]] +id = "tools/standards_metadata/standards_metadata/__init__.py" +metadata = { artifact_kind = "implementation-artifact", authority = "projection", repository_path = "tools/standards_metadata/standards_metadata/__init__.py" } + +[[nodes]] +id = "tools/standards_policy_impact/pyproject.toml" +metadata = { artifact_kind = "implementation-artifact", authority = "projection", repository_path = "tools/standards_policy_impact/pyproject.toml" } + +[[nodes]] +id = "tools/standards_policy_impact/standards_policy_impact/__init__.py" +metadata = { artifact_kind = "implementation-artifact", authority = "projection", repository_path = "tools/standards_policy_impact/standards_policy_impact/__init__.py" } + +[[nodes]] +id = "tools/standards_verifier/pyproject.toml" +metadata = { artifact_kind = "implementation-artifact", authority = "projection", repository_path = "tools/standards_verifier/pyproject.toml" } + +[[nodes]] +id = "tools/standards_verifier/standards_verifier/__init__.py" +metadata = { artifact_kind = "implementation-artifact", authority = "projection", repository_path = "tools/standards_verifier/standards_verifier/__init__.py" } + +[[nodes]] +id = "tools/standards_verifier/standards_verifier/checks/python_package_contract.py" +metadata = { artifact_kind = "implementation-artifact", authority = "projection", repository_path = "tools/standards_verifier/standards_verifier/checks/python_package_contract.py" } + +[[nodes]] +id = "tools/standards_verifier/standards_verifier/entrypoints.py" +metadata = { artifact_kind = "implementation-artifact", authority = "projection", repository_path = "tools/standards_verifier/standards_verifier/entrypoints.py" } + +[[nodes]] +id = "tools/standards_verifier/standards_verifier/git_reachability.py" +metadata = { artifact_kind = "implementation-artifact", authority = "projection", repository_path = "tools/standards_verifier/standards_verifier/git_reachability.py" } + +[[nodes]] +id = "tools/standards_verifier/standards_verifier/python_packages.py" +metadata = { artifact_kind = "implementation-artifact", authority = "projection", repository_path = "tools/standards_verifier/standards_verifier/python_packages.py" } + +[[nodes]] +id = "tools/standards_verifier/tests/test_python_package_contract.py" +metadata = { artifact_kind = "fixture", authority = "evidence", repository_path = "tools/standards_verifier/tests/test_python_package_contract.py" } + +[[nodes]] +id = "tools/standards_verifier/verify.py" +metadata = { artifact_kind = "implementation-artifact", authority = "projection", repository_path = "tools/standards_verifier/verify.py" } + +[[nodes]] +id = "tools/verify_git_reachability.py" +metadata = { artifact_kind = "implementation-artifact", authority = "projection", repository_path = "tools/verify_git_reachability.py" } + +[[nodes]] +id = "tools/standards_analysis/standards_analysis/keys.py" +metadata = { artifact_kind = "implementation-artifact", authority = "projection", repository_path = "tools/standards_analysis/standards_analysis/keys.py" } + +[[nodes]] +id = "tools/standards_analysis/standards_analysis/coverage.py" +metadata = { artifact_kind = "implementation-artifact", authority = "projection", repository_path = "tools/standards_analysis/standards_analysis/coverage.py" } + +[[nodes]] +id = "tools/standards_analysis/standards_analysis/impact.py" +metadata = { artifact_kind = "implementation-artifact", authority = "projection", repository_path = "tools/standards_analysis/standards_analysis/impact.py" } + +[[nodes]] +id = "tools/standards_analysis/standards_analysis/obligations.py" +metadata = { artifact_kind = "implementation-artifact", authority = "projection", repository_path = "tools/standards_analysis/standards_analysis/obligations.py" } + +[[nodes]] +id = "tools/standards_analysis/standards_analysis/reading.py" +metadata = { artifact_kind = "implementation-artifact", authority = "projection", repository_path = "tools/standards_analysis/standards_analysis/reading.py" } + +[[nodes]] +id = "tools/standards_metadata/standards_metadata/policy_units.py" +metadata = { artifact_kind = "implementation-artifact", authority = "projection", repository_path = "tools/standards_metadata/standards_metadata/policy_units.py" } + +[[nodes]] +id = "tools/standards_metadata/standards_metadata/suite_inputs.py" +metadata = { artifact_kind = "implementation-artifact", authority = "projection", repository_path = "tools/standards_metadata/standards_metadata/suite_inputs.py" } + +[[nodes]] +id = "tools/standards_analysis/tests/test_coverage.py" +metadata = { artifact_kind = "fixture", authority = "evidence", repository_path = "tools/standards_analysis/tests/test_coverage.py" } + +[[nodes]] +id = "tools/standards_engine/tests/test_analysis.py" +metadata = { artifact_kind = "fixture", authority = "evidence", repository_path = "tools/standards_engine/tests/test_analysis.py" } + +[[nodes]] +id = "tools/standards_verifier/standards_verifier/policy_impact.py" +metadata = { artifact_kind = "implementation-artifact", authority = "projection", repository_path = "tools/standards_verifier/standards_verifier/policy_impact.py" } + +[[nodes]] +id = "tools/standards_verifier/tests/test_policy_impact.py" +metadata = { artifact_kind = "fixture", authority = "evidence", repository_path = "tools/standards_verifier/tests/test_policy_impact.py" } + +[[nodes]] +id = "tools/graph_engine/graph_engine/projection.py" +metadata = { artifact_kind = "implementation-artifact", authority = "evidence", repository_path = "tools/graph_engine/graph_engine/projection.py" } + +[[nodes]] +id = "tools/graph_engine/graph_engine/registry.py" +metadata = { artifact_kind = "implementation-artifact", authority = "evidence", repository_path = "tools/graph_engine/graph_engine/registry.py" } + +[[nodes]] +id = "tools/standards_analysis/standards_analysis/routing.py" +metadata = { artifact_kind = "implementation-artifact", authority = "evidence", repository_path = "tools/standards_analysis/standards_analysis/routing.py" } + +[[nodes]] +id = "tools/standards_snapshots/standards_snapshots/errors.py" +metadata = { artifact_kind = "implementation-artifact", authority = "evidence", repository_path = "tools/standards_snapshots/standards_snapshots/errors.py" } + +[[nodes]] +id = "tools/standards_snapshots/standards_snapshots/model.py" +metadata = { artifact_kind = "implementation-artifact", authority = "evidence", repository_path = "tools/standards_snapshots/standards_snapshots/model.py" } + +[[nodes]] +id = "tools/repository_git/repository_git/model.py" +metadata = { artifact_kind = "implementation-artifact", authority = "evidence", repository_path = "tools/repository_git/repository_git/model.py" } + +[[nodes]] +id = "tools/standards_metadata/standards_metadata/source.py" +metadata = { artifact_kind = "implementation-artifact", authority = "evidence", repository_path = "tools/standards_metadata/standards_metadata/source.py" } + +[[nodes]] +id = "tools/repository_git/repository_git/errors.py" +metadata = { artifact_kind = "implementation-artifact", authority = "projection", repository_path = "tools/repository_git/repository_git/errors.py" } + +[[nodes]] +id = "tools/standards_metadata/standards_metadata/corpus.py" +metadata = { artifact_kind = "implementation-artifact", authority = "projection", repository_path = "tools/standards_metadata/standards_metadata/corpus.py" } + +[[nodes]] +id = "tools/standards_metadata/standards_metadata/loader.py" +metadata = { artifact_kind = "implementation-artifact", authority = "projection", repository_path = "tools/standards_metadata/standards_metadata/loader.py" } + +[[nodes]] +id = "tools/standards_contracts/standards_contracts/errors.py" +metadata = { artifact_kind = "implementation-artifact", authority = "evidence", repository_path = "tools/standards_contracts/standards_contracts/errors.py" } + +[[nodes]] +id = "tools/standards_contracts/standards_contracts/model.py" +metadata = { artifact_kind = "implementation-artifact", authority = "evidence", repository_path = "tools/standards_contracts/standards_contracts/model.py" } + +[[nodes]] +id = "tools/standards_graph/standards_graph/repository.py" +metadata = { artifact_kind = "implementation-artifact", authority = "evidence", repository_path = "tools/standards_graph/standards_graph/repository.py" } + +[[nodes]] +id = "tools/standards_identity/standards_identity/errors.py" +metadata = { artifact_kind = "implementation-artifact", authority = "evidence", repository_path = "tools/standards_identity/standards_identity/errors.py" } + +[[nodes]] +id = "tools/standards_policy_impact/standards_policy_impact/compiler.py" +metadata = { artifact_kind = "implementation-artifact", authority = "evidence", repository_path = "tools/standards_policy_impact/standards_policy_impact/compiler.py" } + +[[nodes]] +id = "tools/standards_verifier/standards_verifier/checks/__init__.py" +metadata = { artifact_kind = "implementation-artifact", authority = "evidence", repository_path = "tools/standards_verifier/standards_verifier/checks/__init__.py" } + +[[nodes]] +id = "tools/standards_verifier/standards_verifier/checks/contract_projection.py" +metadata = { artifact_kind = "implementation-artifact", authority = "evidence", repository_path = "tools/standards_verifier/standards_verifier/checks/contract_projection.py" } + +[[nodes]] +id = "tools/standards_verifier/standards_verifier/repository_graph.py" +metadata = { artifact_kind = "implementation-artifact", authority = "evidence", repository_path = "tools/standards_verifier/standards_verifier/repository_graph.py" } + +[[nodes]] +id = "tools/standards_verifier/standards_verifier/suite_inputs.py" +metadata = { artifact_kind = "implementation-artifact", authority = "projection", repository_path = "tools/standards_verifier/standards_verifier/suite_inputs.py" } + +[[nodes]] +id = "tools/standards_verifier/standards_verifier/checks/markdown_link_coverage.py" +metadata = { artifact_kind = "implementation-artifact", authority = "projection", repository_path = "tools/standards_verifier/standards_verifier/checks/markdown_link_coverage.py" } + +[[nodes]] +id = "tools/standards_verifier/standards_verifier/checks/markdown_links.py" +metadata = { artifact_kind = "implementation-artifact", authority = "projection", repository_path = "tools/standards_verifier/standards_verifier/checks/markdown_links.py" } + +[[nodes]] +id = "tools/standards_verifier/standards_verifier/checks/metadata.py" +metadata = { artifact_kind = "implementation-artifact", authority = "projection", repository_path = "tools/standards_verifier/standards_verifier/checks/metadata.py" } + +[[nodes]] +id = "tools/standards_verifier/standards_verifier/checks/metadata_route.py" +metadata = { artifact_kind = "implementation-artifact", authority = "projection", repository_path = "tools/standards_verifier/standards_verifier/checks/metadata_route.py" } + +[[nodes]] +id = "tools/standards_verifier/standards_verifier/checks/policy_impact.py" +metadata = { artifact_kind = "implementation-artifact", authority = "projection", repository_path = "tools/standards_verifier/standards_verifier/checks/policy_impact.py" } + +[[nodes]] +id = "tools/standards_verifier/standards_verifier/checks/table.py" +metadata = { artifact_kind = "implementation-artifact", authority = "projection", repository_path = "tools/standards_verifier/standards_verifier/checks/table.py" } + +[[nodes]] +id = "tools/standards_verifier/standards_verifier/model.py" +metadata = { artifact_kind = "implementation-artifact", authority = "projection", repository_path = "tools/standards_verifier/standards_verifier/model.py" } + +[[nodes]] +id = "tools/standards_analysis/standards_analysis/coverage_publication.py" +metadata = { artifact_kind = "implementation-artifact", authority = "evidence", repository_path = "tools/standards_analysis/standards_analysis/coverage_publication.py" } + +[[nodes]] +id = "tools/standards_engine/tests/test_coverage_publication.py" +metadata = { artifact_kind = "fixture", authority = "evidence", repository_path = "tools/standards_engine/tests/test_coverage_publication.py" } + +[[nodes]] +id = "tools/standards_engine/standards_engine/evidence_maintenance.py" +metadata = { artifact_kind = "implementation-artifact", authority = "evidence", repository_path = "tools/standards_engine/standards_engine/evidence_maintenance.py" } + +[[nodes]] +id = "tools/standards_engine/tests/test_evidence_maintenance.py" +metadata = { artifact_kind = "fixture", authority = "evidence", repository_path = "tools/standards_engine/tests/test_evidence_maintenance.py" } + +[[nodes]] +id = "consumer.engine.authoring-guide" +metadata = { artifact_kind = "documentation", authority = "projection", repository_path = ".agents/skills/standards-engine/references/authoring.md" } + +[[nodes]] +id = "consumer.analysis.routing-tests" +metadata = { artifact_kind = "fixture", authority = "evidence", repository_path = "tools/standards_analysis/tests/test_routing.py" } + +[[nodes]] +id = "consumer.engine.navigation-tests" +metadata = { artifact_kind = "fixture", authority = "evidence", repository_path = "tools/standards_engine/tests/test_navigation.py" } diff --git a/evaluation/standards-effectiveness/suite-registry.toml b/evaluation/standards-effectiveness/suite-registry.toml index 80c2ec3d..c52f673c 100644 --- a/evaluation/standards-effectiveness/suite-registry.toml +++ b/evaluation/standards-effectiveness/suite-registry.toml @@ -50,11 +50,6 @@ id = "release-reference-closure" path = "evaluation/standards-effectiveness/suites/release-reference-closure.toml" requires = [] -[[suites]] -id = "release-maintenance-policy" -path = "evaluation/standards-effectiveness/suites/release-maintenance-policy.toml" -requires = ["release-reference-closure"] - [[suites]] id = "s1-routing" path = "evaluation/standards-effectiveness/suites/s1-routing.toml" diff --git a/evaluation/standards-effectiveness/suites/release-maintenance-policy.toml b/evaluation/standards-effectiveness/suites/release-maintenance-policy.toml deleted file mode 100644 index 156480e9..00000000 --- a/evaluation/standards-effectiveness/suites/release-maintenance-policy.toml +++ /dev/null @@ -1,9 +0,0 @@ -schema_version = 1 -id = "release-maintenance-policy" -owner = "workflow.release" -description = "Checks current metadata graph constraints. Does not certify prose quality, consumer compliance, or unexecuted runtime behavior." - -[[checks]] -id = "metadata-closure" -type = "metadata_graph" -paths = ["CORE-STANDARDS.md", "workflows/verification.md", "topics/contracts.md", "workflows/release.md", "topics/contracts/schemas.md", "topics/contracts/protocols.md", "topics/contracts/evolution.md", "workflows/verification/oracles.md", "workflows/verification/platforms.md", "workflows/release/operations.md", "workflows/verification/gui.md", "topics/code-design.md"] From 0a4aa35a7093016b1dcc9ad7cf1b4c0b07fa29a6 Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: MrScripty Date: Fri, 13 Nov 2026 18:39:57 -0700 Subject: [PATCH 2/4] chore(evidence): retire the plan-format checks The owner has decided that the plan template is a guide and that the layout of a plan is not something to verify. The 19 plan_contract checks in suite planning-consolidation ran a layout validator on 19 sample plans and nothing else: no check ran it on a real plan, and run by hand it rejects 25 of the 28 plans under docs/plans. The checks worked as written, but what they checked is not a requirement, so they are removed rather than repaired. The removal was made by the Engine's maintain_evidence operation (preview, then apply), not by hand. Retiring the suite removed its 19 checks, its registry entry, its enforcement-suite node in the policy-impact catalogue and the four relationships that named the suite as consumer and evidence owner (from workflow.planning.active-plan-fields, workflow.planning.lifecycle- authority, topic.architecture.composed-design-admission and workflow.commit.per-commit-boundary). No other relationship named the suite, so no evidence owner was replaced. Each of the four units keeps its template, prompt, documentation and normative consumers. The validator code and the sample plans follow in the next two commits; the samples go last because the validator's unit test reads them. templates/PLAN-TEMPLATE.md is kept. Every certificate is already stale after the metadata-check retirement. Two of them cite the retired suite file as evidence; a stale certificate is ignored on load, so they stay in place until they are reissued. docs/audits/plan-format-check-removal-2026-11-13.md is the review record supplied to the operation. Suites 23 -> 22, checks 66 -> 47, catalogue nodes 121 -> 120, policy-impact relationships 356 -> 352. Co-Authored-By: Claude Fable 5.2 --- .../plan-format-check-removal-2026-11-13.md | 97 +++++++ .../generated/suite-inputs.json | 260 +----------------- .../policy-impact-node-catalog.toml | 5 - .../policy-impact/topic.architecture.toml | 8 - .../policy-impact/workflow.commit.toml | 8 - .../policy-impact/workflow.planning.toml | 16 -- .../suite-registry.toml | 5 - .../suites/planning-consolidation.toml | 133 --------- 8 files changed, 104 insertions(+), 428 deletions(-) create mode 100644 docs/audits/plan-format-check-removal-2026-11-13.md delete mode 100644 evaluation/standards-effectiveness/suites/planning-consolidation.toml diff --git a/docs/audits/plan-format-check-removal-2026-11-13.md b/docs/audits/plan-format-check-removal-2026-11-13.md new file mode 100644 index 00000000..e902db88 --- /dev/null +++ b/docs/audits/plan-format-check-removal-2026-11-13.md @@ -0,0 +1,97 @@ +# Removal of the plan-format checks + +Reviewed revision `a5e8bf7ee4f29ba14826df1ce363bef13fbe2963` with the +metadata-check retirement of the same date applied. This is the review record +supplied to the Engine operations named below. It records what was checked +before the removal; it is not a coverage attestation. + +## Decision + +On 2026-11-13 the repository owner decided that the plan template is a guide +and that the layout of a plan is not something to verify, so the plan-format +checks are removed. Under the owner's rule for weak checks (repair a check +that is at fault; remove a check for something there is no reason to check) +this is a removal: the checks work as written, but what they check is not a +requirement. + +`templates/PLAN-TEMPLATE.md`, the planning prompts and the Planning policy +text are kept. Historical records under `docs/archive/`, `docs/audits/` and +`docs/proposals/` are not changed. + +## What the checks observed + +Suite `planning-consolidation` held 19 checks, all of type `plan_contract`. +Each ran the plan-layout validator on one sample plan under +`evaluation/standards-effectiveness/fixtures/plans/`: 4 samples had to be +accepted and 15 had to be rejected with a fixed message. + +- No check ran the validator on a real plan. The validator had two callers: + this suite and its own unit test, which read the same 19 samples. +- Run by hand on this repository's own plans at the reviewed revision, the + validator rejects 25 of the 28 `plan.md` files under `docs/plans/` (16 of + them for having no `## Objective` heading) and 1 of the 20 under + `docs/archive/plans/`. Nothing reported this, because nothing ran it. + +The suite therefore showed that the validator agreed with its samples. It did +not show that any plan in use followed the template. + +## What is removed, and how + +| Part | Items | Operation | +| --- | --- | --- | +| Registry | The 19 checks, suite `planning-consolidation`, its registry entry, its `enforcement-suite` catalogue node, and the 4 relationships that name it | Engine `maintain_evidence`, `retire_suites` | +| Validator | `checks/plan_contract.py`, its unit test, its registration and its README row in `tools/standards_verifier/` | Ordinary code commit | +| Samples | The 19 files under `fixtures/plans/` | Engine `maintain_evidence`, `retire_inputs` | + +The samples are retired after the validator code so that the validator's unit +test, which reads them, never runs without them. + +## Relationships + +Four relationships named the suite as both consumer and evidence owner. They +are removed with its node. No other relationship names `suite:planning-consolidation`, +so no evidence owner is replaced. + +| Source policy unit | Relationships before | After | +| --- | ---: | ---: | +| `workflow.planning.active-plan-fields` | 4 | 3 | +| `workflow.planning.lifecycle-authority` | 7 | 6 | +| `topic.architecture.composed-design-admission` | 9 | 8 | +| `workflow.commit.per-commit-boundary` | 4 | 3 | + +Each unit keeps its template, prompt, documentation and normative consumers, +all owned by consumer review. Policy-impact relationships 356 to 352. + +## Certificates + +All 24 certificates are already stale after the metadata-check retirement. +Two of them, for `workflow.planning.active-plan-fields` and +`workflow.planning.lifecycle-authority`, cite the retired suite file as +evidence. A stale certificate is ignored when coverage is read and its evidence +is not resolved, so both stay loadable. They are left in place +(`prune_stale_certificates` is `false`) until a reissue replaces them. + +## Statements this makes untrue + +- `workflows/planning.md`, metadata line `Verification: Active-plan structure + fixtures and objective-level acceptance review.` +- `evaluation/standards-effectiveness/verification-guide.md`, which lists + `plan records` among what the checkpoint checks. +- `tools/standards_verifier/README.md`, the `plan_contract` row of the + check-kind table. This row is removed with the validator code. + +The first two can only be corrected through the Engine's standards-authoring +workflow. That correction is prepared as a separate change so that it can be +accepted or rejected on its own. `workflows/planning.md` also says that +automated verification may inspect current plan structure. That sentence +grants a permission and does not say a check exists, so it stays true. + +## Counts + +| | Before | After | +| --- | ---: | ---: | +| Registered suites | 23 | 22 | +| Checks | 66 | 47 | +| Catalogue nodes | 121 | 120 | +| Policy-impact relationships | 356 | 352 | +| Sample plans | 19 | 0 | diff --git a/evaluation/standards-effectiveness/generated/suite-inputs.json b/evaluation/standards-effectiveness/generated/suite-inputs.json index 79709d3b..dc56732a 100644 --- a/evaluation/standards-effectiveness/generated/suite-inputs.json +++ b/evaluation/standards-effectiveness/generated/suite-inputs.json @@ -1039,234 +1039,6 @@ } ] }, - { - "digest": "sha256:b097bacf82568192c9087800f99126cfc1071e0f7340b567cdf2be144130fdca", - "path": "evaluation/standards-effectiveness/fixtures/plans/invalid-accepted-malformed-objective-status.md", - "state": "present", - "uses": [ - { - "check": "invalid-accepted-malformed-objective-status", - "role": "plan-contract", - "suite": "planning-consolidation" - } - ] - }, - { - "digest": "sha256:9b29a201762e4ec3535104e692fffff83979805b3a76cd059b100aa784077cc1", - "path": "evaluation/standards-effectiveness/fixtures/plans/invalid-accepted-missing-final-projections.md", - "state": "present", - "uses": [ - { - "check": "invalid-accepted-missing-final-projections", - "role": "plan-contract", - "suite": "planning-consolidation" - } - ] - }, - { - "digest": "sha256:7fb320d27c8a779e8d3418a3580301008e1302f50436b945d9e5c6c0c8d21738", - "path": "evaluation/standards-effectiveness/fixtures/plans/invalid-accepted-pending-criterion.md", - "state": "present", - "uses": [ - { - "check": "invalid-accepted-pending-criterion", - "role": "plan-contract", - "suite": "planning-consolidation" - } - ] - }, - { - "digest": "sha256:8cc388259f047c5bed9f1c39ae5647b3c4e78889b6cf5e6803b836019c384fa2", - "path": "evaluation/standards-effectiveness/fixtures/plans/invalid-accepted-satisfied-without-evidence.md", - "state": "present", - "uses": [ - { - "check": "invalid-accepted-satisfied-without-evidence", - "role": "plan-contract", - "suite": "planning-consolidation" - } - ] - }, - { - "digest": "sha256:011aa18a7b88d82fc6b164f163dda938e59d1d57c040c7ed93e0e6aa61499f03", - "path": "evaluation/standards-effectiveness/fixtures/plans/invalid-duplicate-composed-design-probe.md", - "state": "present", - "uses": [ - { - "check": "invalid-duplicate-composed-design-probe", - "role": "plan-contract", - "suite": "planning-consolidation" - } - ] - }, - { - "digest": "sha256:5e619e5e89ec1f39f30152a626efb399503df7d060813d6f88c253f4d9aa7a7a", - "path": "evaluation/standards-effectiveness/fixtures/plans/invalid-execution-history.md", - "state": "present", - "uses": [ - { - "check": "invalid-execution-history", - "role": "plan-contract", - "suite": "planning-consolidation" - } - ] - }, - { - "digest": "sha256:9a104fb2730160b1966f6f676e7276649ab9fb3c099dd2ad8cbff5a57b6ba3b1", - "path": "evaluation/standards-effectiveness/fixtures/plans/invalid-headless-accepted.md", - "state": "present", - "uses": [ - { - "check": "invalid-headless-accepted", - "role": "plan-contract", - "suite": "planning-consolidation" - } - ] - }, - { - "digest": "sha256:d96a2009793bc2ad18c8aaae67e60df00d3f91cb78a9a950140cf7d015640ca7", - "path": "evaluation/standards-effectiveness/fixtures/plans/invalid-incomplete-composed-design-review.md", - "state": "present", - "uses": [ - { - "check": "invalid-incomplete-composed-design-review", - "role": "plan-contract", - "suite": "planning-consolidation" - } - ] - }, - { - "digest": "sha256:c96a4b777506b536f25c72867dc5decd6ba069cb304290631dab83a709546e29", - "path": "evaluation/standards-effectiveness/fixtures/plans/invalid-missing-composed-design-applicability.md", - "state": "present", - "uses": [ - { - "check": "invalid-missing-composed-design-applicability", - "role": "plan-contract", - "suite": "planning-consolidation" - } - ] - }, - { - "digest": "sha256:4fe7f1b78346674db605e0510103cb65221044e1334a239d548a40b96330ac50", - "path": "evaluation/standards-effectiveness/fixtures/plans/invalid-missing-next.md", - "state": "present", - "uses": [ - { - "check": "invalid-missing-next", - "role": "plan-contract", - "suite": "planning-consolidation" - } - ] - }, - { - "digest": "sha256:b80611bfeda96e9fcbdca6fb62ff14a0e54117e4a6445fb6172bac509af4d799", - "path": "evaluation/standards-effectiveness/fixtures/plans/invalid-objective-partial.md", - "state": "present", - "uses": [ - { - "check": "invalid-objective-partial", - "role": "plan-contract", - "suite": "planning-consolidation" - } - ] - }, - { - "digest": "sha256:53af1a7828676fc0f94814b4152129f33b0dc82026973fc6bae925a246388fef", - "path": "evaluation/standards-effectiveness/fixtures/plans/invalid-three-state.md", - "state": "present", - "uses": [ - { - "check": "invalid-three-state", - "role": "plan-contract", - "suite": "planning-consolidation" - } - ] - }, - { - "digest": "sha256:7625cd98c65e59ea66eaee3969fc5b73300a95faea98721173ca80917c2a320f", - "path": "evaluation/standards-effectiveness/fixtures/plans/invalid-unreasoned-composed-design-exclusion.md", - "state": "present", - "uses": [ - { - "check": "invalid-unreasoned-composed-design-exclusion", - "role": "plan-contract", - "suite": "planning-consolidation" - } - ] - }, - { - "digest": "sha256:a3601a27b5bbed0f24d22b1c93d4a4206f29b1cc120cbc2ae6b6e2995a7caba5", - "path": "evaluation/standards-effectiveness/fixtures/plans/invalid-whitespace-composed-design-probe.md", - "state": "present", - "uses": [ - { - "check": "invalid-whitespace-composed-design-probe", - "role": "plan-contract", - "suite": "planning-consolidation" - } - ] - }, - { - "digest": "sha256:e1198ac7c730cab63d7da022456f7f879c6259969254583c1729720b1cdb9fff", - "path": "evaluation/standards-effectiveness/fixtures/plans/invalid-whitespace-composed-design-reason.md", - "state": "present", - "uses": [ - { - "check": "invalid-whitespace-composed-design-reason", - "role": "plan-contract", - "suite": "planning-consolidation" - } - ] - }, - { - "digest": "sha256:022d92646aa8a99dfb40a309b526e95b4043ce66e1a37ede5a055936b259ab7d", - "path": "evaluation/standards-effectiveness/fixtures/plans/valid-accepted.md", - "state": "present", - "uses": [ - { - "check": "valid-accepted-plan", - "role": "plan-contract", - "suite": "planning-consolidation" - } - ] - }, - { - "digest": "sha256:4afe36413311b1739fe1914a87f5dcf3e52a9ba01a603f580737fcde2027ef79", - "path": "evaluation/standards-effectiveness/fixtures/plans/valid-active.md", - "state": "present", - "uses": [ - { - "check": "valid-active-plan", - "role": "plan-contract", - "suite": "planning-consolidation" - } - ] - }, - { - "digest": "sha256:aa8d2e0bc92ba552064b05b0ee1b406798c6b98ffd08ec5c47278398fb676772", - "path": "evaluation/standards-effectiveness/fixtures/plans/valid-blocked.md", - "state": "present", - "uses": [ - { - "check": "valid-blocked-plan", - "role": "plan-contract", - "suite": "planning-consolidation" - } - ] - }, - { - "digest": "sha256:07c2ef51116492aa967da016eab1fb80a63176f0ca6c1ae738d9f7a7150f1365", - "path": "evaluation/standards-effectiveness/fixtures/plans/valid-superseded.md", - "state": "present", - "uses": [ - { - "check": "valid-superseded-plan", - "role": "plan-contract", - "suite": "planning-consolidation" - } - ] - }, { "digest": "sha256:b9262f05f2939115f65e19bb3c7ecbccebe0fced3d309fa185bd764677279c3f", "path": "evaluation/standards-effectiveness/fixtures/policy-impact/duplicate-edge.toml", @@ -1481,7 +1253,7 @@ ] }, { - "digest": "sha256:9d3ec990d2ee5a74bf1bb71db3619a3fa5c90288b5c5b809f2219efa22343062", + "digest": "sha256:6e3e1564a723380f598330170edd64908434bf68d6841d16d9532e01d27abece", "path": "evaluation/standards-effectiveness/policy-impact-node-catalog.toml", "state": "present", "uses": [ @@ -1565,7 +1337,7 @@ ] }, { - "digest": "sha256:54580f09627ecc95abe7c006d184337b6eebddc964a4143b3fcaf44c04a59450", + "digest": "sha256:1cc93a33278acd12b175b4e4c3d250a1c14335380d52c1d800203ba033d95caf", "path": "evaluation/standards-effectiveness/policy-impact/topic.architecture.toml", "state": "present", "uses": [ @@ -1673,7 +1445,7 @@ ] }, { - "digest": "sha256:54c2deaa6b2de044cb3638c6d8d2418faed4e96d1b6a507a6258f0611ffa2e8a", + "digest": "sha256:16c6db3c28b5a12e03f77808329857a5150ead4e5304ebc2257803fa898c9a2e", "path": "evaluation/standards-effectiveness/policy-impact/workflow.commit.toml", "state": "present", "uses": [ @@ -1709,7 +1481,7 @@ ] }, { - "digest": "sha256:f7e78b6556ae2cbb571fb07f330f73776788031a9672dc5ff1bd96f6e402ccc6", + "digest": "sha256:ff2de65c862a98a81a06db952e5b584636919a00fb69c50ec43f95cf4052f8cf", "path": "evaluation/standards-effectiveness/policy-impact/workflow.planning.toml", "state": "present", "uses": [ @@ -2153,7 +1925,7 @@ ] }, { - "digest": "sha256:8634e8ae372621d80260a6006743ad8bdfe4a87cc5eccc944610448663862748", + "digest": "sha256:9d0bf2a1aebee0f5c0c95ad4a7d4fcda73bc9f6889e7a3ed692b735956b36043", "path": "evaluation/standards-effectiveness/suite-registry.toml", "state": "present", "uses": [ @@ -2248,18 +2020,6 @@ } ] }, - { - "digest": "sha256:8c81ed8a896454155b6aab3836eca711a643eaad14972a7a21423b01bb2cc0a5", - "path": "evaluation/standards-effectiveness/suites/planning-consolidation.toml", - "state": "present", - "uses": [ - { - "check": "current-structure", - "role": "registered-policy-impact", - "suite": "policy-semantic-impact" - } - ] - }, { "digest": "sha256:8627a4c38122d45ebfe1dba5411b2903a96c8a779ec4f0366d0a3ab3f934b90e", "path": "evaluation/standards-effectiveness/suites/policy-semantic-impact.toml", @@ -10517,11 +10277,11 @@ } ], "registry": { - "digest": "sha256:8634e8ae372621d80260a6006743ad8bdfe4a87cc5eccc944610448663862748", + "digest": "sha256:9d0bf2a1aebee0f5c0c95ad4a7d4fcda73bc9f6889e7a3ed692b735956b36043", "path": "evaluation/standards-effectiveness/suite-registry.toml" }, "repository_index": { - "digest": "sha256:c2a56690ade32430a01832b2459f02feed2569f9d015abe1d08a10349ab23d36", + "digest": "sha256:12dfb8a6e2256a3f8f428366cce7787677ee57de3745eadba0ba0f0775a6cd40", "uses": [ { "check": "python-package-contract", @@ -10634,12 +10394,6 @@ "path": "evaluation/standards-effectiveness/suites/router-legacy-route-closure.toml", "requires": [] }, - { - "digest": "sha256:8c81ed8a896454155b6aab3836eca711a643eaad14972a7a21423b01bb2cc0a5", - "id": "planning-consolidation", - "path": "evaluation/standards-effectiveness/suites/planning-consolidation.toml", - "requires": [] - }, { "digest": "sha256:823c0b11b169e39ed02db8f64e70c8887932fa08143c7312ff270e4209518039", "id": "source-index-closures", diff --git a/evaluation/standards-effectiveness/policy-impact-node-catalog.toml b/evaluation/standards-effectiveness/policy-impact-node-catalog.toml index 3c3ba631..c68bb7a0 100644 --- a/evaluation/standards-effectiveness/policy-impact-node-catalog.toml +++ b/evaluation/standards-effectiveness/policy-impact-node-catalog.toml @@ -25,11 +25,6 @@ metadata = { artifact_kind = "documentation", authority = "projection", reposito id = "evaluation/standards-effectiveness/fixtures/planning/full-review-prompt-decisions.tsv" metadata = { artifact_kind = "fixture", authority = "evidence", repository_path = "evaluation/standards-effectiveness/fixtures/planning/full-review-prompt-decisions.tsv" } -[[nodes]] -aliases = ["evaluation/standards-effectiveness/suites/planning-consolidation.toml"] -id = "planning-consolidation" -metadata = { artifact_kind = "enforcement-suite", authority = "evidence", repository_path = "evaluation/standards-effectiveness/suites/planning-consolidation.toml", suite_id = "planning-consolidation" } - [[nodes]] aliases = ["evaluation/standards-effectiveness/suites/policy-semantic-impact.toml"] id = "policy-semantic-impact" diff --git a/evaluation/standards-effectiveness/policy-impact/topic.architecture.toml b/evaluation/standards-effectiveness/policy-impact/topic.architecture.toml index bb6d3b55..a414546f 100644 --- a/evaluation/standards-effectiveness/policy-impact/topic.architecture.toml +++ b/evaluation/standards-effectiveness/policy-impact/topic.architecture.toml @@ -1,14 +1,6 @@ schema_version = 2 owner = "topic.architecture" -[[relationships]] -source = "topic.architecture.composed-design-admission" -consumer = "planning-consolidation" -relation = "enforcement-suite-projection" -applicability = { operator = "always" } -evidence_owner = "suite:planning-consolidation" -rationale = "This suite checks the current structural projection associated with the policy. Its declared checks do not establish semantic completeness or consumer behavior." - [[relationships]] source = "topic.architecture.authority-scope-admission" consumer = "profile.application.library" diff --git a/evaluation/standards-effectiveness/policy-impact/workflow.commit.toml b/evaluation/standards-effectiveness/policy-impact/workflow.commit.toml index 14ff5291..fcf87c84 100644 --- a/evaluation/standards-effectiveness/policy-impact/workflow.commit.toml +++ b/evaluation/standards-effectiveness/policy-impact/workflow.commit.toml @@ -96,11 +96,3 @@ relation = "documentation-projection" applicability = { operator = "always" } evidence_owner = "review:consumer" rationale = "The standards-effectiveness README documents the registered Commit suite's branch, worktree, and commit-reachability coverage. Review binds this consumer and relationship; it requires substantive evidence before certification." - -[[relationships]] -source = "workflow.commit.per-commit-boundary" -consumer = "planning-consolidation" -relation = "enforcement-suite-projection" -applicability = { operator = "always" } -evidence_owner = "suite:planning-consolidation" -rationale = "This suite checks the current structural projection associated with the policy. Its declared checks do not establish semantic completeness or consumer behavior." diff --git a/evaluation/standards-effectiveness/policy-impact/workflow.planning.toml b/evaluation/standards-effectiveness/policy-impact/workflow.planning.toml index 63a02339..fa13109c 100644 --- a/evaluation/standards-effectiveness/policy-impact/workflow.planning.toml +++ b/evaluation/standards-effectiveness/policy-impact/workflow.planning.toml @@ -9,22 +9,6 @@ applicability = { operator = "always" } evidence_owner = "review:consumer" rationale = "Fixture records the analysis-only full-review prompt's Router and Planning delegation decisions. Review binds this consumer and relationship; it requires substantive evidence before certification." -[[relationships]] -source = "workflow.planning.active-plan-fields" -consumer = "planning-consolidation" -relation = "enforcement-suite-projection" -applicability = { operator = "always" } -evidence_owner = "suite:planning-consolidation" -rationale = "This suite checks the current structural projection associated with the policy. Its declared checks do not establish semantic completeness or consumer behavior." - -[[relationships]] -source = "workflow.planning.lifecycle-authority" -consumer = "planning-consolidation" -relation = "enforcement-suite-projection" -applicability = { operator = "always" } -evidence_owner = "suite:planning-consolidation" -rationale = "The suite's plan_contract checks enforce valid plan status vocabulary, Accepted evidence and unfinished-state constraints; discovery does not add a lifecycle state." - [[relationships]] source = "workflow.planning.projection-completeness" consumer = "policy-semantic-impact" diff --git a/evaluation/standards-effectiveness/suite-registry.toml b/evaluation/standards-effectiveness/suite-registry.toml index c52f673c..3d6121f0 100644 --- a/evaluation/standards-effectiveness/suite-registry.toml +++ b/evaluation/standards-effectiveness/suite-registry.toml @@ -85,11 +85,6 @@ id = "router-legacy-route-closure" path = "evaluation/standards-effectiveness/suites/router-legacy-route-closure.toml" requires = [] -[[suites]] -id = "planning-consolidation" -path = "evaluation/standards-effectiveness/suites/planning-consolidation.toml" -requires = [] - [[suites]] id = "source-index-closures" path = "evaluation/standards-effectiveness/suites/source-index-closures.toml" diff --git a/evaluation/standards-effectiveness/suites/planning-consolidation.toml b/evaluation/standards-effectiveness/suites/planning-consolidation.toml deleted file mode 100644 index f2debc32..00000000 --- a/evaluation/standards-effectiveness/suites/planning-consolidation.toml +++ /dev/null @@ -1,133 +0,0 @@ -schema_version = 1 -id = "planning-consolidation" -owner = "workflow.planning" -description = "Checks structured plan lifecycle records. Does not certify prose quality, consumer compliance, or unexecuted runtime behavior." - -[[checks]] -id = "valid-active-plan" -type = "plan_contract" -path = "evaluation/standards-effectiveness/fixtures/plans/valid-active.md" -expected = "valid" - -[[checks]] -id = "valid-blocked-plan" -type = "plan_contract" -path = "evaluation/standards-effectiveness/fixtures/plans/valid-blocked.md" -expected = "valid" - -[[checks]] -id = "valid-accepted-plan" -type = "plan_contract" -path = "evaluation/standards-effectiveness/fixtures/plans/valid-accepted.md" -expected = "valid" - -[[checks]] -id = "valid-superseded-plan" -type = "plan_contract" -path = "evaluation/standards-effectiveness/fixtures/plans/valid-superseded.md" -expected = "valid" - -[[checks]] -id = "invalid-accepted-malformed-objective-status" -type = "plan_contract" -path = "evaluation/standards-effectiveness/fixtures/plans/invalid-accepted-malformed-objective-status.md" -expected = "invalid" -message = "objective A1 has invalid status satified" - -[[checks]] -id = "invalid-accepted-missing-final-projections" -type = "plan_contract" -path = "evaluation/standards-effectiveness/fixtures/plans/invalid-accepted-missing-final-projections.md" -expected = "invalid" -message = "accepted plan requires both final acceptance projections" - -[[checks]] -id = "invalid-accepted-pending-criterion" -type = "plan_contract" -path = "evaluation/standards-effectiveness/fixtures/plans/invalid-accepted-pending-criterion.md" -expected = "invalid" -message = "accepted plan has unsatisfied objective A1" - -[[checks]] -id = "invalid-accepted-satisfied-without-evidence" -type = "plan_contract" -path = "evaluation/standards-effectiveness/fixtures/plans/invalid-accepted-satisfied-without-evidence.md" -expected = "invalid" -message = "satisfied objective A1 requires evidence" - -[[checks]] -id = "invalid-duplicate-composed-design-probe" -type = "plan_contract" -path = "evaluation/standards-effectiveness/fixtures/plans/invalid-duplicate-composed-design-probe.md" -expected = "invalid" -message = "applicable composed-design review requires Independent concepts and dimensions" - -[[checks]] -id = "invalid-execution-history" -type = "plan_contract" -path = "evaluation/standards-effectiveness/fixtures/plans/invalid-execution-history.md" -expected = "invalid" -message = "execution history belongs in the ledger" - -[[checks]] -id = "invalid-headless-accepted" -type = "plan_contract" -path = "evaluation/standards-effectiveness/fixtures/plans/invalid-headless-accepted.md" -expected = "invalid" -message = "accepted plan has partial acceptance" - -[[checks]] -id = "invalid-incomplete-composed-design-review" -type = "plan_contract" -path = "evaluation/standards-effectiveness/fixtures/plans/invalid-incomplete-composed-design-review.md" -expected = "invalid" -message = "applicable composed-design review requires Deletion and cumulative machinery result" - -[[checks]] -id = "invalid-missing-composed-design-applicability" -type = "plan_contract" -path = "evaluation/standards-effectiveness/fixtures/plans/invalid-missing-composed-design-applicability.md" -expected = "invalid" -message = "expected one ## Simplicity And Ownership Review heading" - -[[checks]] -id = "invalid-missing-next" -type = "plan_contract" -path = "evaluation/standards-effectiveness/fixtures/plans/invalid-missing-next.md" -expected = "invalid" -message = "expected one Next slice field" - -[[checks]] -id = "invalid-objective-partial" -type = "plan_contract" -path = "evaluation/standards-effectiveness/fixtures/plans/invalid-objective-partial.md" -expected = "invalid" -message = "objective A1 has invalid status partial" - -[[checks]] -id = "invalid-three-state" -type = "plan_contract" -path = "evaluation/standards-effectiveness/fixtures/plans/invalid-three-state.md" -expected = "invalid" -message = "invalid plan status Complete" - -[[checks]] -id = "invalid-unreasoned-composed-design-exclusion" -type = "plan_contract" -path = "evaluation/standards-effectiveness/fixtures/plans/invalid-unreasoned-composed-design-exclusion.md" -expected = "invalid" -message = "not-applicable composed-design review requires a concrete Reason" - -[[checks]] -id = "invalid-whitespace-composed-design-probe" -type = "plan_contract" -path = "evaluation/standards-effectiveness/fixtures/plans/invalid-whitespace-composed-design-probe.md" -expected = "invalid" -message = "applicable composed-design review requires Deletion and cumulative machinery result" - -[[checks]] -id = "invalid-whitespace-composed-design-reason" -type = "plan_contract" -path = "evaluation/standards-effectiveness/fixtures/plans/invalid-whitespace-composed-design-reason.md" -expected = "invalid" -message = "not-applicable composed-design review requires a concrete Reason" From 1fc7a9fdd2bd63a550000e03244adfdadc36ff08 Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: MrScripty Date: Fri, 13 Nov 2026 18:40:04 -0700 Subject: [PATCH 3/4] refactor(verifier): remove the plan-layout validator The plan_contract check kind validated the layout of a plan document. Its only suite, planning-consolidation, was retired in the previous commit after the owner decided the plan template is a guide rather than something to verify, so the validator has no caller left. Remove the check implementation, its registration in the check parser, its unit test (3 tests) and its row in the README's check-kind table. A suite that still declares a plan_contract check now fails with CONFIG.UNKNOWN_CHECK, like any other unsupported kind. Nothing else used the validator. The sample plans its unit test read are retired through the Engine in the next commit. templates/PLAN-TEMPLATE.md is unchanged. Co-Authored-By: Claude Fable 5.2 --- .../generated/suite-inputs.json | 18 +- tools/standards_verifier/README.md | 1 - .../standards_verifier/checks/__init__.py | 3 - .../checks/plan_contract.py | 382 ------------------ .../tests/test_plan_contract.py | 81 ---- 5 files changed, 3 insertions(+), 482 deletions(-) delete mode 100644 tools/standards_verifier/standards_verifier/checks/plan_contract.py delete mode 100644 tools/standards_verifier/tests/test_plan_contract.py diff --git a/evaluation/standards-effectiveness/generated/suite-inputs.json b/evaluation/standards-effectiveness/generated/suite-inputs.json index dc56732a..94096327 100644 --- a/evaluation/standards-effectiveness/generated/suite-inputs.json +++ b/evaluation/standards-effectiveness/generated/suite-inputs.json @@ -7027,7 +7027,7 @@ ] }, { - "digest": "sha256:e56834537ad6ee2ef8a243141ef554c1cb24cfdc6b5b0d543e998892920a766b", + "digest": "sha256:cbaba5def21234f44c2d45e50fc60e202dfce4fbeb5bd313ace374a3f386e362", "path": "tools/standards_verifier/README.md", "state": "present", "uses": [ @@ -7073,7 +7073,7 @@ ] }, { - "digest": "sha256:4fd26bc3eba2945d3f9ca888a9a7eb02ac4e2dcca9527a578a4d934e25fcfab3", + "digest": "sha256:c9100c80a3b7fec7d5b108570a603f5506161d6dd99ecbaeb76cf87bf850657a", "path": "tools/standards_verifier/standards_verifier/checks/__init__.py", "state": "present", "uses": [ @@ -7210,18 +7210,6 @@ } ] }, - { - "digest": "sha256:c7266c0564b9ee02944fc4eb12d66cc20d604fd4ddb7f051ed77d01e9fe4466e", - "path": "tools/standards_verifier/standards_verifier/checks/plan_contract.py", - "state": "present", - "uses": [ - { - "check": "python-package-contract", - "role": "package-contract-input", - "suite": "a1c-public-cutover" - } - ] - }, { "digest": "sha256:e28442711d42d69bdb9348ec01923daefd49cec2be8850239c9489fb6cb71dc9", "path": "tools/standards_verifier/standards_verifier/checks/policy_impact.py", @@ -10281,7 +10269,7 @@ "path": "evaluation/standards-effectiveness/suite-registry.toml" }, "repository_index": { - "digest": "sha256:12dfb8a6e2256a3f8f428366cce7787677ee57de3745eadba0ba0f0775a6cd40", + "digest": "sha256:52d4a6d19cf74204f2651085cc1000ecd321debe1c8bb5fe075692c97710e7ff", "uses": [ { "check": "python-package-contract", diff --git a/tools/standards_verifier/README.md b/tools/standards_verifier/README.md index e8acf42a..c3dc75a7 100644 --- a/tools/standards_verifier/README.md +++ b/tools/standards_verifier/README.md @@ -31,7 +31,6 @@ the command above with `refresh_verification_inputs` set to `true`. | `markdown_targets` | Required navigation destinations, independent of link wording | | `markdown_links` | Declared links and destinations | | `markdown_link_coverage` | Navigation coverage of a declared member inventory | -| `plan_contract` | Structured plan lifecycle records | | `policy_impact` | Declared consumer graph and fixture validity | | `contract_projection` | Generated Interface agrees with canonical contract | | `python_package_contract` | Declared Python package boundaries | diff --git a/tools/standards_verifier/standards_verifier/checks/__init__.py b/tools/standards_verifier/standards_verifier/checks/__init__.py index 90f5b48c..1c9cbf0a 100644 --- a/tools/standards_verifier/standards_verifier/checks/__init__.py +++ b/tools/standards_verifier/standards_verifier/checks/__init__.py @@ -10,7 +10,6 @@ from .markdown_targets import parse_markdown_targets_check from .metadata import parse_metadata_graph_check from .metadata_route import parse_metadata_route_check -from .plan_contract import parse_plan_contract_check from .policy_impact import parse_policy_impact_check from .python_package_contract import parse_python_package_contract_check @@ -34,8 +33,6 @@ def parse_check(raw: Any, suite_id: str) -> Check: return parse_markdown_links_check(raw, suite_id) if kind == "markdown_link_coverage": return parse_markdown_link_coverage_check(raw, suite_id) - if kind == "plan_contract": - return parse_plan_contract_check(raw, suite_id) if kind == "policy_impact": return parse_policy_impact_check(raw, suite_id) if kind == "python_package_contract": diff --git a/tools/standards_verifier/standards_verifier/checks/plan_contract.py b/tools/standards_verifier/standards_verifier/checks/plan_contract.py deleted file mode 100644 index 5eea8ad6..00000000 --- a/tools/standards_verifier/standards_verifier/checks/plan_contract.py +++ /dev/null @@ -1,382 +0,0 @@ -from __future__ import annotations - -import re -from dataclasses import dataclass -from typing import Any - -from ..diagnostics import Diagnostic, EngineError -from ..model import CheckAuthorityInput, CheckContext, CheckInputContext, present_inputs -from ..paths import contained_file - - -PLAN_STATUSES = frozenset( - { - "Planned", - "Active", - "Blocked", - "Implemented", - "Verifying", - "Accepted", - "Deferred", - "Superseded", - } -) -ACCEPTANCE_STATUSES = frozenset({"pending", "partial", "blocked", "satisfied"}) -OBJECTIVE_STATUSES = frozenset({"pending", "blocked", "satisfied"}) -REQUIRED_HEADINGS = ( - "## Objective", - "## Objective Acceptance", - "## Binding Decisions", - "## Milestones", - "## Blockers", - "## Re-Plan Triggers", - "## Final Acceptance", -) -REQUIRED_FIELDS = ( - "Plan status", - "Current phase", - "Next slice", - "Acceptance status", - "Execution ledger", - "Issues", -) -DESIGN_PROBES = ( - "Independent concepts and dimensions", - "State, identity, value, time, policy, and mechanism", - "Caller and composition-root knowledge", - "Representative change paths and forced owners", - "Stable Interfaces versus hidden knowledge", - "Independent evolution, testing, failure, and replacement", - "Necessary complexity and containment", - "Deletion and cumulative machinery result", -) - - -def _field_values(content: str, field: str) -> list[str]: - prefix = f"**{field}:** " - return [ - line.removeprefix(prefix).replace("`", "") - for line in content.splitlines() - if line.startswith(prefix) - ] - - -def _section(content: str, heading: str) -> list[str]: - lines = content.splitlines() - try: - start = lines.index(heading) + 1 - except ValueError: - return [] - result: list[str] = [] - for line in lines[start:]: - if line.startswith("## "): - break - result.append(line) - return result - - -def _objective_rows(content: str) -> list[tuple[str, str, str]]: - lines = _section(content, "## Objective Acceptance") - status_column = 0 - evidence_column = 0 - rows: list[tuple[str, str, str]] = [] - for line in lines: - if not line.startswith("|"): - continue - cells = [cell.strip() for cell in line.split("|")[1:-1]] - if not cells: - continue - identity = cells[0] - if identity == "ID": - for index, cell in enumerate(cells): - if cell == "Status": - status_column = index - if cell == "Evidence": - evidence_column = index - continue - if not identity or set(identity) == {"-"}: - continue - status = ( - cells[status_column].replace("`", "") if status_column < len(cells) else "" - ) - evidence = ( - cells[evidence_column].replace("`", "") - if evidence_column < len(cells) - else "" - ) - rows.append((identity, status, evidence or "")) - return rows - - -def validate_plan(content: str) -> str | None: - lines = content.splitlines() - for heading in REQUIRED_HEADINGS: - if lines.count(heading) != 1: - return f"expected one {heading} heading" - - fields: dict[str, str] = {} - for field in REQUIRED_FIELDS: - values = _field_values(content, field) - if len(values) != 1: - return f"expected one {field} field" - fields[field] = values[0] - - status = fields["Plan status"] - acceptance_status = fields["Acceptance status"] - if status not in PLAN_STATUSES: - return f"invalid plan status {status}" - if acceptance_status not in ACCEPTANCE_STATUSES: - return f"invalid acceptance status {acceptance_status}" - if any( - line in {"## Execution Notes", "## History", "## Daily Log"} - for line in lines - ): - return "execution history belongs in the ledger" - - milestone_pattern = re.compile(r"^\*\*Status:\*\* `([^`]*)`") - for line in lines: - match = milestone_pattern.match(line) - if match is not None and match.group(1) not in PLAN_STATUSES: - return f"invalid milestone status {match.group(1)}" - - if status == "Accepted": - if acceptance_status != "satisfied": - return f"accepted plan has {acceptance_status} acceptance" - unfinished = {"Planned", "Active", "Blocked", "Implemented", "Verifying"} - for line in lines: - match = milestone_pattern.match(line) - if match is not None and match.group(1) in unfinished: - return "accepted plan has unfinished milestone" - elif acceptance_status == "satisfied": - return "satisfied acceptance requires Accepted plan status" - - objective_rows = _objective_rows(content) - if not objective_rows: - return "expected at least one objective-acceptance row" - for objective_id, objective_status, objective_evidence in objective_rows: - if objective_status not in OBJECTIVE_STATUSES: - return f"objective {objective_id} has invalid status {objective_status}" - if objective_status == "satisfied" and objective_evidence in { - "", - "pending", - }: - return f"satisfied objective {objective_id} requires evidence" - if status == "Accepted" and objective_status != "satisfied": - return f"accepted plan has unsatisfied objective {objective_id}" - - final_acceptance = [ - match.group(1) - for line in lines - if (match := re.fullmatch(r"- Acceptance status: `([^`]*)`", line)) - ] - final_status = [ - match.group(1) - for line in lines - if (match := re.fullmatch(r"- Final status: `([^`]*)`", line)) - ] - if len(final_acceptance) > 1 or len(final_status) > 1: - return "final acceptance projections must be unique" - if status == "Accepted" and ( - len(final_acceptance) != 1 or len(final_status) != 1 - ): - return "accepted plan requires both final acceptance projections" - if final_acceptance and final_acceptance[0] != acceptance_status: - return "final acceptance status does not match header" - if final_status and final_status[0] != status: - return "final plan status does not match header" - - if status in {"Planned", "Active", "Blocked", "Implemented", "Verifying"}: - design_heading = "## Simplicity And Ownership Review" - if lines.count(design_heading) != 1: - return f"expected one {design_heading} heading" - design_lines = _section(content, design_heading) - applicability_lines = [ - line.removeprefix("**Applicability:** ").replace("`", "") - for line in design_lines - if line.startswith("**Applicability:** ") - ] - if len(applicability_lines) != 1: - return "composed-design review requires one Applicability field" - applicability = applicability_lines[0] - if applicability not in {"applicable", "not-applicable"}: - return f"invalid composed-design Applicability {applicability}" - if applicability == "not-applicable": - reasons = [ - line.removeprefix("**Reason:**").replace("`", "").strip() - for line in design_lines - if line.startswith("**Reason:**") - ] - if ( - len(reasons) != 1 - or not reasons[0] - or re.fullmatch(r"\[.*\]", reasons[0]) is not None - or reasons[0] in {"TBD", "pending"} - ): - return "not-applicable composed-design review requires a concrete Reason" - else: - for probe in DESIGN_PROBES: - prefix = f"- {probe}:" - answers = [ - line.removeprefix(prefix).replace("`", "").strip() - for line in design_lines - if line.startswith(prefix) - ] - if ( - len(answers) != 1 - or not answers[0] - or re.fullmatch(r"\[.*\]", answers[0]) is not None - or answers[0] in {"TBD", "pending"} - ): - return f"applicable composed-design review requires {probe}" - return None - - -@dataclass(frozen=True, slots=True) -class PlanContractCheck: - id: str - path: str - expected: str - message: str | None - - def authority_inputs( - self, context: CheckInputContext - ) -> tuple[CheckAuthorityInput, ...]: - return present_inputs("plan-contract", self.path) - - def run(self, context: CheckContext) -> list[Diagnostic]: - source = contained_file( - context.repo_root, - self.path, - suite=context.suite_id, - check=self.id, - ) - try: - observed = validate_plan(source.read_text(encoding="utf-8")) - except UnicodeError as error: - raise EngineError( - Diagnostic( - "INPUT.INVALID_UTF8", - "invalid", - str(error), - suite=context.suite_id, - check=self.id, - path=self.path, - ) - ) from error - if self.expected == "valid" and observed is not None: - return [ - Diagnostic( - "ASSERT.PLAN_CONTRACT", - "invalid", - observed, - suite=context.suite_id, - check=self.id, - path=self.path, - expected="valid", - observed="invalid", - ) - ] - if self.expected == "invalid" and observed is None: - return [ - Diagnostic( - "ASSERT.PLAN_CONTRACT", - "invalid", - "invalid plan fixture was accepted", - suite=context.suite_id, - check=self.id, - path=self.path, - expected="invalid", - observed="valid", - ) - ] - if ( - self.expected == "invalid" - and self.message is not None - and observed != self.message - ): - return [ - Diagnostic( - "ASSERT.PLAN_DIAGNOSTIC", - "invalid", - "invalid plan produced the wrong diagnostic", - suite=context.suite_id, - check=self.id, - path=self.path, - expected=self.message, - observed=observed, - ) - ] - return [] - - -def parse_plan_contract_check(raw: dict[str, Any], suite_id: str) -> PlanContractCheck: - allowed = {"id", "type", "path", "expected", "message"} - unknown = set(raw) - allowed - if unknown: - raise EngineError( - Diagnostic( - "CONFIG.UNKNOWN_FIELD", - "invalid", - "plan_contract check contains unknown fields", - suite=suite_id, - field=sorted(unknown)[0], - ) - ) - check_id = raw.get("id") - path = raw.get("path") - expected = raw.get("expected") - message = raw.get("message") - if type(check_id) is not str or not check_id: - raise EngineError( - Diagnostic( - "CONFIG.CHECK_ID", - "invalid", - "check id must be a non-empty string", - suite=suite_id, - ) - ) - if type(path) is not str or not path: - raise EngineError( - Diagnostic( - "CONFIG.PATH", - "invalid", - "path must be a non-empty string", - suite=suite_id, - check=check_id, - field="path", - ) - ) - if expected not in {"valid", "invalid"}: - raise EngineError( - Diagnostic( - "CONFIG.ENUM", - "invalid", - "expected must be valid or invalid", - suite=suite_id, - check=check_id, - field="expected", - ) - ) - if message is not None and (type(message) is not str or not message): - raise EngineError( - Diagnostic( - "CONFIG.STRING", - "invalid", - "message must be a non-empty string", - suite=suite_id, - check=check_id, - field="message", - ) - ) - if expected == "valid" and message is not None: - raise EngineError( - Diagnostic( - "CONFIG.CONTRADICTORY_EXPECTATION", - "invalid", - "valid plans cannot declare an invalid diagnostic", - suite=suite_id, - check=check_id, - field="message", - ) - ) - return PlanContractCheck(check_id, path, expected, message) diff --git a/tools/standards_verifier/tests/test_plan_contract.py b/tools/standards_verifier/tests/test_plan_contract.py deleted file mode 100644 index 641423c4..00000000 --- a/tools/standards_verifier/tests/test_plan_contract.py +++ /dev/null @@ -1,81 +0,0 @@ -from __future__ import annotations - -import sys -import unittest -from pathlib import Path - - -ENGINE_ROOT = Path(__file__).resolve().parents[1] -sys.path.insert(0, str(ENGINE_ROOT)) - -from standards_verifier.checks.plan_contract import ( # noqa: E402 - parse_plan_contract_check, - validate_plan, -) -from standards_verifier.diagnostics import EngineError # noqa: E402 - - -REPOSITORY_ROOT = Path(__file__).resolve().parents[3] -FIXTURES = REPOSITORY_ROOT / "evaluation/standards-effectiveness/fixtures/plans" - - -class PlanContractTest(unittest.TestCase): - def test_valid_fixtures_pass(self) -> None: - for path in sorted(FIXTURES.glob("valid-*.md")): - with self.subTest(path=path.name): - self.assertIsNone(validate_plan(path.read_text(encoding="utf-8"))) - - def test_invalid_fixtures_preserve_diagnostics(self) -> None: - expected = { - "invalid-accepted-malformed-objective-status.md": "objective A1 has invalid status satified", - "invalid-accepted-missing-final-projections.md": "accepted plan requires both final acceptance projections", - "invalid-accepted-pending-criterion.md": "accepted plan has unsatisfied objective A1", - "invalid-accepted-satisfied-without-evidence.md": "satisfied objective A1 requires evidence", - "invalid-duplicate-composed-design-probe.md": "applicable composed-design review requires Independent concepts and dimensions", - "invalid-execution-history.md": "execution history belongs in the ledger", - "invalid-headless-accepted.md": "accepted plan has partial acceptance", - "invalid-incomplete-composed-design-review.md": "applicable composed-design review requires Deletion and cumulative machinery result", - "invalid-missing-composed-design-applicability.md": "expected one ## Simplicity And Ownership Review heading", - "invalid-missing-next.md": "expected one Next slice field", - "invalid-objective-partial.md": "objective A1 has invalid status partial", - "invalid-three-state.md": "invalid plan status Complete", - "invalid-unreasoned-composed-design-exclusion.md": "not-applicable composed-design review requires a concrete Reason", - "invalid-whitespace-composed-design-probe.md": "applicable composed-design review requires Deletion and cumulative machinery result", - "invalid-whitespace-composed-design-reason.md": "not-applicable composed-design review requires a concrete Reason", - } - self.assertEqual( - {path.name for path in FIXTURES.glob("invalid-*.md")}, - set(expected), - ) - for name, message in expected.items(): - with self.subTest(path=name): - content = (FIXTURES / name).read_text(encoding="utf-8") - self.assertEqual(validate_plan(content), message) - - def test_parser_rejects_unknown_and_contradictory_configuration(self) -> None: - with self.assertRaises(EngineError): - parse_plan_contract_check( - { - "id": "plan", - "type": "plan_contract", - "path": "plan.md", - "expected": "valid", - "unknown": True, - }, - "suite", - ) - with self.assertRaises(EngineError): - parse_plan_contract_check( - { - "id": "plan", - "type": "plan_contract", - "path": "plan.md", - "expected": "valid", - "message": "must fail", - }, - "suite", - ) - - -if __name__ == "__main__": - unittest.main() From 2c2138ae204491c60437207cc0dfe38e3bf06fc3 Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: MrScripty Date: Fri, 13 Nov 2026 18:40:32 -0700 Subject: [PATCH 4/4] chore(evidence): retire the sample plans of the plan-layout validator The 19 files under evaluation/standards-effectiveness/fixtures/plans/ were the inputs of the plan_contract checks and of the validator's unit test. Both are gone, so nothing reads the samples any more. The files were removed by the Engine's maintain_evidence operation (preview, then apply) with retire_inputs, not by hand. The operation refuses an input a retained suite still uses; none did. No suite, catalogue node, relationship or certificate changes. This is a separate commit from the suite retirement so that the validator's unit test never ran without the samples it read. docs/audits/plan-format-check-removal-2026-11-13.md is the review record supplied to the operation. Co-Authored-By: Claude Fable 5.2 --- ...lid-accepted-malformed-objective-status.md | 46 --------------- ...alid-accepted-missing-final-projections.md | 45 -------------- .../invalid-accepted-pending-criterion.md | 46 --------------- ...lid-accepted-satisfied-without-evidence.md | 47 --------------- ...invalid-duplicate-composed-design-probe.md | 59 ------------------- .../plans/invalid-execution-history.md | 54 ----------------- .../plans/invalid-headless-accepted.md | 43 -------------- ...valid-incomplete-composed-design-review.md | 57 ------------------ ...d-missing-composed-design-applicability.md | 45 -------------- .../fixtures/plans/invalid-missing-next.md | 47 --------------- .../plans/invalid-objective-partial.md | 51 ---------------- .../fixtures/plans/invalid-three-state.md | 43 -------------- ...id-unreasoned-composed-design-exclusion.md | 49 --------------- ...nvalid-whitespace-composed-design-probe.md | 58 ------------------ ...valid-whitespace-composed-design-reason.md | 51 ---------------- .../fixtures/plans/valid-accepted.md | 47 --------------- .../fixtures/plans/valid-active.md | 58 ------------------ .../fixtures/plans/valid-blocked.md | 55 ----------------- .../fixtures/plans/valid-superseded.md | 45 -------------- .../generated/suite-inputs.json | 2 +- 20 files changed, 1 insertion(+), 947 deletions(-) delete mode 100644 evaluation/standards-effectiveness/fixtures/plans/invalid-accepted-malformed-objective-status.md delete mode 100644 evaluation/standards-effectiveness/fixtures/plans/invalid-accepted-missing-final-projections.md delete mode 100644 evaluation/standards-effectiveness/fixtures/plans/invalid-accepted-pending-criterion.md delete mode 100644 evaluation/standards-effectiveness/fixtures/plans/invalid-accepted-satisfied-without-evidence.md delete mode 100644 evaluation/standards-effectiveness/fixtures/plans/invalid-duplicate-composed-design-probe.md delete mode 100644 evaluation/standards-effectiveness/fixtures/plans/invalid-execution-history.md delete mode 100644 evaluation/standards-effectiveness/fixtures/plans/invalid-headless-accepted.md delete mode 100644 evaluation/standards-effectiveness/fixtures/plans/invalid-incomplete-composed-design-review.md delete mode 100644 evaluation/standards-effectiveness/fixtures/plans/invalid-missing-composed-design-applicability.md delete mode 100644 evaluation/standards-effectiveness/fixtures/plans/invalid-missing-next.md delete mode 100644 evaluation/standards-effectiveness/fixtures/plans/invalid-objective-partial.md delete mode 100644 evaluation/standards-effectiveness/fixtures/plans/invalid-three-state.md delete mode 100644 evaluation/standards-effectiveness/fixtures/plans/invalid-unreasoned-composed-design-exclusion.md delete mode 100644 evaluation/standards-effectiveness/fixtures/plans/invalid-whitespace-composed-design-probe.md delete mode 100644 evaluation/standards-effectiveness/fixtures/plans/invalid-whitespace-composed-design-reason.md delete mode 100644 evaluation/standards-effectiveness/fixtures/plans/valid-accepted.md delete mode 100644 evaluation/standards-effectiveness/fixtures/plans/valid-active.md delete mode 100644 evaluation/standards-effectiveness/fixtures/plans/valid-blocked.md delete mode 100644 evaluation/standards-effectiveness/fixtures/plans/valid-superseded.md diff --git a/evaluation/standards-effectiveness/fixtures/plans/invalid-accepted-malformed-objective-status.md b/evaluation/standards-effectiveness/fixtures/plans/invalid-accepted-malformed-objective-status.md deleted file mode 100644 index 63574d12..00000000 --- a/evaluation/standards-effectiveness/fixtures/plans/invalid-accepted-malformed-objective-status.md +++ /dev/null @@ -1,46 +0,0 @@ -# Plan: Invalid Accepted Malformed Objective Status - -**Plan status:** `Accepted` - -**Current phase:** Complete - -**Next slice:** `none` - -**Acceptance status:** `satisfied` - -**Execution ledger:** [execution-ledger.md](execution-ledger.md) - -**Issues:** [issues.md](issues.md) - -## Objective - -Deliver the workflow. - -## Objective Acceptance - -| ID | Observable criterion | Kind | Environment | Mode | Status | Evidence | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| A1 | The workflow is complete. | `integration` | `not-applicable` | `automated` | `satified` | Evidence | - -## Binding Decisions - -- The table is authoritative. - -## Milestones - -### Milestone 0: Workflow - -**Status:** `Accepted` - -## Blockers - -- `none` - -## Re-Plan Triggers - -- `none` - -## Final Acceptance - -- Acceptance status: `satisfied` -- Final status: `Accepted` diff --git a/evaluation/standards-effectiveness/fixtures/plans/invalid-accepted-missing-final-projections.md b/evaluation/standards-effectiveness/fixtures/plans/invalid-accepted-missing-final-projections.md deleted file mode 100644 index 901922b9..00000000 --- a/evaluation/standards-effectiveness/fixtures/plans/invalid-accepted-missing-final-projections.md +++ /dev/null @@ -1,45 +0,0 @@ -# Plan: Invalid Accepted Missing Final Projections - -**Plan status:** `Accepted` - -**Current phase:** Complete - -**Next slice:** `none` - -**Acceptance status:** `satisfied` - -**Execution ledger:** [execution-ledger.md](execution-ledger.md) - -**Issues:** [issues.md](issues.md) - -## Objective - -Deliver the workflow. - -## Objective Acceptance - -| ID | Observable criterion | Kind | Environment | Mode | Status | Evidence | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| A1 | The workflow is complete. | `integration` | `not-applicable` | `automated` | `satisfied` | Evidence | - -## Binding Decisions - -- The table is authoritative. - -## Milestones - -### Milestone 0: Workflow - -**Status:** `Accepted` - -## Blockers - -- `none` - -## Re-Plan Triggers - -- `none` - -## Final Acceptance - -- Objective evidence: `reports/user-workflow.md` diff --git a/evaluation/standards-effectiveness/fixtures/plans/invalid-accepted-pending-criterion.md b/evaluation/standards-effectiveness/fixtures/plans/invalid-accepted-pending-criterion.md deleted file mode 100644 index 11b60208..00000000 --- a/evaluation/standards-effectiveness/fixtures/plans/invalid-accepted-pending-criterion.md +++ /dev/null @@ -1,46 +0,0 @@ -# Plan: Invalid Accepted Pending Criterion - -**Plan status:** `Accepted` - -**Current phase:** Complete - -**Next slice:** `none` - -**Acceptance status:** `satisfied` - -**Execution ledger:** [execution-ledger.md](execution-ledger.md) - -**Issues:** [issues.md](issues.md) - -## Objective - -Deliver the workflow. - -## Objective Acceptance - -| ID | Observable criterion | Kind | Environment | Mode | Status | Evidence | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| A1 | The workflow is complete. | `integration` | `not-applicable` | `automated` | `pending` | Missing | - -## Binding Decisions - -- The table is authoritative. - -## Milestones - -### Milestone 0: Workflow - -**Status:** `Accepted` - -## Blockers - -- `none` - -## Re-Plan Triggers - -- `none` - -## Final Acceptance - -- Acceptance status: `satisfied` -- Final status: `Accepted` diff --git a/evaluation/standards-effectiveness/fixtures/plans/invalid-accepted-satisfied-without-evidence.md b/evaluation/standards-effectiveness/fixtures/plans/invalid-accepted-satisfied-without-evidence.md deleted file mode 100644 index bb9f7ca1..00000000 --- a/evaluation/standards-effectiveness/fixtures/plans/invalid-accepted-satisfied-without-evidence.md +++ /dev/null @@ -1,47 +0,0 @@ -# Plan: Accepted Without Objective Evidence - -**Plan status:** `Accepted` - -**Current phase:** Complete - -**Next slice:** `none` - -**Acceptance status:** `satisfied` - -**Execution ledger:** [execution-ledger.md](execution-ledger.md) - -**Issues:** [issues.md](issues.md) - -## Objective - -Deliver the workflow. - -## Objective Acceptance - -| ID | Observable criterion | Kind | Environment | Mode | Status | Evidence | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| A1 | The workflow is complete. | `user-workflow` | `not-applicable` | `automated` | `satisfied` | | - -## Binding Decisions - -- The workflow owns its visible acceptance evidence. - -## Milestones - -### Milestone 0: Workflow - -**Status:** `Accepted` - -## Blockers - -- `none` - -## Re-Plan Triggers - -- `none` - -## Final Acceptance - -- Objective evidence: `reports/workflow.md` -- Acceptance status: `satisfied` -- Final status: `Accepted` diff --git a/evaluation/standards-effectiveness/fixtures/plans/invalid-duplicate-composed-design-probe.md b/evaluation/standards-effectiveness/fixtures/plans/invalid-duplicate-composed-design-probe.md deleted file mode 100644 index 0d7b6e46..00000000 --- a/evaluation/standards-effectiveness/fixtures/plans/invalid-duplicate-composed-design-probe.md +++ /dev/null @@ -1,59 +0,0 @@ -# Plan: Duplicate Composed-Design Probe - -**Plan status:** `Active` - -**Current phase:** Milestone 0 - -**Next slice:** Implement the admitted change. - -**Acceptance status:** `pending` - -**Execution ledger:** [execution-ledger.md](execution-ledger.md) - -**Issues:** [issues.md](issues.md) - -## Objective - -Deliver one valid change. - -## Objective Acceptance - -| ID | Observable criterion | Kind | Environment | Mode | Status | Evidence | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| A1 | Focused evidence passes. | `contract` | `not-applicable` | `automated` | `pending` | `pending` | - -## Binding Decisions - -- One Module owns the change. - -## Simplicity And Ownership Review - -**Applicability:** `applicable` - -- Independent concepts and dimensions: Parsing and validation remain distinct. -- Independent concepts and dimensions: Parsing and validation must always change together. -- State, identity, value, time, policy, and mechanism: Policy is contained by one owner. -- Caller and composition-root knowledge: Callers know only the public Interface. -- Representative change paths and forced owners: A representative policy change reaches one owner. -- Stable Interfaces versus hidden knowledge: The stable Interface hides representation. -- Independent evolution, testing, failure, and replacement: The owner can evolve and fail independently. -- Necessary complexity and containment: Necessary policy is contained by the owning Module. -- Deletion and cumulative machinery result: Deletion redistributes necessary policy to callers. - -## Milestones - -### Milestone 0: Change - -**Status:** `Active` - -## Blockers - -- `none` - -## Re-Plan Triggers - -- Ownership changes. - -## Final Acceptance - -- Objective evidence: `pending` diff --git a/evaluation/standards-effectiveness/fixtures/plans/invalid-execution-history.md b/evaluation/standards-effectiveness/fixtures/plans/invalid-execution-history.md deleted file mode 100644 index dd34bb6b..00000000 --- a/evaluation/standards-effectiveness/fixtures/plans/invalid-execution-history.md +++ /dev/null @@ -1,54 +0,0 @@ -# Plan: Invalid Embedded History - -**Plan status:** `Active` - -**Current phase:** Milestone 0 - -**Next slice:** Continue implementation. - -**Acceptance status:** `pending` - -**Execution ledger:** [execution-ledger.md](execution-ledger.md) - -**Issues:** [issues.md](issues.md) - -## Objective - -Demonstrate embedded history rejection. - -## Objective Acceptance - -Focused evidence passes. - -## Binding Decisions - -- Plan should remain current. - -## Simplicity And Ownership Review - -**Applicability:** `not-applicable` - -**Reason:** This fixture isolates embedded execution-history rejection and admits no composed software design. - -## Milestones - -### Milestone 0: Invalid - -**Status:** `Active` - -## Execution Notes - -- 2026-07-01: ran a command. -- 2026-07-02: ran another command. - -## Blockers - -- `none` - -## Re-Plan Triggers - -- `none` - -## Final Acceptance - -- Objective evidence: `pending` diff --git a/evaluation/standards-effectiveness/fixtures/plans/invalid-headless-accepted.md b/evaluation/standards-effectiveness/fixtures/plans/invalid-headless-accepted.md deleted file mode 100644 index b4db1d5f..00000000 --- a/evaluation/standards-effectiveness/fixtures/plans/invalid-headless-accepted.md +++ /dev/null @@ -1,43 +0,0 @@ -# Plan: Invalid Headless Acceptance - -**Plan status:** `Accepted` - -**Current phase:** Complete - -**Next slice:** `none` - -**Acceptance status:** `partial` - -**Execution ledger:** [execution-ledger.md](execution-ledger.md) - -**Issues:** [issues.md](issues.md) - -## Objective - -Deliver a user workflow. - -## Objective Acceptance - -Focused backend test passes. - -## Binding Decisions - -- Headless evidence is treated as complete. - -## Milestones - -### Milestone 0: Backend - -**Status:** `Accepted` - -## Blockers - -- `none` - -## Re-Plan Triggers - -- `none` - -## Final Acceptance - -- Objective evidence: `reports/focused-test.md` diff --git a/evaluation/standards-effectiveness/fixtures/plans/invalid-incomplete-composed-design-review.md b/evaluation/standards-effectiveness/fixtures/plans/invalid-incomplete-composed-design-review.md deleted file mode 100644 index 23503667..00000000 --- a/evaluation/standards-effectiveness/fixtures/plans/invalid-incomplete-composed-design-review.md +++ /dev/null @@ -1,57 +0,0 @@ -# Plan: Incomplete Composed-Design Review - -**Plan status:** `Active` - -**Current phase:** Milestone 0 - -**Next slice:** Implement the admitted change. - -**Acceptance status:** `pending` - -**Execution ledger:** [execution-ledger.md](execution-ledger.md) - -**Issues:** [issues.md](issues.md) - -## Objective - -Deliver one valid change. - -## Objective Acceptance - -| ID | Observable criterion | Kind | Environment | Mode | Status | Evidence | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| A1 | Focused evidence passes. | `contract` | `not-applicable` | `automated` | `pending` | `pending` | - -## Binding Decisions - -- One Module owns the change. - -## Simplicity And Ownership Review - -**Applicability:** `applicable` - -- Independent concepts and dimensions: Parsing and validation remain distinct. -- State, identity, value, time, policy, and mechanism: Policy is contained by one owner. -- Caller and composition-root knowledge: Callers know only the public Interface. -- Representative change paths and forced owners: A representative policy change reaches one owner. -- Stable Interfaces versus hidden knowledge: The stable Interface hides representation. -- Independent evolution, testing, failure, and replacement: The owner can evolve and fail independently. -- Necessary complexity and containment: Necessary policy is contained by the owning Module. - -## Milestones - -### Milestone 0: Change - -**Status:** `Active` - -## Blockers - -- `none` - -## Re-Plan Triggers - -- Ownership changes. - -## Final Acceptance - -- Objective evidence: `pending` diff --git a/evaluation/standards-effectiveness/fixtures/plans/invalid-missing-composed-design-applicability.md b/evaluation/standards-effectiveness/fixtures/plans/invalid-missing-composed-design-applicability.md deleted file mode 100644 index 3bb61924..00000000 --- a/evaluation/standards-effectiveness/fixtures/plans/invalid-missing-composed-design-applicability.md +++ /dev/null @@ -1,45 +0,0 @@ -# Plan: Missing Composed-Design Applicability - -**Plan status:** `Active` - -**Current phase:** Milestone 0 - -**Next slice:** Implement the admitted change. - -**Acceptance status:** `pending` - -**Execution ledger:** [execution-ledger.md](execution-ledger.md) - -**Issues:** [issues.md](issues.md) - -## Objective - -Deliver one valid change. - -## Objective Acceptance - -| ID | Observable criterion | Kind | Environment | Mode | Status | Evidence | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| A1 | Focused evidence passes. | `contract` | `not-applicable` | `automated` | `pending` | `pending` | - -## Binding Decisions - -- One Module owns the change. - -## Milestones - -### Milestone 0: Change - -**Status:** `Active` - -## Blockers - -- `none` - -## Re-Plan Triggers - -- Ownership changes. - -## Final Acceptance - -- Objective evidence: `pending` diff --git a/evaluation/standards-effectiveness/fixtures/plans/invalid-missing-next.md b/evaluation/standards-effectiveness/fixtures/plans/invalid-missing-next.md deleted file mode 100644 index 170a1a1f..00000000 --- a/evaluation/standards-effectiveness/fixtures/plans/invalid-missing-next.md +++ /dev/null @@ -1,47 +0,0 @@ -# Plan: Invalid Missing Next Slice - -**Plan status:** `Active` - -**Current phase:** Milestone 0 - -**Acceptance status:** `pending` - -**Execution ledger:** [execution-ledger.md](execution-ledger.md) - -**Issues:** [issues.md](issues.md) - -## Objective - -Demonstrate missing next slice. - -## Objective Acceptance - -Focused evidence passes. - -## Binding Decisions - -- Fixture intentionally omits a next slice. - -## Simplicity And Ownership Review - -**Applicability:** `not-applicable` - -**Reason:** This fixture isolates next-slice validation and admits no composed software design. - -## Milestones - -### Milestone 0: Invalid - -**Status:** `Active` - -## Blockers - -- `none` - -## Re-Plan Triggers - -- `none` - -## Final Acceptance - -- Objective evidence: `pending` diff --git a/evaluation/standards-effectiveness/fixtures/plans/invalid-objective-partial.md b/evaluation/standards-effectiveness/fixtures/plans/invalid-objective-partial.md deleted file mode 100644 index a36612d8..00000000 --- a/evaluation/standards-effectiveness/fixtures/plans/invalid-objective-partial.md +++ /dev/null @@ -1,51 +0,0 @@ -# Plan: Partial Objective - -**Plan status:** `Active` - -**Current phase:** Milestone 0 - -**Next slice:** Finish the objective. - -**Acceptance status:** `pending` - -**Execution ledger:** [execution-ledger.md](execution-ledger.md) - -**Issues:** [issues.md](issues.md) - -## Objective - -Deliver one complete contract. - -## Objective Acceptance - -| ID | Observable criterion | Kind | Environment | Mode | Status | Evidence | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| A1 | The contract is complete. | `contract` | `not-applicable` | `automated` | `partial` | `reports/partial.md` | - -## Binding Decisions - -- The parser owns objective status validation. - -## Simplicity And Ownership Review - -**Applicability:** `not-applicable` - -**Reason:** This fixture isolates objective-state validation and admits no composed software design. - -## Milestones - -### Milestone 0: Contract - -**Status:** `Active` - -## Blockers - -- `none` - -## Re-Plan Triggers - -- `none` - -## Final Acceptance - -- Objective evidence: `pending` diff --git a/evaluation/standards-effectiveness/fixtures/plans/invalid-three-state.md b/evaluation/standards-effectiveness/fixtures/plans/invalid-three-state.md deleted file mode 100644 index a4181b83..00000000 --- a/evaluation/standards-effectiveness/fixtures/plans/invalid-three-state.md +++ /dev/null @@ -1,43 +0,0 @@ -# Plan: Invalid Three-State Fixture - -**Plan status:** `Complete` - -**Current phase:** Complete - -**Next slice:** `none` - -**Acceptance status:** `pending` - -**Execution ledger:** [execution-ledger.md](execution-ledger.md) - -**Issues:** [issues.md](issues.md) - -## Objective - -Demonstrate invalid status. - -## Objective Acceptance - -Focused evidence passes. - -## Binding Decisions - -- Old status vocabulary is retained. - -## Milestones - -### Milestone 0: Old state - -**Status:** `Complete` - -## Blockers - -- `none` - -## Re-Plan Triggers - -- `none` - -## Final Acceptance - -- Objective evidence: `reports/focused.md` diff --git a/evaluation/standards-effectiveness/fixtures/plans/invalid-unreasoned-composed-design-exclusion.md b/evaluation/standards-effectiveness/fixtures/plans/invalid-unreasoned-composed-design-exclusion.md deleted file mode 100644 index bf1b59ad..00000000 --- a/evaluation/standards-effectiveness/fixtures/plans/invalid-unreasoned-composed-design-exclusion.md +++ /dev/null @@ -1,49 +0,0 @@ -# Plan: Unreasoned Composed-Design Exclusion - -**Plan status:** `Active` - -**Current phase:** Milestone 0 - -**Next slice:** Implement the admitted change. - -**Acceptance status:** `pending` - -**Execution ledger:** [execution-ledger.md](execution-ledger.md) - -**Issues:** [issues.md](issues.md) - -## Objective - -Deliver one valid change. - -## Objective Acceptance - -| ID | Observable criterion | Kind | Environment | Mode | Status | Evidence | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| A1 | Focused evidence passes. | `contract` | `not-applicable` | `automated` | `pending` | `pending` | - -## Binding Decisions - -- One Module owns the change. - -## Simplicity And Ownership Review - -**Applicability:** `not-applicable` - -## Milestones - -### Milestone 0: Change - -**Status:** `Active` - -## Blockers - -- `none` - -## Re-Plan Triggers - -- Ownership changes. - -## Final Acceptance - -- Objective evidence: `pending` diff --git a/evaluation/standards-effectiveness/fixtures/plans/invalid-whitespace-composed-design-probe.md b/evaluation/standards-effectiveness/fixtures/plans/invalid-whitespace-composed-design-probe.md deleted file mode 100644 index 1f15477e..00000000 --- a/evaluation/standards-effectiveness/fixtures/plans/invalid-whitespace-composed-design-probe.md +++ /dev/null @@ -1,58 +0,0 @@ -# Plan: Whitespace Composed-Design Probe - -**Plan status:** `Active` - -**Current phase:** Milestone 0 - -**Next slice:** Implement the admitted change. - -**Acceptance status:** `pending` - -**Execution ledger:** [execution-ledger.md](execution-ledger.md) - -**Issues:** [issues.md](issues.md) - -## Objective - -Deliver one valid change. - -## Objective Acceptance - -| ID | Observable criterion | Kind | Environment | Mode | Status | Evidence | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| A1 | Focused evidence passes. | `contract` | `not-applicable` | `automated` | `pending` | `pending` | - -## Binding Decisions - -- One Module owns the change. - -## Simplicity And Ownership Review - -**Applicability:** `applicable` - -- Independent concepts and dimensions: Parsing and validation remain distinct. -- State, identity, value, time, policy, and mechanism: Policy is contained by one owner. -- Caller and composition-root knowledge: Callers know only the public Interface. -- Representative change paths and forced owners: A representative policy change reaches one owner. -- Stable Interfaces versus hidden knowledge: The stable Interface hides representation. -- Independent evolution, testing, failure, and replacement: The owner can evolve and fail independently. -- Necessary complexity and containment: Necessary policy is contained by the owning Module. -- Deletion and cumulative machinery result: ` ` - -## Milestones - -### Milestone 0: Change - -**Status:** `Active` - -## Blockers - -- `none` - -## Re-Plan Triggers - -- Ownership changes. - -## Final Acceptance - -- Objective evidence: `pending` diff --git a/evaluation/standards-effectiveness/fixtures/plans/invalid-whitespace-composed-design-reason.md b/evaluation/standards-effectiveness/fixtures/plans/invalid-whitespace-composed-design-reason.md deleted file mode 100644 index dfa7c944..00000000 --- a/evaluation/standards-effectiveness/fixtures/plans/invalid-whitespace-composed-design-reason.md +++ /dev/null @@ -1,51 +0,0 @@ -# Plan: Whitespace Composed-Design Reason - -**Plan status:** `Active` - -**Current phase:** Milestone 0 - -**Next slice:** Implement the admitted change. - -**Acceptance status:** `pending` - -**Execution ledger:** [execution-ledger.md](execution-ledger.md) - -**Issues:** [issues.md](issues.md) - -## Objective - -Deliver one valid change. - -## Objective Acceptance - -| ID | Observable criterion | Kind | Environment | Mode | Status | Evidence | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| A1 | Focused evidence passes. | `contract` | `not-applicable` | `automated` | `pending` | `pending` | - -## Binding Decisions - -- One Module owns the change. - -## Simplicity And Ownership Review - -**Applicability:** `not-applicable` - -**Reason:** ` ` - -## Milestones - -### Milestone 0: Change - -**Status:** `Active` - -## Blockers - -- `none` - -## Re-Plan Triggers - -- Ownership changes. - -## Final Acceptance - -- Objective evidence: `pending` diff --git a/evaluation/standards-effectiveness/fixtures/plans/valid-accepted.md b/evaluation/standards-effectiveness/fixtures/plans/valid-accepted.md deleted file mode 100644 index 547cf84c..00000000 --- a/evaluation/standards-effectiveness/fixtures/plans/valid-accepted.md +++ /dev/null @@ -1,47 +0,0 @@ -# Plan: Accepted Fixture - -**Plan status:** `Accepted` - -**Current phase:** Complete - -**Next slice:** `none` - -**Acceptance status:** `satisfied` - -**Execution ledger:** [execution-ledger.md](execution-ledger.md) - -**Issues:** [issues.md](issues.md) - -## Objective - -Deliver the workflow through the user interface. - -## Objective Acceptance - -| ID | Observable criterion | Kind | Environment | Mode | Status | Evidence | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| A1 | Recorded user interaction reaches the visible result. | `user-workflow` | `not-applicable` | `automated` | `satisfied` | `reports/user-workflow.md` | - -## Binding Decisions - -- Backend owns policy; frontend owns projection. - -## Milestones - -### Milestone 0: Workflow - -**Status:** `Accepted` - -## Blockers - -- `none` - -## Re-Plan Triggers - -- `none` - -## Final Acceptance - -- Objective evidence: `reports/user-workflow.md` -- Acceptance status: `satisfied` -- Final status: `Accepted` diff --git a/evaluation/standards-effectiveness/fixtures/plans/valid-active.md b/evaluation/standards-effectiveness/fixtures/plans/valid-active.md deleted file mode 100644 index 8bb0bb8f..00000000 --- a/evaluation/standards-effectiveness/fixtures/plans/valid-active.md +++ /dev/null @@ -1,58 +0,0 @@ -# Plan: Active Fixture - -**Plan status:** `Active` - -**Current phase:** Milestone 0 - -**Next slice:** Implement the focused parser correction. - -**Acceptance status:** `pending` - -**Execution ledger:** [execution-ledger.md](execution-ledger.md) - -**Issues:** [issues.md](issues.md) - -## Objective - -Reject empty identifiers. - -## Objective Acceptance - -| ID | Observable criterion | Kind | Environment | Mode | Status | Evidence | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| A1 | Focused regression test rejects an empty identifier. | `contract` | `not-applicable` | `automated` | `pending` | `pending` | - -## Binding Decisions - -- Parser owns identifier validation. - -## Simplicity And Ownership Review - -**Applicability:** `applicable` - -- Independent concepts and dimensions: Parsing and identifier validation remain distinct but composed through one parser Interface. -- State, identity, value, time, policy, and mechanism: Identifier value policy is contained by the parser and introduces no state or time coupling. -- Caller and composition-root knowledge: Callers provide source text and do not know identifier-validation mechanics. -- Representative change paths and forced owners: Changing the empty-identifier rule changes only parser-owned validation and its focused evidence. -- Stable Interfaces versus hidden knowledge: The parser Interface hides identifier representation and validation ordering. -- Independent evolution, testing, failure, and replacement: The validation rule can be tested and replaced without changing callers. -- Necessary complexity and containment: The single validation branch is necessary and contained in the parser Module. -- Deletion and cumulative machinery result: No pass-through owner or duplicate verifier remains after the correction. - -## Milestones - -### Milestone 0: Parser - -**Status:** `Active` - -## Blockers - -- `none` - -## Re-Plan Triggers - -- Validation is owned by a different boundary. - -## Final Acceptance - -- Objective evidence: `pending` diff --git a/evaluation/standards-effectiveness/fixtures/plans/valid-blocked.md b/evaluation/standards-effectiveness/fixtures/plans/valid-blocked.md deleted file mode 100644 index c93d8b9e..00000000 --- a/evaluation/standards-effectiveness/fixtures/plans/valid-blocked.md +++ /dev/null @@ -1,55 +0,0 @@ -# Plan: Blocked Fixture - -**Plan status:** `Blocked` - -**Current phase:** Hardware acceptance - -**Next slice:** Run the user workflow on the required device. - -**Acceptance status:** `blocked` - -**Execution ledger:** [execution-ledger.md](execution-ledger.md) - -**Issues:** [issues.md](issues.md) - -## Objective - -Deliver a hardware-backed user capability. - -## Objective Acceptance - -| ID | Observable criterion | Kind | Environment | Mode | Status | Evidence | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| A1 | Recorded real-device workflow succeeds. | `user-workflow` | `required-device` | `manual` | `blocked` | `pending` | - -## Binding Decisions - -- Simulation cannot accept the hardware objective. - -## Simplicity And Ownership Review - -**Applicability:** `not-applicable` - -**Reason:** This fixture records lifecycle behavior for an unavailable external device and admits no composed software design. - -## Milestones - -### Milestone 0: Headless path - -**Status:** `Implemented` - -### Milestone 1: Hardware path - -**Status:** `Blocked` - -## Blockers - -- Required device is unavailable. - -## Re-Plan Triggers - -- Supported hardware contract changes. - -## Final Acceptance - -- Objective evidence: `pending` diff --git a/evaluation/standards-effectiveness/fixtures/plans/valid-superseded.md b/evaluation/standards-effectiveness/fixtures/plans/valid-superseded.md deleted file mode 100644 index a03f6eee..00000000 --- a/evaluation/standards-effectiveness/fixtures/plans/valid-superseded.md +++ /dev/null @@ -1,45 +0,0 @@ -# Plan: Superseded Fixture - -**Plan status:** `Superseded` - -**Current phase:** Superseded - -**Next slice:** `none` - -**Acceptance status:** `partial` - -**Execution ledger:** [execution-ledger.md](execution-ledger.md) - -**Issues:** [issues.md](issues.md) - -## Objective - -Replace a contract. - -## Objective Acceptance - -| ID | Observable criterion | Kind | Environment | Mode | Status | Evidence | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| A1 | Producer and consumer contract evidence passes. | `contract` | `not-applicable` | `automated` | `pending` | `superseded by plan-v2.md` | - -## Binding Decisions - -- A newer plan owns the replacement. - -## Milestones - -### Milestone 0: Prior approach - -**Status:** `Superseded` - -## Blockers - -- `none` - -## Re-Plan Triggers - -- `none` - -## Final Acceptance - -- Objective evidence: `superseded by plan-v2.md` diff --git a/evaluation/standards-effectiveness/generated/suite-inputs.json b/evaluation/standards-effectiveness/generated/suite-inputs.json index 94096327..29ee2ce7 100644 --- a/evaluation/standards-effectiveness/generated/suite-inputs.json +++ b/evaluation/standards-effectiveness/generated/suite-inputs.json @@ -10269,7 +10269,7 @@ "path": "evaluation/standards-effectiveness/suite-registry.toml" }, "repository_index": { - "digest": "sha256:52d4a6d19cf74204f2651085cc1000ecd321debe1c8bb5fe075692c97710e7ff", + "digest": "sha256:89a3057e43de98bf31d34407b70f744a5f96d1eaa3b45b9a63ce5084be447267", "uses": [ { "check": "python-package-contract",